No. 00-07
Law Enforcement and School Authorities Sharing of Information
Cite as Colo. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 00-07
Barbara McDonnell
Chief Deputy Attorney General
ALAN J. GILBERT
Solicitor General
K
e n S a l a z a r
Attorney General
STATE OF COLORADO
DEPARTMENT OF LAW
Office of the Attorney General
State Services Building
1525 Sherman Street - 5th Floor
Denver, Colorado 80203
Phone (303) 866-4500
FAX (303) 866-5691
FORMAL
)
OPINION
)
)
Of
)
)
KEN SALAZAR
)
Attorney General
)
No. 00-7
Law Enforcement and School
Authorities Sharing of Information
Alpha No. LW CJAGBAI
Issued August 3, 2000
This opinion sets forth guidelines for schools and law enforcement agencies about
information that can be exchanged between law enforcement and school authorities. It is meant
to present and clarify these complex issues.
Recent statutory changes have greatly expanded the ability of school districts and law
enforcement agencies to cooperate in the transmission and sharing of information. Juvenile
justice agencies are now required to provide schools with basic identification information
whenever a student is charged in any court with committing a crime of violence or unlawful
sexual offense; arrest and criminal records information whenever a delinquency petition is filed
in juvenile court; notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for an offense
constituting a crime of violence involving controlled substances or unlawful sexual behavior;
notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for a crime that would result in mandatory
expulsion proceedings under Colorado law; and notice whenever a court makes school
attendance a condition of release, probation, or sentencing. Moreover, law enforcement agencies
may now, upon request, provide certain school officials access to records or information on
students which are maintained by the judicial department or any agency that performs duties with
respect to delinquency or dependency and neglect matters, when the information is required to
perform the school officials’ legal duties and responsibilities.
This includes information or
records of threats made by the student, arrest or charging information, records relating to the
adjudication or conviction of a child for a misdemeanor or felony, court records in juvenile
delinquency proceedings, and probation officer, law enforcement, and parole records.
School districts are now required to provide the following information upon request from
law enforcement authorities: truancy, disciplinary, and attendance records; reports of incidents on
school grounds involving assault or harassment of a teacher or school employee; and notification of
failure of a student to attend school, if school attendance is a condition of that student’s sentence or
release. However, the disclosure of student information must comply with the provisions of the
federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (“FERPA”). School officials may also disclose
personally identifiable student information with the consent of the student’s parents if the
information falls under the category of “directory information,” if the records are of the school’s
own “law enforcement unit,” or in an emergency if knowledge of the information is necessary to
protect the health or safety of the student or of other individuals.
QUESTIONS PRESENTED AND CONCLUSIONS
ISSUE 1: Under Colorado law, what information must law enforcement officials provide to
school authorities concerning students enrolled in schools?
ANSWER 1: Law enforcement must provide schools the following information: (1) basic
identification information whenever a student is charged with committing a crime of violence or
unlawful sexual offense; (2) arrest and criminal records information whenever a delinquency
petition is filed in juvenile court; (3) notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for an
offense involving a crime of violence, illegal use of controlled substances, or unlawful sexual
behavior; (4) notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for a crime that would result
in mandatory expulsion proceedings under Colorado law (i.e., while on school grounds,
possessing a dangerous weapon, sale of drugs, robbery, or first or second degree assault); and (5)
notice whenever a court makes school attendance a condition of release, probation, or
sentencing.
ISSUE 2: Under Colorado law, what other information may law enforcement authorities share
with school authorities concerning students enrolled in schools?
ANSWER 2: Upon request of school personnel, law enforcement authorities may share with
school authorities records or information on students maintained by the judicial department or
any agency that performs duties with respect to delinquency or dependency and neglect matters,
when the information is required to perform the school officials’ legal duties and responsibilities.
The information shared may include information or records of threats made by the student, arrest
or charging information, records relating to the adjudication or conviction of a child for a
misdemeanor or felony, court records in juvenile delinquency proceedings, and probation officer,
law enforcement, and parole records.
ISSUE 3: What information concerning students must school officials provide to law enforcement
agencies under Colorado and federal law?
