No. 7-73
The Board of Trustees of the Firemen’s and Police Pension Fund of the City of Jennings , Missouri, organized pursuant to Section 86.583, RSMo 1969, (1) cannot apply the funds of such system toward the purchase of accidental death or permanent total disability insurance policies, but (2) can enter into a contract with an insurance company whereby the insurance company would hold the funds of the system in a “separate account” and would invest same as authorized by Section 376.309 (4), RSMo 1969.
Cite as Mo. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 7-73
INSURANCE:
PENSIONS:
RETIREMENT:
CITIES, TOWNS & VILLAGES:
The Board of Trustees of the Fire-
men's and Police Pension Fund of
the City of Jennings, Missouri, or-
ganized pursuant to Section 86.583,
RSMo 1969, (1) cannot apply the
funds of such system toward the purchase of accidental death or
permanent total disability insurance policies, but (2) can enter
into a contract with an insurance company whereby the insurance
company would hold the funds of the system in a "separate ac-
count'' and would invest same as authorized by Section 376.309
(4), RSMo 1969.
OPINION NO. 7
June 19, 1973
Honorable James P. Mulvaney
State Representative, District 61
317 State Capitol Building
Jefferson City, Missouri
65101
Dear Representative Mulvaney:
FILE 0
w
This official opinion is issued in response to your inquir-
ies addressed to the Attorney General's Office which follow:
"Does the Board of Trustees of the Firemen
and Police Pension Fund of the City of Jen-
nings, Missouri have authority to (1) pur-
chase insurance against accidental death or
permanent total disability on its covered
employees, and (2) enter into a pension con-
tract with a life insurance company whereby
the funds of the pension plan would be in-
vested in the insurance company's fixed in-
come account which consists principally of
investments in corporate bonds and mortgages?"
Section 86.583, RSMo 1969, permits certain municipalities
to establish police and firemen's pension systems.
We quote:
"Any municipality in any county of the first
class, and any other municipality in this
state which now contains or may hereafter
contain not more than one hundred thousand
inhabitants nor less than three thousand
inhabitants as determined by the last preced-
ing federal census is hereby authorized to
Honorable James P. Mulvaney
provide for the pensioning of the salaried
members of its organized police force or fire
department and the widows and minor children
of deceased members; . .. "
The remainder of Section 86.583 provides how such pension sys-
tems may be established.
Your inquiry indicates that the City of
Jennings has complied with this section to create its Police and
Firemen's Pension Fund.
Section 86.590, RSMo 1969, authorizes the board of trustees
of such a pension fund to invest the moneys thereof as follows:
"The board of trustees of police and fire-
men's pension systems, established under the
provisions of section 86.583, may invest and
reinvest the moneys of the system, and may
hold, purchase, sell, assign, transfer or
dispose of any of the securities and invest-
ments in which such moneys shall have been
invested, as well as the proceeds of such
investments and such moneys; except that such
investment and reinvestments shall be subject
to all the terms, conditions, limitations,
and restrictions imposed by law upon life and
casualty companies in the state of Missouri
in making and disposing of their investments,
except that the percentage limitations of
subsection 2 of section 376.305, RSMo, shall
not apply; and except that the system shall
not increase its common stock investments by
more than four percent of its assets in any
one fiscal year after its first fiscal year."
Disposing of your second inquiry first, we shall answer the
question whether the board of trustees of a firemen's and police
pension fund may "enter into a pension contract with a life in-
surance company whereby the funds of the pension plan would be
invested in the insurance company's fixed income account which
consists principally of investments in corporate bonds and
mortgages?"
Mr. Lloyd E. Eaker, Jennings city attorney and attorney
for the Board of Trustees of the Police and Firemen's Retirement
Fund of Jennings, has informed us that this particular question
contemplates that the Board of Trustees would enter into an in-
vestment contract with an insurance company whereby the insurance
company would hold and invest the funds made available under the
contract pursuant to the "separate account'' provisions of Sec-
tion 376 . 309 , RSMo 1969.
That section defines a "separate
account" of an insurance company as one
-
2 -
Honorable James P. Mulvaney
" .•. into which any amounts paid to or
held by such company under applicable con-
tracts are credited and the assets of which,
subject to the provisions of this section ,
may be invested in such investments as shall
be authorized by a resolution adopted by such
company's board of directors ....
"
All income, gains, or losses realized on such a separate account
are cr edit ed to the account only without regard to other assets
of the company.
Likewise, such accounts are not chargeable with
the liabilities arising out of other business the company con-
ducts.
