Aeronautical Industrial District Lodge 751

450 DECISIONS OF NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD Aeronautical Industrial District Lodge 751 , affiliated with the International Association of Machinists & Aerospace Workers , AFL-CIO and The Boeing Company. Case 19-CB-1202 October 30, 1968 DECISION AND ORDER BY CHAIRMAN MCCULLOCH AND MEMBERS FANNING AND JENKINS Upon charges filed by The Boeing Company on March 17, 1967, the General Counsel of the National Labor Relations Board, by the Regional Director for Region 19, issued a complaint on November 13, 1967, alleging that the Respondent Union has de- manded and is demanding the termination of employ- ment of certain employees of The Boeing Company, in violation of Section 8(b)(2) and (1)(A) of the National Labor Relations Act, as amended. Copies of the charge and the complaint and notice of hearing before a Trial Examiner were duly served upon the Respondent Union. The complaint alleges, among other things, that the Respondent Union has demanded and is demanding the discharge of certain individuals for failure to comply with the terms of the union-security provision of the current collective-bargaining agreement be- tween it and Boeing and therby has engaged in and is engaging in unfair labor practices affecting commerce within the meaning of Section 8(b)(2) and (1)(A) of the Act. On January 29, 1968, the Respondent Union filed its answer admitting certain jurisdictional and factual allegations of the complaint, but denying the commission of any unfair labor practice. On March 26, 1968, the Charging Party, the Respondent Union, Landon R. Estep, counsel for the Intervenor herein, and counsel for the General Coun- sel entered into a "Stipulation in Lieu of Hearing." The parties agreed that the stipulation of facts, together with the exhibits attached thereto and made a part thereof, should constitute the entire record in the case. The parties further stipulated that they have waived their right to a hearing before a Trial Examiner and to the issuance of a Trial Examiner's Decision and that they have submitted the case directly to the Board for findings of fact, conclusions of law, and for Decision and Order. On March 29, 1968, the Board ordered that the stipulation of the parties be approved and made a part of the record herein and further ordered the proceeding transferred to and conducted before the Board for the purpose of making findings of fact and conclusions of law, and for the issuance of a Decision and Order. The Board also granted permission to the parties to file briefs. The General Counsel and the Charging Party filed opening briefs, the Respondent Union filed an an- swering brief, and the Charging Party and the Respon- dent Union filed reply briefs. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 3(b) of the Act, the Board has delegated its powers in connection with this case to a three-member panel. Upon the basis of the stipulation of the parties, the briefs, and the entire record in this case, the Board makes the following- FINDINGS OF FACT I COMMERCE The Boeing Company, a Delaware corporation with plants in the State of Washington, is, and at all times material has been, engaged in the manufacture of aircraft. The Company annually ships products valued in excess of $50,000 from these plants directly to points outside the State of Washington. We find that the Company is engaged in commerce within the meaning of Section 2(6) and (7) of the Act. II. THE LABOR ORGANIZATION INVOLVED The Respondent, Aeronautical Industrial District Lodge 75 1, affiliated with the International Associa- tion of Machinists & Aerospace Workers, AFL-CIO, is, and at all times material has been, a labor organization within the meaning of Section 2(5) of the Act. III. THE UNFAIR LABOR PRACTICE A. The Facts For many years Boeing has recognized and bar- gained with the Respondent Union as the repre- sentative of a unit of its production and maintenance employees in the State of Washington, known as the Seattle-Renton unit. Collective-bargaining agreements covering these employees have been negotiated by the parties since prior to 1948. On May 16, 1963, Boeing and the Respondent Union executed an agreement which expired on September 15, 1965. A new agreement was not reached until October 2, 1965. Both the 1963 and the 1965 contracts contain union-security provisions which, among other things, provide that those employees of Boeing who were not members of the Respondent Union on the effective date of the most recent agreement would not be required to become members. However, all employees who became members of the Respondent Union within 30 days following the effective date of that agreement would be required to maintain their membership in the Respondent Union as a condition of continued employment. Between September 16 and October 2, 1965, during which time there was no collective-bargaining 173 NLRB No. 71 AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT LODGE 751 agreement in effect or existing between Boeing