ANSWER 3: Upon request from law enforcement personnel, school officials must provide the
following information to law enforcement agencies: truancy, disciplinary and attendance records;
reports of incidents on school grounds involving assault or harassment of a teacher or school
employee; and notification of failure of a student to attend school, if school attendance is a condition
of that student’s sentence or release. These disclosures of student information must comply with
FERPA.
ISSUE 4: What student information are school authorities permitted, but not required, to provide
law enforcement authorities under Colorado and federal law?
ANSWER 4: Permissible disclosure of information to law enforcement is governed by FERPA.
Generally, personally identifiable student information may be disclosed with the consent of the
-2 -
student’s parents, if he or she is over 18, with the consent of the student. Personally identifiable
student information may also be disclosed if it falls under the category of “directory information”
(i.e., the student’s name, address, telephone number, etc., if such information has been
designated as directory information by the school in accordance with law); if the records are of
the school’s own “law enforcement unit”; or in an emergency if knowledge of the information is
necessary to protect the health or safety of the student or of other individuals.
BACKGROUND
The Colorado legislature enacted laws in the 2000 term of the General Assembly
governing the sharing of information between law enforcement agencies and schools.
Senate Bill 133 requires school boards to establish written policies for reporting criminal
activity occurring on school property to the District Attorney or a law enforcement agency, and
provides for the greater exchange of information between school districts and law enforcement.
Greater exchange of information between schools and law enforcement agencies is also
authorized by House Bill 1119. These new enactments also require boards of education to
cooperate with law enforcement, and to the extent possible, to develop and implement written
agreements with law enforcement officials, the juvenile justice system, and social services, as
allowed under state and federal law, to keep each school environment safe.
Section 22-32-
109.1(3), C.R.S. (2000).
ANALYSIS
Issue 1: Under Colorado law, what information must law enforcement officials provide to
school authorities concerning students enrolled in schools?
A.
Crimes of Violence and Sex Offenses
Whenever a student between the ages of 12 and 18 is charged with committing an offense
constituting a crime of violence or unlawful sexual behavior, basic identification information
concerning the student and details of the alleged offense must be forwarded by the juvenile
justice agency (defined as the investigating police agency, prosecuting attorney’s office, or court)
to the school district in which the student is enrolled.
Sections 22-33-105(5)(a), and 19-1-
304(5), C.R.S. (2000). For purposes of this reporting requirement, a “crime of violence” means
any of the following crimes if the student, during the commission of the crime, used, or
possessed and threatened the use of, a deadly weapon, or caused serious bodily injury or death to
any person: (1) any crime against an at-risk adult or at-risk juvenile; (2) murder; (3) first or
second degree assault;
(4) kidnapping;
(5) sexual assault; (6) aggravated robbery; (7) first
degree arson; (8) first degree burglary; (9) escape; or (10) criminal extortion.
A “crime of
violence” also includes any unlawful sexual offense in which the student caused bodily injury to
the victim, or in which the student used threat, intimidation or force against the victim. Section
16-11-309(2), C.R.S. (2000).
- 3 -
For purposes of this reporting requirement, “unlawful sexual behavior” means any of the
following crimes: (1) sexual assault in the first, second or third degree; (2) sexual assault on a
child; (3) sexual assault on a child by one in a position of trust; (4) enticement of a child; (5)
incest; (6) aggravated incest; (7) trafficking in children; (8) sexual exploitation of children; (9)
procurement of a child for sexual exploitation; (10) indecent exposure; (11) soliciting for child
prostitution; (12) pandering of a child; (13) procurement of a child; (14) keeping a place of child
prostitution; (15) pimping of a child; (16) inducement of child prostitution; or (17) patronizing a
prostituted child. Section 18-3-412.5(l)(b), C.R.S. (2000).
Upon receipt of the information outlined above, the district’s board of education or its
designee is required to make a determination regarding whether the student’s behavior is
detrimental to the safety, welfare, and morals of the other students or of school personnel, and
whether educating the student in the school may disrupt the learning environment, provide a
negative example for other students, or create a dangerous and unsafe environment for students,
teachers, and other school personnel.
