1906-1908 Ind. Op. Att'y Gen. p. 190
1906-1908 Ind. Op. Att'y Gen. p. 190
189, and Winchester Co. v. Veal, 145 Ind. 506, 510, 516.
It is
difficult, if not impossible, to reconcile the latter with the case of
Shelton v. State, supra.
It is much more consistent with true legal principles and
sound morals to regard the treasurer as a fiduciary, and that all
profits realized by him from loaning the public funds, belong
to the public, the real beneficiary.
This view has the support of
respectable authorities.
(Dillon v. Munic. Corps., Sec. 444; Su-
pervisions v. Wandel, 6 Laws, 33, affirmed 59 N. Y. 645; U. S.
v. Mosley, 133 U. S. 273, 287; Wilkesbarre v. Rochafellow, 171
Pa. St. 177, 30 L. R. A. 393; U. S. v. Thomas, 15 Wall, 337 ; State
v. Copeland (Tenn.) 34 S. W. 427; State v. McTetridge (Wis.)
20 L. R. A. 223; State v. Hardsaw (Wis.), 54 S. W. 17; State
v. Windle, 156 Ind. 648).
If such liability on the part of the treasurers exists, as I cou-
sider it does, it can be enforced by suits prosecuted against
them by the state on the relation of the county auditor.
Hunt v. State, 93 Ind. 311;
Gauntt v. State, 81 Ind. 137.
The interest having been received at least by color of office,
the treasurers' bondsmen are also liable therefor.
State v. Walford, 11 Ind. App. 392.
Replying to your questions, my opinion is that suits should be
brought against the treasurers respectively and their bondsmen,
these actions being brought in the name of the state on relation
of the county auditor.
LIBRARY COMMISSION-RAILROAD AND HOTEL EXPEN-
SES OF SECRETARY TO ASHEVILLE, NORTH CARO-
LINA (AMERICAN LIBRARY ASSOCIATION).
May 17, 1907.
Hon. Chalmers Hadley, Secretary Public Library Commission,
Indianapolis, Indiana:
Dear Sir-I am in receipt of your favor of the 16th inst., ask-
ing whether there is any law preventing the public library com-
mission from paying your railroad and hotel bill at the Ameri-
can Library Association at Asheville, North Carolina.
The general appropriation act of 1907 provided that all appro-
priations designated and intended as and for traveling and hotel
expenses for any department should be construed to mean trav-
eling and hotel eypenses within the state of Ipdiana, and not else-
where. The provision made for the public library commission is
$7,000, no part of which is especially designated for traveling
or hotel expenses. My view is-that even if the section first above
mentioned applied to the appropriations for the year 1907 it
would not apply to a case where no specific appropriation for hotel
or traveling expenses is made. You will notice, however, the sec-
tion mentioned above relates to appropriations "herein provided,"
that which was made for the benefit of the public library com-
mission is available after the beginning of the fiscal year in Octo-
ber, 1907. The appropriation under which the commission is now
acting is that made in 1905, and the latter statute contains no
restriction as to traveling or hotel expenses.
I am therefore of the opinion that there was nothing passed
at the recent session of the legislature to prevent the payment
of your railroad expenses and your hotel bill at the meeting
of the American Library Association at Asheville, North Carolina.
INDIANA GIRLS' SCHOOL-INSTALLATION OF "BOILER,
ENGINE AND GENERATOR,"
ETC.
May 17, 1907.
Mr. Samuel Shutt, Chief Engineer, State House:
Dear Sir-Your verbal request for my opiuion as to whether
the board of trustees of the Indiana Girls' School were authorized
to expend the appropriation made by the act of 1907 (Acts 1907,
p. 669) for "furnishing and installing boiler, engine and genera-
tor, switch board and all necessary appliances, equipments, mate-
rials and labor" without first receiving competitive bids, after
notice given, or whether the board could legally purchase and
have installed such boiler, etc., the same as an individual might
do.
Among other items appropriated I notice the following,
specific:
"One new cottage, twenty-five thousand dollars; two
employes' cottages for men, at two thousand dollars each,
four thousand dollars; cow barn and horse barn, three
thousand dollars; storehouse and cold storage, six thou-
sand five hundred dollars; fence, two thousand dollars;
hennery and piggery, five hundred dollars; grading walks,