and the Respondent Union, and while the latter was engaged in a strike against the former, certain employees whose names are listed in appendix A, attached hereto, notified the Respondent Union in writing that they were resigning, withdrawing, and terminating their membership in the Union. These notifications were received by the Union by October 2, 1965. Thereafter, on various dates between Janu- ary 26, 1966, and September 15, 1966, the Respon- dent Union, having taken the position that the employees involved had not by such notification effectively resigned their membership in the Union, requested Boeing to terminate the employment of these employees. The Respondent Union assigned as the reason for this request the fact that the employees involved were either delinquent in the payment of dues or had failed to reestablish membership in the Union, having lost membership status for being delinquent in the payment of dues., Boeing refused, advising that the listed employees had terminated their Union membership during a penod when no collective-bargaining agreement was in affect and, further, that as they were employees of the Company on October 2, 1965, the effective date of the current collective-bargaining agreement, and not members of the Respondent Union, they were not required to become members as a condition of continued employ- ment with Boeing. On March 1 and May 23, 1966, the Respondent Union filed grievances alleging that Boeing had violated their collective-bargaining agreement by re- fusing to discharge the above-mentioned employees pursuant to its request. The parties discussed these grievances, but no settlement was reached. Thereafter, the Respondent Union requested arbitration. Boeing refused, claiming that the requested discharges were not properly the subject of the grievance and arbitra- tion procedure contained in the collective-bargaining agreement between the parties. On July 18, 1966, the Respondent Union filed an action in the U.S District Court for the Western District of Washington, Northern Division, to compel arbitration. Numerous pleadings have been filed by the parties with that court between August 8, 1966, and June 21, 1967. On August 18, 1967, the court issued an order denying the Respondent Union's motion for summary judgment. Thereafter, on Sep- tember 15, 1967, the court denied the request of the t The Respondent Union sent notices to all of the employees whose names are listed in appendix A, stating that their dues were in arrears. Each notice was sent during the month at the end of which the employee's membership lapsed for nonpayment of dues Each notice stated "DELINQUENCY FOR 3 MONTHS IN PAYMENT of dues shall AUTOMATICALLY CANCEL MEMBERSHIP in a local lodge of this Association. 451 Respondent Union to set the matter for trial. How- ever, the Union has not withdrawn its suit in the District Court to compel arbitration of its grievances over the failure of Boeing to discharge the employees as requested. In this respect, the Respondent Union continues to adhere to its original position that membership in the Union ceases only when the employees involved become delinquent for 3 months in the payment of fees or are expelled as a result of a proper hearing on charges. Accordingly, it is the position of the Respondent Union that these individ- uals did not sever their membership and that they continued to be members at the time the current agreement with Boeing was executed. B. Contentions of the Parties The General Counsel and the Charging Party contend that the employees involved effectively termi- nated their membership in the Respondent Union and accordingly that the terms of the union-security provision in the collective-bargaining agreement sub- sequently executed does not, by its own terms, apply to them. Accordingly, it is the position of the General Counsel and Charging Party that the Respondent Union unlawfully demanded that Boeing discharge the employees involved for reasons stemming from their failure to pay union dues. Further, while the Union's original demands precede the 6-month period prior to the filing of charges herein, and for that reason cannot form the basis for finding an unfair labor practice,2 the General Counsel and the Charging Party urge that the demands made by the Respondent Union have continued to the present time and that these continuing demands are manifest, among other things, by the persistent effort of the Respondent Union to compel arbitration of their grievances over the failure of Boeing to discharge the employees involved. As noted above, the Respondent Union contends that its constitution precludes voluntary withdrawal from membership and, therefore, that the employees here involved, being members of the Respondent Union on the effective date of the current collective- bargaining agreement, are covered by the terms of the union-security provision contained therein. Further, as these employees have not complied with that provision, the Respondent Union may justifiably seek their discharge. The Respondent Union also contends 2 Section 10 (b) of the Act reads in pertinent part. ... no complaint shall issue based upon any unfair labor practice occurring more than six months prior to the filing of the charge with the Board and the service of a copy thereof upon the person against whom such charge is made ... 