Subsection 2 of that statute provides:
"Any domestic life insurance company may,
after adoption of a resolution by its board
of directors, establish one or more separate
accounts, and may allocate to such account
or accounts any amounts paid to or held by
it which are to be applied under the terms
of an individual or group contract to pro-
vide benefits payable in fixed or in vari-
able dollar amounts or in both."
The language of the statute indicates that the primary purpose
of "separ ate accounts" is to segregate from the other business
of the insurance company investment contracts such as the pension
investment contract which is the subject of your inquiry.
Please
note that subsection 3 of Section 376.309 would author ize an in-
surance company to give the members of a pension fund, such as
the one in question, some control over the separate account which
includes said fund.
Subsection 4 provides how amounts included
in such accounts can be invested.
That subsection provides that:
"The amounts allocated to each such account
and accumulations thereon may be invested
and reinvested in any kind or type of in-
vestment authorized for life insurance com-
panies by the statutes of this state, but
the investment shall not be included or
taken into account in applying the limita-
tions established in sections 375.330 , 376.
300, 376.301 , 376.303, 376.305, and 376.307
to the general investment account of any
company; provided, that to the extent that
the company's reserve liability with regard
to (1) benefits guaranteed as to principal
amount and duration, and (2) funds guaran-
teed as to principal amount or stated rate
-
3 -
Honorable James P. Mulvaney
of interest, is maintained in any separate
account a portion of the assets of such sep-
arate account at least equal to such reserve
liability shall be, except as the superinten-
dent of insurance might otherwise approve,
invested in accordance with the laws of this
state governing the general investment ac-
count of any company.
As used herein, the
expression 'general investment account' shall
mean all of the funds, assets and investments
of the company which are not allocated in a
separate account.
The provisions of section
376.170 relating to deposits for registered
policies shall not be applicable to funds
and investments allocated to separate ac-
counts.
No investment in the separate ac-
count or in the general investment account
of a life insurance company shall be trans-
ferred by sale, exchange, substitution or
otherwise from one account to another . "
An investment in a "separate account", therefore, would com-
ply with the generic requirement of Section 86 . 590 , that the in-
vestment and reinvestment of pension funds be consistent with
the legal requirements imposed upon the investments of life and
casualty companies.
Any contract executed between t he board of directors of the
pension fund in question and an insurance company should include
the 4% common stock increase limitation set forth in Section
86 . 590.
This inclusion would be consistent with the establish-
ment of a "fixed income account" which we assume refers to in-
vestments in debt securities paying a fixed rate of return which
would not include investments in common stock.
The contract
should also include a provision that the trustees have the power
to terminate the contract and resume custody of the funds or
securities involved upon r easonable notice given to the insurance
company.
This provision would enable the trustees to retain the
power to "invest and reinvest " the funds of the system as autho-
rized by Section 86.590.
We conclude that the Board of Trustees of the Firemen's and
Police Pension Fund of the City of Jennings, Missouri, can enter
into a contract with an insurance company whereby the funds of
the pension system would be held in a "separate account" of the
insurance company and would be invested by the insurance company
subject to the limitations and restrictions imposed upon by law
upon the investment s of life and casualty companies .
The use
of the "separate account" devise is a reasonable and permissible
exercise of the trustees' discretion and authority with regard
to investments conferred by Section 86 .590, RSMo 1969.
- 4 -
Honorable James P. Mulvaney
Your first inquiry asks whether the board of trustees of a
firemen's and police pension fund may "purchase insurance against
accidental death or permanent total disability on its covered
employees."
The General Assembly of the state of Missouri, by
means of Section 86.590, RSMo 1969, has expressly confined the
authority of the board of trustees of the police and firemen's
pension system, to the investment and reinvestment of the moneys
of the system.
The legislature has not authorized the purchase
of insurance against accidental death or permanent total dis-
ability.
We conclude that because of the specific requirement
in Section 86.590, that the funds of a police and firemen's pen-
sion system be invested and reinvested, there has been granted
no authority by law for the trustees of such a system to purchase
insurance policies against accidental death or permanent total
disability on its covered employees.
CONCLUSION
It is the opinion of this office that the Board of Trustees
of the Firemen's and Police Pension Fund of the City of Jennings,
Missouri, organized pursuant to Section 86.583, RSMo 1969, (1)
cannot apply the funds of such system toward the purchase of
accidental death or permanent total disability insurance policies,
but (2) can enter into a contract with an insurance company where-
by the insurance company would hold the funds of the system in a
"separate account" and would invest same as authorized by Sec-
tion 376.309(4), RSMo 1969.
The foregoing opinion, which I hereby approve, was prepared
by my assistant, Michael L. Boicourt.
Very truly yours,
~
.. J.._f-~
JOHN C. DANFORTH
Attorney General
-
5 -