86-6
Opinion 86-6
Cite as Idaho Op. Att'y Gen. No. 86-6
JIM JONES
ATTORNEY GENERAL
S T A T E O F I D A H O
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
BOISE 83720
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-6
TO:
The Honorable Larry EchoHawk
Idaho State Representative
1777 Lancaster
Pocatello, Idaho 83201
Per Request for Attorney General's Opinion
OUESTION PRESENTED:
TELEPHONE
(208)
334-2400
Must an electe? representative of the Idaho Legislature resign
from his legislative position prior to assuming the office of
prosecuting attorney within the State of Idaho?
Would that same individual be required to resign from his
position on the 1986 general election ballot as a candidate for a
legislative position?
CONCLUSION:
A prosecuting attorney may not serve as a member of the Idaho
Legislature. Therefore, prior to assuming office as prosecutor, a
legislator must resign from his legislative office.
However, a
prosecutor is not barred from seeking a legislative office.
ANALY S I S :
Idaho Code
§
31-2601 sets forth the qualifications for
prosecuting attorney:
No person shall be eligible to qualify for
the office of prosecuting attorney who is
not an attorney and counselor at law duly
licensed to practice as such in the district
courts of the state at the time he assumes
office
as
prosecuting
attorney.
No
prosecutinq attorney shall hold any o t h E
county or state office during his term of
off ice as prosecuting attorney provided,
however, that a prosecuting attorney or a
deputy prosecuting attorney may be appointed
by
the
attorney
general
as
a
special
assistant
attorney
general
for
the
performance of duties pursuant to
such
appointment in any other county than the
county in which such prosecutor or deputy
prosecutor serves. . . .(emphasis added)
It is axiomatic that where a statute is clear and unambiguous,
the expressed intent of the legislature must be given effect.
Intermountain Health Care v. Board of County Commissioners of
Madison County, 109 Idaho 685, 710 P.2d 595 (1985). It is clear
that the office of prosecuting attorney, in this context, is a
county office.
See Idaho Code S 31-2001.
It is equally clear
that a legislator is a state office holder within the meaning of
Idaho Code S 31-2601,
See Idaho Code S S 67-301, 67-401 et seq.
Therefore, a prosecutor is statutorily barred from serving as a
legislator.
Further, even if Idahc Code S 31-2601 did not bar a prosecutor
from holding a legislative office, it is our opinion that a
prosecutor required to devote full time - to the position of
prosecuting attorney pursuant to Idaho Code S 31-3113 could not
serve as a legislator.
That statute mandates that the Bannock
County Prosecutor devote full tine to the performance of his
official duties. We do not believe that a "full time" prosecutor
could also serve as a "part-timett legislator given the time
requirements imposed upon an Idaho legislator. Because of these
two independent statutory bases, we do not believe it is necessary
to address the potential incompatibility of these two offices,
which could provide yet a third ground for prohibiting an
individual from holding these two offices.
Concerning your second question, we do not find any statutory
or constitutional prohibition that prevents a prosecutor from
seeking a legislative seat.
However, for the reasons set forth
above, once elected the prosecutor would be required to make a
choice between the two offices,
AUTHORITIES CONSIDERED:
1.
S t a t u t e s :
Idaho C o d e § 3 1 - 2 0 0 1
Idaho C o d e § 3 1 - 2 6 0 1
Idaho C o d e § 3 1 - 3 1 1 3
Idaho C o d e §§ 6 7 - 3 0 1 ,
6 7 - 4 0 1 e t seq.
2.
Idaho C a s e s :
F-d
DATED t h i s 3 --
day of J u l y , 1 9 8 6 .
ATTORNEY GENEFPJ;
S t a t e of Idaho
ANALYSIS BY:
PATRICK J. KOLE
C h i e f , L e g i s l a t i v e and
Public A f f a i r s D i v i s i o n