452 DECISIONS OF NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD that, in any event, it has engaged in no conduct within the 10(b) period upon which a finding of unlawful conduct can be based. In this respect, it is the Respondent Union's position that its resort to legal processes to compel arbitration of its grievances, conduct which is not in itself unlawful, cannot be held to constitute unlawful conduct merely because it had previously demanded of the Employer that these employees be discharged as a result of dues delinquen- cies. C. Concluding Findings We sustain the position of the General Counsel and the Charging Party and reject the contentions of the Respondent Union, as set forth above. The determina- tion of whether the Respondent's conduct was unlawful turns on whether or not, on the effective date of the collective-bargaining agreement between Boeing and the Respondent Union, the above- mentioned employees had effectively terminated their membership in the Union. The parties stipulated and the record shows that the constitution relied upon by the Respondent Union in attempted justification of its discharge demands sets forth no procedure by which employees may voluntarily resign their mem- bership. The Board has previously stated that in such cases, as is true of membership for an indefinite period in voluntary associations generally, members are at liberty to resign at wi11.3 As the employees here involved resigned their membership in the Union prior to the effective date of the current agreement between the Union and Boeing, and at a time when no contract binding them to continued membership was in force, their resignations were effective on the governing date of the maintenance-of-membership clause fixed in the new contract. It follows that the provisions of that clause were not applicable to them and that they could not therefore be lawfully discharged thereunder for failure either to reestablish their membership in the Union or to pay Union dues. Although the Union's discharge demand was initially made on Boeing before the 10(b) date, it is clear, and we find, that the Union has never abandoned that demand, but, on the contrary, has at all times since, both prior and subsequent to the 10(b) date, main- tained and pressed it as a continuing and viable demand, as is affirmatively evidenced by its afore- mentioned efforts, in which it still persists, to compel arbitration of its asserted grievance over Boeing's refusal to effectuate the requested discharges.4 We find, accordingly, that by continuing since September 17, 1966, to attempt to cause Boeing to discharge the employees listed in Appendix A and therefore to violate Section 8(a)(3) of the Act, the Respondent Union has engaged in and is engaging in, conduct in violation of Section 8(b)(2) and (1)(A) of the Act. IV. THE EFFECT OF THE UNFAIR LABOR PRACTICES UPON COMMERCE The activities of the Respondent Union set forth in section III, above, occurring in connection with the operations described in section I, above, have a close, intimate, and substantial relation to trade, traffic, and commerce among the several States, and tend to lead to labor disputes burdening and obstructing com- merce and the free flow of commerce. THE REMEDY Having found that the Respondent Union has engaged in said unfair labor practices, we shall order that it cease and desist therefrom and take certain affirmative action designed to effectuate the policies of the Act. Upon the basis of the foregoing findings of fact and upon the entire record in this case, the Board makes the following: CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The Boeing Company is engaged in commerce within the meaning of Section 2(2) and Section 2(6) and (7) of the Act. 2. The Respondent Union is a labor organization within the meaning of Section 2(5) of the Act. 3. By attempting to cause The Boeing Company to discriminate against certain employees in violation of Section 8(a)(3) of the Act, the Respondent Union has violated Section 8(b)(2) and (1)(A) of the Act. 4. The aforesaid unfair labor practices are unfair labor practices affecting commerce within the mean- ing of Section 2(6) and (7) of the Act. These unfair labor practices stem from an attempt on the part of the Respondent Union to cause Boeing to discriminate against a substantial number of employees because these employees exercised certain rights guaranteed them by Section 7 of the Act. As such, these violations go to the very heart of the Act. Accordingly, a broad order is required. ORDER Pursuant to Section 10(c) of the National Labor Relations Act, as amended, the National Labor Relations Board hereby orders that the Respondent, Aeronautical Industrial District Lodge 751, affiliated with the International Association of Machinists & Aerospace Workers, AFL-CIO, Seattle, Washington, its officers, agents, and representatives, shall: 3 Atlantic Research Corporation, 167 NLRB No. 83. 