If the board of education determines that the student
should not be educated in the school, it may then proceed with its suspension or expulsion
procedures.
Alternatively, the board of education may decide to wait until the conclusion of the
delinquency or criminal proceedings to consider the expulsion matter and to provide the student
with an appropriate alternative education program of the board’s choosing, such as an on-line
program or home-based education program, while the juvenile proceedings are pending.
However, no student being educated in an alternative education program shall be allowed to
return to the education program in the public school until there has been a disposition of the
charge. Should the student plead or be found guilty, or be otherwise adjudicated a delinquent
juvenile or convicted, the school district may proceed to expel the student. Sections.22-33-
105(5)(a) and (b), C.R.S. (2000). Other than using the information obtained through section 22-
33-105(5), C.R.S. (2000) in accord with its stated purpose, this information. must remain
confidential unless otherwise made available to the public by operation of law. Sections 22-33-
105(5)(a) and 19-1-304(5), C.R.S. (2000).
.
B.
Filing of Charges and Convictions
'
The law now requires school personnel to be notified whenever certain types of criminal
actions are initiated against the school’s students. Specifically, when a delinquency petition {i.e.,
a petition alleging that the juvenile has committed a violation of a statute, ordinance, or order
listed in section 19-2-104(1 )(a), C.R.S. (2000)) is filed in juvenile court, the prosecuting attorney
must now notify the principal of the school in which the juvenile is enrolled on or before the next
school day. The prosecuting attorney must also provide the principal with arrest and criminal
records information concerning the student.
Section 19-1-304(5.5), C.R.S. (2000).
Also,
whenever a student under the age of 18 is convicted or adjudicated for an offense constituting a
crime of violence or involving controlled substances, the court must now notify the school
district in which the student is enrolled of the conviction or adjudication.
Section 22-33-
106.5(2), C.R.S. (2000). (The term “adjudication” in this context means a determination by a
court that a juvenile has committed a delinquent act, or has pled guilty to a delinquent act.
- 4 -
Section 19-1-103(2), C.R.S. (2000)). The same reporting requirement applies when a student
between the ages of 12 and 18 is convicted or adjudicated of an offense constituting unlawful
sexual behavior. Section 22-33-106.5(2), C.R.S. (2000). Finally, when a student under the age
of 18 is convicted or adjudicated of one of the following crimes, the court must now notify the
school district in which the student is enrolled that the student is subject to mandatory expulsion:
carrying, bringing, using or possessing a dangerous weapon on school grounds without
authorization of the school or school district; sale of drugs or controlled substances; robbery; or
first or second degree assault. Sections 22-33-106.5(1) and 22-33-106(l)(d), C.R.S. (2000).
Thus, the prosecuting attorney must notify the principal or school district each time a
delinquency petition is filed against a student in juvenile court, and each time a student is
charged in any court with a crime of violence or unlawful sexual behavior. Furthermore, each
time a student is convicted or adjudicated in any court for an offense involving a crime of
violence, controlled substances, unlawful sexual behavior, or an offense subjecting the student to
mandatory expulsion, the court must notify the school district of that conviction or adjudication.
It should be noted, however, that not all charges or convictions in adult district or county court
are subject to these mandatory reporting requirements. The law distinguishes between criminal
charges, and allegations that a juvenile has committed a delinquent act. While certain conduct
might give rise to criminal charges for a perpetrator 18 years of age or older, if the perpetrator is
under 18, the conduct is generally classified as a delinquent act, and usually results in the filing
of a delinquency petition in juvenile court, as opposed to criminal charges in an adult court.
Under certain circumstances, a juvenile may be charged as an adult in district court. If
this happens, it is referred to as a “direct file.” Section 19-2-517, C.R.S. (2000). In such a case,
the charging document is not classified as a delinquency petition, and it is filed in adult district
court rather than juvenile court. Finally, certain conduct perpetrated by a person under 18 may
be processed either in juvenile court, or in county court. If charges against a student under 18 are
directly filed in adult district court, or in county court, the mandatory reporting of those charges
to school personnel is limited to crimes of violence and unlawful sexual behavior.