4 Cf.United Nuclear Corp. v. N.L.R.B, 340 F.2d 133 (C.A. 1, 1965). AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT LODGE 751 1. Cease and desist from: (a) Attempting to cause The Boeing Company to discharge or otherwise discriminate against any em- ployee when such discharge or discrimination would be in violation of Section 8(a)(3) of the Act. (b) In any other manner restraining or coercing employees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed in Section 7 of the Act, except to the extent that such rights may lawfully be affected by an agreement requiring membership in a labor organization as a condition of employment, as authorized in Section 8(a)(3) of the Act. 2. Take the following affirmative action which the Board finds will effectuate the policies of the Act. (a) Notify The Boeing Company, in writing, that it has no objection to the employment of any of the employees listed in Appendix A, and send a copy of said letter to each of the employees listed in said Appendix. (b) Post in its business office and meeting halls copies of the attached notice marked "Appendix."5 Copies of said notice, on forms to be provided by the Regional Director for Region 19, shall, after being duly signed by an authorized representative of the Respondent Union, be posted immediately upon receipt thereof and be maintained by the Respondent Union for 60 consecutive days thereafter, in conspic- uous places, including all places where notices to employees are customarily posted. Reasonable steps shall be taken by the Respondent Union to insure that said notices are not altered, defaced, or covered by any other material. (c) Sign and mail sufficient copies of said notice to the aforementioned Regional Director for forwarding to The Boeing Company, for information, and if it is willing, for posting by it at all locations where notices to its employees are customarily posted. (d) Notify the Regional Director for Region 19, in writing, within 10 days from the date of this Order, what steps the Respondent Union has taken to comply herewith. 5 In the event that this Order is enforced by a decree of a United States Court of Appeals, there shall be substituted for the words "a Decision and Order" the words "a Decree of the United States Court of Appeals Enforcing an Order " APPENDIX A Name Clock Name Clock Adams, R. J. 1169 Ambrosch, R. J. 9572 Adams, W. 0 4906 Ames, R. C. 6213 Ady, R. D 5211 Andersen, E. 3280 Alejo, J J. 0677 Anderson, D. D. 7141 Alexander, B. 0288 Anderson, D. M. 4569 Alexander, C L. 6386 Anderson, G A. 2657 Alleger, E C. 4598 Anderson, Harry E. 5923 Allen, J G 6000 Anderson, Helen M 0534 Allen, L. E. 5198 Anderson, M. C. 7873 Allen, W. R 8525 Anderson, 0. T 5421 Name Clock 453 Name Clock Anderson, Roger L. 2123 Bridges, C. 7952 Anderson, Ronald D. 4009 Briggs, Donald H. 6420 Anderson, T. E 0376 Brocato, E. 0745 Anderson, Wilbur K. 1945 Brooke, R. W. 2446 Andrews, Michael 0560 Brookes, C. R. 1559 Aoyama, Masatoshi 4458 Brooks, R. J 5070 Armstrong, J L. 8325 Broomfield, R. C 9495 Arnall, Pearl A 9924 Brown, Billie 5711 Arnett, Alvin 0. 6222 Brown, J., Jr. 0027 Arnold, T E. 2292 Bruaw, Darrell J. 2447 Arrera, W A 1816 Bruce, D. W. 8441 Arrison, G W 5810 Bruce, R A 1314 Ashbaugh, A. L 4182 Brundage, Vincent G. 5426 Atkin, F L 3958 Buchanan, Albert Milton 1695 Atkinson, Willard T. 9599 Bucknn, D. G. 9634 Babcock, M. 0674 Buckner, E. V. 4334 Babcock, P. R. 5284 Buckner, Stanley H 4920 Backer, Elroy F. 0872 Bueser, J. E. 7689 Baer, E. F. 3316 Buffington, Alvin M. 2819 Bayles, L L. 0785 Burkey, K. N. 2453 Bailey, M. H 1708 Burnichon, G. 8053 Baisden, Vinton W. 4672 Bums, Wm. E 8504 Bakan, T. 8426 Burtis, B. 4122 Baker, E C 4264 Burton, 1. 5502 Baker, G. R. 5472 Butler, L R. 6530 Baker, Kenneth A. 4503 Butterfield, Clifford 3529 Baker, M. R 1558 Cables, Rodolfo 3964 Bakoles, Mary R 1517 Callaham, William R. 7525 Baldwin, R Q. 7425 Callas, Harry D. 2742 Ballou, G F. 0493 Camenzind, Paul J. 3949 Barham, Maxwell 0039 Camp, D. D. 1501 Barkell, D. T. 6092 Canaday, Lawrence 9678 Barker, H. 5344 Cannon, P. E. 6473 Barnes, K. L. 6417 Canty, E. 5053 Barto, D J 5934 Carithers, Earl W. 9597 Baskett, William 2552 Carmody, R A 5392 Bates, K. E. 8723 Carpenter, Carl 0816 Bauer, 1 J., Jr 4727 Carpenter, Londis 2331 Bayles, R 6110 Can, C. K. 2974 Beam, D. A. 5156 Carr, M. A 2119 Beasley, L D 1517 Carrell, C. E 9713 Becvar, R. G. 4607 Carver, Alvira 9215 Bell, D. E. 5563 Carter, D. A. 4005 Bell, J H. 2311 Carter, R A. 1559 Bell, Sylvester L 3883 Castillo, Nora 8690 Bennett, W. L. 8530 Cauffield, L R. 8625 Berg, P. E 1878 Chabot, Wayne A 4620 Bergman, E. M. 6409 Chaffey, P. S. 4138 Bergmann, Dennis G. 9559 Chaffin, Mildred A. 4199 Berkey, C J. 4967 Challender, A. 7585 Berlmg, V D. 0769 Chandler, Michael H. 3367 Berry, John C 0543 Chaplin, W. 0. 4277 Beutz, J P. 2539 Chattick, L M 1719 Bihary, Stephen J. 5790 Chiofor, Charles R 1519 Bingaman, M. 0 6366 Christenson, S. 2237 Bird, G. D. 3866 Christian, D D 3624 Bitenieks, R. A. 8401 Church, Gordon E. 9679 Blakely, D. 2033 Claassen, Leo 6699 Blanchard, Melvin E. 7401 Clark, C. J. 9930 Blankenship, K. W 5996 Clark, L. 6288 Blaud, Emma 1 6479 Clark, O B 8689 Blood, C A. 3540 Clement, H. 7945 Boatright, Barbara 5121 Clemons, C. J. 6763 Bol, C 9010 Clough, J. P 4253 Bolton, Kenneth M. 9197 Clyde, Ivan E. 4481 Bosley, K 8834 Coad, Howard E. 0225 Boss, K. 9824 Cody, R. 1658 Boswell, I. A. 6308 Coe, G. M. 3397 Bourbonnie, J 7364 Coffman, R. W 8899 Boylan, John G 5076 Cohen, N. N. 5237 Brandon, Melade 1121 Colacarro, H F. 9611 Branson, J G. 0374 Colbum, Billy 9366 Bratset, Loraine 2840 Colhoff, I. 0809 Breese, A. M. 3877 Collier, Ernest 7357 Brensdal, W. H. 6541 Collins, Hattie 8876 454 DECISIONS OF NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD Name Clock Name Clock Name Clock Name Clock Collins, J. L. 6729 Dunoven, John A. 9083 Gibbs, J. E. 0957 Healy, M. J. 5944 Collins, L G. 1736 Duxbury, D L. 3541 Giboney, E. V., Jr. 6582 Hegrenes, C 0021 Collins, Oliver 2153 Duxbury, Vivian 5917 Gilbertson , Catherine M. 3039 Hein, Maurice T. 7168 Collum, Robert 7175 Dvorak, D L 2693 Gilbertson, R. A. 6569 Heine, Albert 9900 Comstock, Delmer 5570 Eakins, R E. 3218 Ginn, A M. 1183 Heiret, Gordon 3721 Cone, E. I. 1721 Easterby, N O. 9012 Glandon, C. E , Jr 3087 Hela, E. R. 0442 Conradi, E. H. 1885 Easterly, Larry 7050 Glass, Calvin 5699 Helm, T P 4823 Conradi, F. L. 0414 Eck, John 3550 Glazier, G. L 2606 Henderson , D. L. 4422 Contreras, Eligio, Sr. 4978 Edmond, W. H. 1471 Gleason, R M. 9785 Henderson , J. 1884 Conwell, R J 4161 Edwards, T. 4918 Gloden, N. A 8259 Henderson , R. P 2080 Coogan, T E., Sr 4425 Eggerud, D. L. 5315 Goforth, R E. 7294 Henkel, Larry G. 5150 Cook, Ivan I. 7330 Eliason, P. C. 9278 Gogg, Ethel E. 4431 Heppard, H. L. 8925 Cook, O. E 9152 Elledge, Wayne 8664 Gonzales, R. 0174 Hermans, David A. 5259 Cooper, J. M., Jr. 4759 Elliott, Jesse Paul 5680 Gooding, J. W. 4451 Hermanson, W 5332 Cooper, Oran 3973 Ellis, Paul 3023 Goodwin, L. R. 8942 Herrett, Stan W., Jr. 4818 Cooper, Robert W 0023 Ellsworth, R. M. 7509 Gordon, Richard E. 0039 Herrington Lum D. 3119 Corpuz, R. P. 4819 Elstrom, Florman 4534 Grann, Eileen 4152 , Hetland R. 2174 Cota, D R. 6609 Engelhardt, Carrol 6702 Grant, J. Dale 5787 , Hewitt H M. 8960 Coursey, H. 6156 Evangelista, R J 4834 Gray, E. L. 7261 , Hezel K. H 5886 Con tee, C. L. 4692 Evans, P. J 4791 Grayson, C. T. 3172 , Hickman, L 2954 Cox, G. E. 0224 Evers, D. E 3067 Green, L J 1404 Higley, N. B 5745 Crapson, L G. 4254 Fallis, J. V. 1280 Griffith, E. C. 8272 Hildreth, Robert 5688 Cribby, Chas. E. 2156 Farrar, C E. 0806 Griffith, R. V 5915 Hill, M E 5391 Cross, Jim 4500 Fears, M. F 0041 Gngar, James D. 8142 Hilsendager, Wilbert L. 1737 Crouse, B. 1146 Fee,L. 7739 Groen, R A. 7063 Hiner, G. W. 5448 Cuddeback, L. C. 2467 Fee, P. L. 4467 Grogan, S. M. 0116 Hirata, Yoshio 3958 Culbertson , James R. 3656 Felicies-lopez, P. A. 2716 Grooms, B. L 0954 Hirschi, A D. 4475 Culler, J. M. 1496 Feller, Arthur C. 8102 Gross, John H. 1181 Hodge, P. D. 6774 Cullings, A. D. 0035 Fenton, Charles F. 8659 Gross, Virginia 8240 Hoffine, D. E. 4678 Dahl, D. A. 6919 Fenton , Howard E. 9010 Grover, A., Jr 3119 Hoffine, P. S. 2882 Dahlm,J B. 9990 Ferns, C L. 0070 Grymes, Karl J., Jr. 2206 Hohenstem , D. C. 1737 Dana, M. E. 7440 Fields, P R 4383 Gugel, R. H 1538 Holcombe, H. E. 4832 Danley, F. 5811 Fifield, G. A 6173 Guilmet, M. 1051 Holder, R. A. 0255 Darilek, B P. 5076 Fischer, W. A. 3367 Gulbranson, D. L. 8971 Holdren, E. A. 5476 David, D 5713 Fisher, J E. 8403 Gulbranson, N. I. 7238 Holloway, O. C. 2114 Davis, Phillip 9365 Fiske, Sidney C. 0505 Gulley, Lonnie C 7812 Holly, Clyde E. 2793 Davidson, H. S. 3651 Flack, K. G 1249 Haak, Lewis A. 1808 Holm, D. W. 1543 Davila, Arturo E. 8216 Flake, J L. 6446 Hacker, W. C. 2533 Holmgren, Walfred 1507 Davis, D. P. 7374 Flanigan, J. T. 6913 Hackl, M. A 7523 Hood, R. E 4704 Davis, H. C 7249 Flesch, Richard 3755 Haddon, M. A. 1762 Hooper, W. 4968 Davis, P. T. 1033 Fletcher, Ralph P , Jr 6585 Hafsos, G. A. 5259 Hoover, G. M. 0816 Dazey, D. J. 0564 Flick, Derrek V 3277 Hagbom, D. V. 1705 Hopkins, Jack L 7173 Deel, Robert H 6078 Flick, Gertrude P 3253 Hague , David 6127 Hord, R. W. 4357 Deel, Ronald L. 0566 Flynn, Thomas L 4025 Hains, L D. 6255 Horton , Charles F. 9591 DeJesus, M. B. 2531 Ford, F J 0550 Hake, Walter 2708 Horton , W. A 1172 DelBosque , Oscar V 9952 Fogaras, M J. 8701 Hale, B J. 7095 Hostynek, F. 8765 Daley, Erbie 1765 Fortier, D. J. 3271 Hale, Edward E. 9183 Howard , W. F. 4741 DeMass, W. J. 6143 Fouke, W. S. 0335 Hales, K. G 7143 Howard, W. L 3896 Demery, D M. 6795 Fox, M. H. 2168 Hales, Thomas F. 6697 Hryciw, S. 7164 Deniger, E. 3560 Francisco, A. T. 5291 Halvorson, Warren 3706 Huber, Delons 5629 Denney, Roderick D 9463 Franklin, C D. 6537 Hambly, Timothy 3565 Huber, N. C. 1652 Denney, R. R 0005 Froehlich, Thomas A. 3050 Hamilton, A. E. 4283 Hudson, M. C 