If the
conviction of a student under 18 occurs in adult district court or county court, the mandatory
reporting of the conviction to school personnel is limited to crimes of violence, unlawful sexual
behavior, and those crimes occurring on school property which subject the student to mandatory
expulsion. However, records and information related to charges or convictions in adult district
or county court, which are not subject to mandatory reporting, may be obtained by school
personnel upon request, as outlined below.
C.
Notification of Mandatory School Attendance
Courts frequently require school attendance as a condition of release, probation, or
sentencing of a juvenile. Colorado law requires the court to notify the school district in which the
juvenile is enrolled of such a condition in the following cases: (1) whenever a court allows a
juvenile to be released pending resolution of a delinquency matter, and, as a condition of this
release, requires the juvenile to attend school, Section 19-2-508(3)(a)(VI), C.R.S. (2000); (2)
whenever a court, as a condition of or in connection with any sentence imposed in a delinquency
matter, requires a juvenile to attend school, Section 19-2-907(4), C.R.S. (2000); (3) whenever a
- 5 -
court, as a specific condition of probation in a delinquency matter, requires a juvenile to attend
school; Section 19-2-925(5), C.R.S. (2000); (4) whenever a criminal defendant who is under
eighteen years of age at the time of sentencing (i.e., where a juvenile is processed and sentenced as
an adult) is required to attend school as a condition of probation, Section 16-1 l-204(2.3)(b), C.R.S.
(2000); (5) whenever a juvenile is required, as condition of juvenile parole, to attend school, Section
19-2-1002(3)(b)(II) C.R.S., (2000); and (6) whenever a municipal court requires a person under
eighteen years of age to attend school as a condition of or in connection with any sentence. Section
13-10-113(8), C.R.S. (2000).
Issue 2: Under Colorado law, what other information may law enforcement authorities
share with school authorities concerning students enrolled in schools?
A.
Inspection of Criminal Justice Agency Records
School personnel may now obtain records or information on students from the judicial
department or any agency that performs duties with respect to delinquency or dependency and
neglect matters, when the information is required by the school to perform its legal duties and
responsibilities. Section 19-l-303(2)(a), C.R.S. (2000).
Certain records or information concerning a particular child, and which are maintained by
any criminal justice agency or child assessment center, may be obtained by the principal or the
principal’s designee of the school which the child attends or will attend. If the school is public,
the information may also be obtained by the superintendent or superintendent’s designee.
Section 19-1-303(2)(b), C.R.S. (2000). School officials receiving information pursuant to this
section may use it only in the performance of their legal duties, and must otherwise maintain the
confidentiality of the information.
Section 19-l-303(2)(d), C.R.S. (2000).
The following
records or information are open to inspection under this statute:
1)
Any information or records, except mental health or medical records, relating to
incidents that, in the discretion of the agency or center, rise the level of a public
safety concern, including but not limited to, any information or records of threats
made by the child, any arrest or charging information, any information regarding
municipal ordinance violations, and any arrest or charging information relating to
acts that, if committed by an adult, would constitute misdemeanors or felonies.
■
Section 19-1 -303(2)(b)(I), C.R.S. (2000).
2)
Any records of incidents, except mental health or medical records, concerning the
child that, in the discretion of the agency or center, do not rise to the level of a public
safety concern, but that relate to the adjudication or conviction of a child for a
municipal ordinance violation or that relate to the charging, adjudication, deferred
prosecution, deferred judgment, or diversion of a child for an act that, if committed
by an adult, would have constituted a misdemeanor or felony.
Section 19-1-
303(2)(b)(II), C.R.S. (2000).
School and school district personnel who share information pursuant to section 19-1-303,
C.R.S. (2000) are immune from civil and criminal liability for their conduct if they acted in
good-faith compliance with the provisions of section 19-1-303, C.R.S. (2000). Section 19-1-
- 6 -
303(4.3), C.R.S. (2000). A knowing violation of the confidentiality provisions of section 19-1 -
303, C.R.S. (2000) subjects the violating party to a civil penalty not to exceed one thousand
dollars. Section 19-1-303(4.7), C.R.S. (2000).
B.