7921 Dent, L. G 5313 Froula, T. E. 5071 Hamilton, J. N. 1560 Hughes, R. H. 8716 DeVore, C. D 1341 Frownfelter, Michael 0 7255 Hamilton, K . K. 0150 Humphrey, R. G. 1304 DeWell, E. F. 4317 Fudge, Don S. 0567 Hammond, C. L. 2616 Hunt, W 6933 Dick, Robert E 4310 Fultz , Muriel 2371 Hanheide , Edwin A. 2686 Huntington, Gary 7020 Dickerson, B. 8639 Funderhide , P. 6182 Hanke, R. C 4978 Hutchens, Toney, Jr. 9140 Dickson, C. 8337 Gaeth, H C 4363 Hansen, Jewel H. 4050 Hutchins, G. E. 3432 Dimm, Robert O. 8449 Gaines, Evelyn 0666 Hansford , Linda 8619 Hutsell , D. L. 3685 Dimond, H M 7560 Gaines, N. B. 7011 Hargreaves, Loren 7023 Huyler, Garey Heath 8437 Dire, A L 3485 Gallaher, D. E , Sr. 4556 Harnisch , H. H , Jr. 1277 Imbler, E. W. 5626 Diven, G. E 6073 Gann, Letha Willene 6770 Harris, M. I. (Susewind) 2817 Isaacson, Gustave T. 2303 Dodson, Jerry D. 4774 Ganong, J. C , Jr 2603 Harrison, C. 0876 Ivanich, J. A. 3478 Dotson, John L. 9174 Gamer, K. Beatrice 9814 Hart, R. S. 2097 Iversen, John 3466 Doellefeld, G. 5476 Garrett, C H. 4210 Harter, J. E. 8158 Iverson, Robert A. 7449 Dokken, D. A. 8237 Garrett, W. L. 7936 Hartman, Ralph 2083 Jackson, B. C. 9093 Drake, W. T. 3343 Garrison, J. 3694 Harvey, L. L. 2195 Jackson, 1. L., Jr. 5181 Dschaak, T. J. 3394 Garth, R. H. 3504 Harwood, E T 7163 Jackson, J. M. 6714 Duncan, F. C. 7323 Gattshall, Larry J. 3846 Hashimoto, 1 3289 James, C E. 2117 Duncan, G. D. 3458 Gauff, J F., Jr. 3842 Haskins, B. 7623 James, Florence 6536 Duncan, Wayne 4421 Geiss, F 8743 Hatch, D. B 3593 James, S E. 4663 Dundas, James 5472 Gentry, A L. 1132 Hatch, H. C., Jr. 8422 Janisch, J. M. 8246 Dunigan, Mary E. 4093 Gerdes, A. L. 2687 Hawkinson , G. M. 3834 Jeffers, A. R. 1742 Dunks, C. 6065 Gibbons, K. E. 5906 Hawley, George 4415 Jensen, A. P. 8319 AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT LODGE 751 455 Name Clock Name Clock Name Clock Name Clock Jensen, D. A. 4271 Lee, R. C. 4453 McDonald, Howard 6474 Nordyke, R W 2009 Jensen, Keith 7322 Lehman, L. 5149 McDonnell, J. B 1898 Norris, B. T. 6383 Jensen, William R. 2283 Lehmann, E. E. 1653 McDuffee, W. M 8253 Norris, D H 8611 Jirak, F. Marion 5541 Leichner, H. L. 6532 McFarland, J J. 4734 Nowak, D R 2142 Johannes, L. W. 6924 Lemley, A. M. 1380 McFarland, V B 6610 Nunnallee, E. P., Jr. 5595 Johns, Clifford 3166 Lennox, Florence P. 0474 McLallen, Jerry 2900 Nutt, W L. 6765 Johnson, C. N 3698 Lewis, Ivan F 8107 McLeod, Robert J 1176 Nyberg, Harry H 6369 Johnson, E B. 8934 Lewis, M. E. 8521 McMullen, G. D. 3063 Nygard, F. A. 3593 Johnson, G T 5982 Likens, C. F. 0012 McRae, K. H 5000 Nymon, F. M 4508 Johnson, H. T. 2590 Lind, Judith E. 7013 McShane, T D. 7036 Olander, L. L. 4075 Johnson, K. 3961 Lindblad, Gordon M., Jr 2715 Medley, L A. 0388 Oldson, J 1 7131 Johnson, Lawrence D 5310 Lindley, Robert A 4186 Melohn, G. F. 0437 Olesen, H. E. 9424 Johnson, L. R 8448 Lloyd, R. G. 7399 Menard, Larry 1361 Olmstead, C. J. 2128 Johnson, Ralph 2408 Locks, E. M. 0765 Menke, A. E. 2818 Olmstead, M. 7947 Johnson, R D. 9916 Lodge, J. F. 2236 Mentzos, J . F. 2908 Olson, B. E 6416 Johnston, E 0491 Loewen,J E. 1051 Merrifield, R. L. 5385 Olson, D M 8804 Jolley, James 3292 Loken,J M. 7659 Mey, R. E. 9154 Olson, K. E. 9801 Jones, J. H 2239 Long, A. W 1319 Meyer, Billy J 4056 Olson, L M. 3179 Jones, Joe A. 5082 Long,I 6134 Meyer, C N. III 4515 Olson, Morris I. 3101 Jones, Nahoma N 7910 Long, P. 2613 Meyer, D E 4864 Orth, V F. 6618 Jorgensen , Lloyd B. 9686 Longthorne, J E 0626 Mickens, D. V. 2260 Orton, Harriet L. 6232 Juarez, Thomas, Jr 5091 Loomis, S. W. 3201 Mthally, Paul C. 6615 Orvik, R. J. 0244 Joel, William D. 7241 Lord, J. S. 1270 Mikkelsen, D. L. 3111 Osborn, T. R. 1229 Justesen, W. 7766 Lord, William 5380 Miller, K. J 9132 Ott, W C. 6962 Kakuschke, R E. 4719 Long, Jerome 5729 Miller, N L. 4909 Ottosen, H. H. 7282 Kanis, A. 3440 Long, T. A 7744 Miller, T. E 5591 Overton, V. A. 7689 Kanzaki, Tsutomu H. 8826 Loveless, Kerry 3460 Milliken, A. E. 9242 Owen, S. M. 0312 Kappenman , B L. 4911 Lovelett, I L. 1421 Mills, E. R 8384 Owens, Claudia J. 5607 Kase, T. 6468 Lowman, E. L. 8630 Millus , B. J. 4829 Page, S. L. 9757 Kasprick, H. 4213 Lowrie, G. 6694 .4iron, Mary 6272 Paine, A B., Jr. 3508 Kelley, M. B 6537 Lowder, R. L. 6245 Mitchell, D S 4644 Paine, E. A. 4880 Kelly, L. E. 4929 Luke, C. A. 8009 Mitchell, John L. 3961 Palmer, G. A. 6111 Kenan, W. D., Jr. 0758 Lund, A. M. 4146 Mitchell, R E. 9941 Palmer, L. L. 0121 Kennedy, Bruce L. 3657 Lund, E. M. 1081 Mitchell, R. R. 8608 Panette, D. C. 1069 Kennedy, R. J. 9054 Lyon, W. E. 9405 Miyagishima , D. 3807 Parker, Robert K. 8470 Kennell, L R. 2972 Lynas, A 1685 Monaghan, S. M. 9309 Parke, Mayfra 3166 Kernodle, James 1218 Lynd, J. S 6060 Montgomery , R. 1276 Patten, W. M. 3273 Killen, D L 4400 MacDonald, G. J. 1146 Moore, C. R 1607 Payment, R E 3335 Kincaid, F. 5775 Mace, Teddy C. 2730 Moore, E. S. 2657 Patton, J. W. 5502 King, J. 7872 Mackey, Leonard H. 0103 Moore, G. 5221 Peacock, R. R. 5242 Kennett, James L 0691 Madara, G O. 0362 Moore, Harry J. 0123 Pearson, C. H. 0757 Kipp, R H 9583 Madsen, DeWayne 3784 Moore, L. A. 2783 Pearson, F. M. 4804 Kirkey, C. M 8390 Madson, W. M. 0891 Moore, Russell 5941 Pease, H. E. 7543 Kizer, Andrea 6071 Maez, B. 5731 Morain, R. 7522 Peckmino, R. J 4844 Klerland, Merlin K. 7508 Maher, G T 7833 Morehouse , G. A. 8151 Peckman, P. T. 3566 Klug, G. F. 3616 Mahurin, W. I. 3766 Morns, Mary C. 3509 Pegg, B. V 0841 Knadler, Denman E. 9549 Maio, A. L. 0485 Mort E A. 7680 Pennington , H. L 1071 Knight, D. R. 8325 Malone, R. A. 2135 , Mortenson E. 8343 Penwell, D. E 5915 Knox, E. M. 9199 Manning, Clarence W. 9188 , Morton C W 8312 Perkins, Alice V. 7415 Kochel, W. K. 1574 Mantooth, J. 7811 , Mullen R D 8509 Perkins, Earl R. 2400 Koegel, Gerald 0072 Marchell, J. A 2562 , Mullin E. F 7579 Peters, F. R. 8742 Koegel, Glen 5937 Markus, B. J. 6347 , Munds M. A 3507 Petersen , R. E 1315 Koles, R. W, Jr. 7874 Marshall , C. Warren 3341 , Munsell E. C. 8608 Peterson , B. L. 1831 Koury, A J., Jr. 1872 Martin, F. P. 4937 , Murchison A E. 3904 Peterson , Harold 9779 Krueger, H. R. 2475 Martin, R. J. 9622 , Murphy L P. 0413 Peterson , Leroy H. 9478 Kryzsko, Catherine 3295 Martin , Russell J. 8047 , Mustard, D J 2757 Peterson , Paul W. 5062 Kuhn , M. J 5364 Martin, R. L. 0730 Naehter Mary 5467 Petersons, P. A 5498 Kunz, F. M. 1726 Martin, T. P 0286 , Nagamatsu S. 5592 Petet, Lyle 0684 Landes, I. E. 5101 Martinez, J 1992 , Nagel, R. E. 5397 Petrie, D. L. 6441 Landin, A. R. 3302 Martinez, T O. 8571 Nash L. L. 0409 Phan, Robert 0673 LaPointe, R. A 8348 Marvin, C. A. 5268 , Nash, R. I. 2796 Pidduck, J. B. 3822 Larsen, Gary 1994 Masters, W. F. 2203 Naze, J. T. 4290 Pierce, Helen M. 9575 Larsen, Rodney 8493 Matheson, M. A. 3074 Nelson , Julian M. 2106 Pierce, R K. 0051 Larson, R. H. 1941 Mattfeld, V. C 5683 Nelson, L. R. 5242 Piper, T. A. 0613 Larson, W. A. 7627 May, F. E. 4285 Newell, G. E. 1035 Platt, L. C. 2519 Laudon, H. L. 7339 Mayes, L. C 3559 Newkirk, I. M. 8207 Poindexter, David 9248 Laugen, J. A. 1882 Mayo, G. L. 1197 Newland, M. E. 5914 Pontin , F. 6411 Leadley, G. L. 3335 McBeth, J. 3899 Newman, R. E. 8403 Poore, E. T. 3332 Leasy, L. L 6607 McCabe, Edwin R. 8721 Nelson, L. C 7772 Porter, G. L. 4186 Leathers, James F. 5768 McCallick, B. G. 6032 Nichols, J 0815 Powell , Willis 0741 Leberg, M. M. 3068 McConnell, R. J. 0519 Nicholson, D S. 3291 Prichard, Wm E. 3548 LeBow , James D. 3966 McCrory, Furrell, Jr 5709 Nishimura, J. T 6046 Prince, L. H. 0388 Lee, Allen L 0410 McCulloch, G. H. 4481 Nixon, D. A. 7265 Puett, C. A. 2206 Lee, D. L. 3454 McDaniel, J. R 7268 Norbeck, Jerry 0456 Pugerude, R. L. 4862 Lee, G. K. 0354 McDermid, Edward D. 8446 Norberg, W J. 5263 Puckett , M. J. 7420 456 DECISIONS OF NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD Name Clock Name Clock Puckett, R. F. 5435 Shreve, E. E. 5133 Putts, L C. 0330 Shulkin, M. J. 5636 Raiche, J. G. 6406 Shultz, J M. 2745 Raines, A. F. 8994 Sigvartson, M. 0. 3695 Rappe,J W. 6370 Simmonds, F. L. 4531 Rasmusson, V. E. 1359 Sines, I. R. 0186 Ravander, J. L. 6944 Skog, J A. 6806 Reasor, L. 3142 Skura, V. 2403 Reed, R. H. 4714 Small, S. Reuben 9464 Rehder, D L 5193 Smith, B. J. 8096 Reid, B. G. 5505 Smith, C. 7459 Reid, W E. 7821 Smith, E. R. 7718 Reis, W. F 1382 Smith, Harold E. 4878 Rekow, Herman 2233 Smith, L D. 0852 Replogle, H. W. 0899 Smith, L 1222 Rhine, Viola 6142 Smith, P. D. 3706 Rhoades, G. M. 9382 Smith, R J. 9327 Rice, Evelyn M. 7231 Snow, Richard 5038 Richards, Glenda M. 7094 Snyder, F. J 4445 Richardson, R. W. 7181 Snyder, R. C. 2073 Richardson, Wayne 1995 Solam, I. V. 3804 Ridgedale, Herbert E. 8770 Solis, Israel 9469 Rind, C. H. 0633 Sommerfield, W. G. 16568 Rioux, R. L. 8095 Sondergaard, Donna 5193 Ritchey, C., Jr. 1438 Sorrell, C F 9144 Robbins, Leonard 0061 Speidel, N. J. 2942 Roberts, Gloria 5954 Spencer, F M. 5347 Robinson, Earl 4072 Spivey, Rufus Wm. 7991 Robinson, W. E. 9368 Spliethof, C. H. 4078 Robles, J 7257 Sproge, J. R. 9471 Roeder, Douglas X. 9399 Stair, Frank C 3546 Roesler, E. E. 5250 Staley, M. M. 0122 Roger, J. D. 0689 Stancil, Loreen 5117 Roper, J. F 5818 Stark, D. A. 0980 Ross, F. D. 2428 Stark, D. L. 1719 Ross, R. L. 1141 Steckler, Peter 0746 Rouse, Nelson M. 8725 Stein, Donald V 7503 Rowley, R. L. 2416 Stein, Norma C. 2441 Ruffier, K. P. 2078 Stephens, L. J. 5130 Rustad, T. N. 6483 Stephens, W. H. 0300 Rutledge, R. S 9959 Stephenson, E. L. 5711 Rund, G. S. 8967 Stevens, Kathleen 6816 Russell, Delores 6602 Stewart, H. W 7299 Russell, William 4415 Stice, R. E. 1273 Sabounn, M. L. 3914 Stier, Jean C. 4112 Sackett, E. E. 4010 Stillman, Randle 7428 Sampson, L. W. 6616 Stinnett, M. J. 4513 Sanchez, Lorenzo 4786 Stinson, B. E. 4614 Sandell, W. C. 1518 Stock, A. M. 3900 Sands, Anona C. 9252 Stocking, T J. 7168 Sandvick, G. D. 4962 Stokes, R. K. 9485 Sautell, Walter A. 9369 Stone, M. P. 9717 Scattone, M A. 8141 Stone, Walter M. 8672 Schaut, George L. 4978 Stovall, Ronald 5996 Scharnhorst, W. F. 9134 Streeck, T. F. 6377 Scheller, H. 0. 