Inspection of Juvenile Delinquency Records
Juvenile delinquency records maintained by the various agencies responsible for
delinquency proceedings are also now open to inspection by the principal or superintendent of
the school in which the juvenile is or will be enrolled, or to their designees, as outlined below:
1)
Court records in juvenile delinquency proceedings or proceedings concerning a
juvenile charged with the violation of any municipal ordinance except traffic
ordinances. Section 19-l-304(l)(a)(XVI), C.R.S. (2000).
2)
Juvenile probation records, whether or not part of the court file.
Section 19-1-
304(l)(c)(X) or (XI), C.R.S. (2000).
3)
Law enforcement records concerning juveniles.
Section 19-l-304(2)(a)(XV),
C.R.S. (2000).
4)
Parole records. Section 19-1-304(2.5), C.R.S. (2000).
Issue 3: Under Colorado and federal law, what information concerning students are school
authorities now required to provide to law enforcement agencies?
A.
Information to be Provided upon Request
The following student records are now available to criminal justice agencies upon
request: (1) disciplinary and truancy information; (2) the student’s attendance records; and (3)
the student’s disciplinary records. Section 19-1 -303(2)(c), C.R.S. (2000). In order to obtain
these records, the criminal justice agency must meet the following requirements: it must be
investigating a criminal matter concerning the child; the information must be necessary to
effectively serve the child prior to trial; and the request must be accompanied by written
certification that the criminal justice agency will not unlawfully disclose the information without
proper consent. The criminal justice agency should request these records from the principal of
the school in which the child is or will be enrolled, or from the superintendent, if the school is
public.
Section 19-l-303(2)(c), C.R.S. (2000). Upon receiving the request, the principal or
superintendent must provide the criminal justice agency with such records.
Sections 19-1-
303(2)(c) and 22-32-109.3(3), C.R.S. (2000).
B.
Mandatory Reporting of Assault or Harassment of Teachers or School Employees
In addition to the above, the school administration is now required to report the following
to the District Attorney or the appropriate local law enforcement agency or officer: any incident
involving assault upon, disorderly conduct toward, harassment of, the making of a knowingly
false allegation of child abuse against, or any alleged offense under Colorado’s criminal code
directed toward a teacher or school employee, or any incident involving damage occurring on the
premises to the personal property of a teacher or school employee by a student. Section 22-32-
109.1(3)(c), C.R.S. (2000).
As a practical matter, while the new law refers to mandatory
reporting to the District Attorney or to the local law enforcement agency, it is the local law
enforcement agencies that do the preliminary investigation of crimes as opposed to the District
Attorney. Therefore, to satisfy this reporting requirement, schools should report to the local law
enforcement agency.
C.
Mandatory Reporting of Student Non-Attendance
Finally, if a student is required to attend school as a condition of release pending an
adjudicatory trial, or as a condition of or in connection with any sentence imposed by a court,
including probation or parole, and the student fails to attend all or any part of a school day, the
school district must now notify the appropriate court or parole board of the failure to attend.
Section 22-33-107.5, C.R.S. (2000).
D.
Federal Law Governing Disclosure of Student Information
In complying with the above-referenced statutes, school officials must still comply with
the provisions of FERPA. Under FERPA, educational institutions may not disclose information
about students nor permit inspection of their records without written permission of the student,
unless such action is covered by certain exceptions permitted by the Act.
20 U.S.C.
§ 1232g(a)(6)(b). The restrictions on disclosure in FERPA apply to all educational institutions
which either receive funds directly from the federal Department of Education or which have
students in attendance who receive funds through programs administered by the federal
Department of Education. 34 C.F.R. § 99.1. Thus, every public school in Colorado is required
by federal law to comply with the disclosure requirements of FERPA. Violations of FERPA by
a public school may result in termination of federal funding. 20 U.S.C. § 1232g(f).
The restrictions in FERPA apply to personally identifiable information contained in
educational records maintained by the school. An “educational record” is any record maintained
by the school that contains information related to a student. 34 C.F.R. § 99.3(a). However, the
term does not include records of the law enforcement unit of the school, or records that only
contain information about an individual after he or she is no longer a student at the school. 34
C.F.R. § 99.3. The term “personally identifiable information” includes, but is not limited to, the
student’s name, the name of the student’s parents or other family members, the student’s address,
any personal identifiers, including the student’s social security number, any list of personal
characteristics that would make the student’s identity easily traceable, or any other information
that would make the student’s identity easily traceable. 34 C.F.R. § 99.3.
As discussed above, Colorado law allows for the disclosure of disciplinary and truancy
information, attendance records, incidences of student criminal misbehavior directed against the
person or property of teachers, and student failure to attend school when court ordered to do so.
Much of this information would either constitute educational records or contain personally
- 8 -
identifiable student information under FERPA. Fortunately, Colorado’s disclosure provisions
have been drafted with the exceptions to FERPA’s confidentiality provisions in mind; thus,
disclosures of student information meeting the requirements of Colorado law should meet the
requirements of FERPA, as well. It should be noted, however, that Colorado law does not allow
for the disclosure of all personally identifiable student information; except as outlined in our
discussion of Issue 4 below, only those categories of information identified above are accessible
to law enforcement officials.
FERPA allows disclosure of personally identifiable information in student records to law
enforcement in the following circumstances.
First, and most relevant to Colorado’s new
mandatory disclosure laws, FERPA allows the disclosure of such information pursuant to any
state statute adopted after 1974 if the reporting or disclosure: 1) concerns the juvenile justice
system; and 2) is for the purpose of allowing the system to effectively serve, prior to
adjudication, the student whose records are to be released.
34 C.F.R. § § 99.31 (5)(i)(B),
99.38(a).
These requirements are tracked in the language of section 19-1-303(2)(c), C.R.S.
(2000). Thus, a request from a law enforcement agency complying with State law will comply
with the restrictions of FERPA as well. Additionally, a disclosure by a school of a student’s
failure to attend school, when such attendance was a condition ordered by a court or parole
board, would also fit within this exception to the FERPA restrictions.
Under FERPA, in order to obtain such records, the law enforcement officials to whom the
records are to be disclosed must certify in writing to the school that the information will not be
disclosed to any other party, except as provided under State law, without the prior written
consent of the parent of the student. 34 C.F.R. § 99.38(b). This requirement is also contained in.
state law. Furthermore, the school must maintain a record of each disclosure of personally
identifiable information under this provision, including the person receiving such information,
and the legitimate interests the person had in requesting the information.
34 C.F.R.
§ 99.32(a)(3).
The officers, employees, and agents of the law enforcement agency receiving the
information from the school may only use the information for the purposes for which the
disclosure was made. 34 C.F.R. § 99.33(a)(2). The law enforcement agency may not disclose
the information to a third party unless: 1) it obtains prior consent from the parent of the student;
dr 2) the further disclosure meets the requirements of 34 C.F.R. § 99.31 above, and the school
has made a record of the further disclosure pursuant to the provisions of 34 C.F.R. § 99.32(b).
In addition to the above, the school may always disclose student records to a law
enforcement agency pursuant to a judicial order or lawfully issued subpoena.
34 C.F.R.
§ (a)(9)(i). However, if served with such a subpoena, the school must make a reasonable effort
to notify the parent or student (if over 18) in advance of compliance with the subpoena, so that
the parent or student may seek protective action, unless the court or other issuing agency has
ordered that the existence or contents of the subpoena or the information furnished in response to
the subpoena not be disclosed. 34 C.F.R. § 99.31(a)(9)(h).
Issue 4: Under Colorado and federal law, what other information are school authorities
permitted, but not required, provide to law enforcement authorities concerning their
students?
Regarding permissible reporting of other information by schools to law enforcement,
state law requires local boards of education to comply with the applicable provisions of FERPA
and the federal regulations promulgated thereunder. § 24-72-204(3)(d)(III), C.R.S. (2000).
A.
Student Consent
Under FERPA, personally identifiable student information may, of course, be disclosed
by the school with the written consent of the parent of the student, or with the consent of the
student if the student is over 18 years of age. 34 C.F.R. § 99.30 and 34 C.F.R. § 99.3. The
written consent must specify the records to be disclosed, the purpose of the disclosure, and the
party to whom the disclosure will be made. Id.