7911 Strobel, Elmer 0500 Schmitt, R. L. 0419 Suderman, G. H. 9203 Schmidt, Cara P. 3967 Supplee, Daniel 9249 Schmidt, R. M. 2702 Swain, E. M. 7286 Schmidt, W F. 2188 Swanstrom, J. C. 5049 Schollmeyer, J. H. 6068 Swenstad, C. T. 9518 Schrader, L. E. 2955 Tapley, J F. 5036 Schulte, M. 1870 Taylor, B. R. 2578 Schumacher, Michael W. 7613 Taylor, Ervin A. 9007 Schwendiman, Steven 5785 Taylor, J. A. 1435 Schweppe, E. N. 4134 Taylor, M. D. 0705 Scott, Billy E 6943 Taylor, S. A. 7849 Scott, R. E. 8516 Taylor, T. C 8469 Sediver, A. E. 6568 Taylor, W. H. 4116 Seidens, K. L. 1620 Tecca, David 6131 Sexton, R. W. 3576 Temrov, M. B. 9323 Shaum, M. J. 0376 Templeton, M. A. 7256 Shaw, T. J. 9286 Terada, Alvin 3904 Sherman, R E 4948 Ternet, J. L. 6814 Name Clock Name Clock Tervol, R. M. 1861 Welker. Lawanda R. 1437 Thomas, J. W. 6753 Welker, M L. 5880 Thomas, Robert L. 0380 Wells, D. M. 1592 Thomas, Sandra 2500 Wells, D. A. 4191 Thompson, P J. 5481 Wells, W. W. 0700 Thompson, R. B. 2685 Weniger, Harlan 2416 Thompson, W. G. 8594 Werthorst, J. C 7906 Tilbury, V. 8959 Werfhorst, L. V. 2558 Todd, Meritte H. 8778 Wessell, Ralph 9928 Toney, G. H. 8821 West, M. E. 5942 Torkelson, A. B. 8663 West, W. 0032 Townsend, H. G. 3026 Westerman, Louis 6171 Toy, W P. 2817 Wetnck, R. 0. 6490 Tracy, M. R. 3863 Whaley, R. L. 7669 Tranholt, D. H. 3596 Wheaton, L E. 0412 Traylor, C. 6902 Whitbeck, E. J. 4412 Triplett, Robert L. 5875 White, Charles M. 1972 Trunkhill, D. L. 9108 White, D. H. 3347 Tuchrekecer, A. E. 6216 White, Jim 4273 Tuck, R. G. 6858 White, N. C 3064 Tucker, W. L 2120 Whitetree, Mary M. 6331 Tully, M L. 6252 Whitney, Jimmy 5867 Turner, Bobby G. 9916 Whittenberg, H. H. 4126 Turner, E. R. 2226 Wickham, M E. 9585 Turner, G 1685 Wigdahl, L. A. 0639 Turner, W. E. 6736 Wilcox, S. E. 9695 Turner, W. G. 3264 Wileman, R. E. 6473 Tutewiler, P J. 3119 Wiley, W. L. 3670 Tuttle, E. S. 7826 Wilkerson, Pink 9973 Uhl, Donald 8907 Wilkins, Jack 2267 Uhl, R. G. 4448 Williams, Arthur M. 1275 Ullenck, Gary E. 4382 Williams, L. H. 5867 Ullman, E. E. 3292 Williams, Norman 0. 4623 Ulrich, H. J. 3663 Willey, B. M. 6619 Valberg, H. A. 9571 Williams, E. A. 7777 Valente, Frank 0730 Williamson, D. C. 9248 Vance, John L. 0947 Williamson, J. E. 6793 Vandeman, Jack 2316 Wills, B. A. 0574 Van Winkel, J. H. 5822 Wills, R. M. 4105 Vassar, F. D. 0415 Winders, Charles 9702 Veilleux, R. B. 3616 Winter, J. L. 5455 Vernon, J. C. 1813 Winter, L. M. 3452 Vdlmes, B 0. 3522 Winter, R. C. 7303 Vinson, J. V 9449 Wiseman, A L. 0775 Voecks, R. R. 1819 Wiseman, D. M. 4614 Volk, V. P. 7860 Withrow, B. J. 3658 Wachowski, L. J. 7630 Wood, L. A. 5554 Wadsworth, D. A. 0312 Woodland, M. 1745 Wahlgren, R. A. 9116 Woods, B. A. 9310 Wakefield, V. B. 7947 Woods, R A. 3018 Walker, Wanda D 4437 Woodword, R. L. 1074 Walker, W. F., Jr. 4900 Worl, J. M. 6920 Walls, Robert L. 3571 Wray, Raymond 8103 Walters, C. G. 7356 Wurtz, M. G. 2860 Walton, S H 4020 Wyland, Robert L. 0686 Walsh, Lowell James 8961 Wynn, W L. 3998 Wanrow, M. A. 5176 Yadon, C. A. 7412 Wanska, A. M 7372 Yagi, Takeo 5558 Ward, K. L. 8841 Yakel, D. 6311 Warner, G. W. 8822 Yates, H. C. 6374 Warrell, E. E. 3697 Yockey, Clifton T. 9259 Warren, J. C. 1311 Young, B. B. 0803 Washington, C. L 3647 Young, B. 1. 9107 Watanabe, S. 0987 Zanassi, Beatrice V. 9988 Watson, Donna J. 9237 Zaragoza, M. M. 7160 Watts, D. E. 7622 Zatarain, V. W., Jr. 0927 Webb, Judy 6305 Ziegler, P. E. 6146 Webster, G. W. 5172 Zimmerman, David D. 9852 Weir, R. E. 7296 Zirbel, L. B. 1770 Weirauch, 0. Jack 7604 Zitzer, Thomas 5460 Weishaar, G. G. 8673 Zook, R. D. 0331 Welch, R. V. 9377 Zowiski, V. 7183 Welch, Velma R. 2788 AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT LODGE 751 457 APPENDIX B NOTICE TO ALL MEMBERS, OFFICERS, REPRESENTATIVES, AND AGENTS, AND TO ALL EMPLOYEES OF THE BOEING COMPANY Pursuant to the Decision and Order of the National Labor Relations Board and in order to effectuate the policies of the National Labor Relations Act, as amended, we hereby notify you that: WE WILL NOT cause or attempt to cause The Boeing Company to discharge or otherwise discriminate against any employee when such discharge or discrimination would be in violation of Section 8(a)(3) of the Act. WE WILL NOT in any other manner restrain or coerce employees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed in Section 7 of the Act, except to the extent that such rights may lawfully be affected by an agreement requiring membership in a labor organization as a condition of employment, as authorized in Section 8(a)(3) of the Act. Dated AERONAUTICAL INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT LODGE 751 AFFILIATED WITH THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF MACHINISTS & AEROSPACE WORKERS, AFL-CIO (Labor Organization) By (Representative) (Title) This Notice must remain posted for 60 consecutive days from the date of posting, and must not be altered, defaced, or covered by any other material. If members have any question concerning this Notice or compliance with its provisions, they may communicate directly with the Board's Regional Office, 327 Logan Building, 500 Union Street, Seattle, Washington 98101, Telephone 206-583-4532.