B.
Directory Information
The school may also, under certain circumstances, disclose directory information.
“Directory information” includes information contained in the education records of the student
which would not generally be considered harmful or an invasion privacy if disclosed. This
includes the student’s name, address, telephone number, date and place of birth, participation in
extra-curricular activities or sports, weight and height for members of athletic teams, dates of
attendance, and degrees received, and the most recent previous school attended.
34 C.F.R.
§ 99.3. In order to disclose directory information, the school must have given public notice to
parents of students and (if over 18) the students in attendance of the types of personally
identifiable information the school has designated as directory information, and the parent’s or
(if over 18) the student’s right to refuse to let the agency designate any or all of those types of
information as directory information. A school may disclose directory information about former
students without meeting these conditions concerning notice and right to refuse.
34 C.F.R.
§ 99.37.
C.
School Law Enforcement Unit Records
Another applicable exemption from FERPA relates to school district disclosure of the
records of its own law enforcement unit. FERPA does not prohibit the disclosure of the records
of a school’s law enforcement unit. The term “law enforcement unit” in this context relates to an
individual, office, or department of the school, such as a unit of commissioned police officers or
non-commissioned security guards, who are assigned to the school to enforce the law or provide
security services. 34 C.F.R. § 99.8. Law enforcement unit records include those records created
and maintained by the law enforcement unit for a law enforcement purpose.
However, law
enforcement unit records do not include records created by the law enforcement unit that are
maintained by a component of the school other than the law enforcement unit, or records created
and maintained by the law enforcement unit that are exclusively for a non-law enforcement
purpose. 34 C.F.R. § 99.8(b). Finally, educational records do not lose their protection under
- 10-
FERPA solely by being in the possession of a school law enforcement unit.
34 C.F.R.
§ 99.8(b)(2).
D.
Emergencies
Finally, under FERPA a school may disclose personally identifiable information to
appropriate parties in connection with an emergency if knowledge of the information is
necessary to protect the health or safety of the student or of other individuals. 34 C.F.R. § 99.36.
CONCLUSION
Recent statutory changes have greatly expanded the ability of school districts and law
enforcement agencies to cooperate in the transmission and sharing of information. Juvenile
justice agencies are now required to provide schools with basic identification information
whenever a student is charged in any court with committing a crime of violence or unlawful
sexual offense; arrest and criminal records information whenever a delinquency petition is filed
in juvenile court; notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for an offense
constituting a crime of violence, involving controlled substances, or unlawful sexual behavior;
notice whenever a student is convicted or adjudicated for a crime that would result in mandatory
expulsion proceedings under Colorado law; and notice whenever a court makes school
attendance a condition of release, probation, or sentencing. Moreover, law enforcement agencies
may now, upon request, provide certain school officials access to records or information on
students which are maintained by the judicial department or any agency that performs duties with
respect to delinquency or dependency and neglect matters, when the information is required to
perform the school officials’ legal duties and responsibilities.
This includes information or
records of threats made by the student, arrest or charging information, records relating to the
adjudication or conviction of a child for a misdemeanor or felony, court records in juvenile
delinquency proceedings, and probation officer, law enforcement, and parole records.
School districts are now required to provide the following information upon request from
law enforcement authorities: truancy, disciplinary, and attendance records upon proper request;
reports of incidents on school grounds involving assault or harassment of a teacher or school
employee; and notification of failure of a student to attend school, if school attendance is a condition
of that student’s sentence or release. Elowever, the disclosure of student information must comply
with the provisions of FERPA. School officials may also disclose personally identifiable student
information with the consent of the student’s parents, if the information falls under the category
of “directory information,” if the records are of the school’s own “law enforcement unit,” or in
an emergency if knowledge of the information is necessary to protect the health or safety of the
student or of other individuals.
- 11 -
Issued this
_ day of August, 2000.
KEN SALAZAR
Attorney General
ANTONY B. DYL
MATTHEW KARZEN
Assistant Attorneys General
State Services Section
1525 Sherman Street, 5th Floor
Denver, Colorado 80203
- 12-