No. 15-78
The provisions of Section 411.150, RSMo 1969, allow the director of the Department of Agriculture to set fees for grain inspection and sampling services either on a uniform basis throughout the state or on a separate basis at each grain inspection location, based on the administrative expenses at that location, so long as the revenues produced from the fees meet the costs and expenses of administering Chapter 411.
Cite as Mo. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 15-78
AGRICULTURE:
The provisions of Section 411.150,
RSMo 1969, allow the director of
the Department of Agriculture to set fees for grain inspection
and sampling services either on a uniform basis throughout the
state or on a separate basis at each grain inspection location,
based on the administrative expenses at that location, so long
as the revenues produced from the fees meet the costs and
expenses of administering Chapter 411.
OPINION NO. 15
April 13, 1978
FILED
Jack Runyan, Director
Department of Agriculture
15
1300 Jefferson Building
Jefferson City, Missouri 65101
Dear Mr. Runyan:
This is in response to your recent opinion request which
states:
"I request your legal opinion pertaining
to whether the Director must fix fees for
services performed by the Grain Inspection
and Weighing Division on a uniform basis
throughout the State, or may he fix fees
in different parts of the state to generate
revenue to pay for our cost pertaining to
that area of the State."
Chapter 411, RSMo, provides a comprehensive procedure for
inspection, grading and weighing of grain in the state of Missouri,
under the standards established by the United States Grain Stan-
dards Act (7 U.S.C. §§ 71-87h). We understand from your request
that the Missouri Department of Agriculture has been designated
the "official agency" for grain inspection and weighing under
the provisions of 7 U.S.C. §§ 79-79 (a) and that official inspection
locations have been designated in the state of Missouri by the
administrator of the Federal Grain Inspection Service of the
United States Department of Agriculture, pursuant to 7 U.S.C. § 79.
We have previously construed the provisions of Chapter 411,
RSMo, in Opinion No. 37, issued February 2, 1967, copy enclosed,
which held that pursuant to Section 411.150, RSMo Supp. 1965
Mr. Jack Runyan
(now Section 411.150, RSMo 1969) fees for services rendered under
Chapter 411 are to be set by the commissioner (now director) of
the Department of Agriculture for the purpose of producing suffi-
cient revenue to meet the necessary expenses of administering
Chapter 411. The intent of Section 411.150 is that administration
of the Missouri Grain Warehouse Law be self-sustaining through
the collection of fees.
We understand from your request that fees for sampling,
inspection, weighing, protein and chemical analysis, moisture
testing and other services consistent with the provisions of
Sections 411.010 to 411.701, RSMo, are uniformly fixed and applied
throughout the state so that the revenue collected from the fees
meet the necessary expenses of statewide administration of the
Grain Inspection Law. However, we further understand that the
administration expenses of several official inspection locations
exceed the revenues collected from each location, whereas the
administration expenses in the remaining locations are less than
the revenues collected at those locations. We believe your
request to be whether the fees charged for the various services
enumerated above may be fixed at each official inspection loca-
tion so that the fees collected at that inspection point meet
the expenses of inspection provided by the Department at that
location.
Section 411.150 provides in part:
"1. The commissioner shall have full
power to fix the fees for sampling, inspec-
tion, weighing, protein or other chemical
analysis, and moisture testing or for addi-
tional services of whatever nature consistent
with the provisions of sections 411.010 to
411.701, which fees shall be regulated in
such manner as will, in the judgment of the
commissioner, produce sufficient revenue to
meet the necessary expenses of the services
of sampling, inspection, weighing, chemical
analysis or moisture testing, and for admin-
istration and clerical work in connection
therewith."
A primary rule of statutory construction is to ascertain
the intent of the legislature in enacting the interpreted statute
so as to promote the object and purpose of the act. State ex rel.
Zoological Park Subdistrict of the City and County of St. Louis
V. Jordan, 521 S.W.2d 369 (Mo. 1975). This requires review of
- 2 -
Mr. Jack Runyan
the language of the statute giving the words used therein their
plain and ordinary meaning. State V. Kraus, 530 S.W.2d 684
(Mo. Banc 1975).
Following these rules of construction, it appears clear
from the express language of the statute that the sole requirement
placed on the director of the Department of Agriculture in setting
fees is that the fees produce sufficient revenue to meet the
expenses of providing services at the inspection locations. The
manner in which fees will be set has been left to the discretion
and judgment of the director, so long as fee revenues meet the
expenses of inspection. It is therefore our opinion that the
director may, pursuant to Section 411.150, set fees for grain
inspection and sampling services either on a uniform basis
throughout the state or on a separate basis at each location,
so long as the revenues produced from the fees meet the expenses
of location. administering Chapter 411 on a statewide basis or at each
As mentioned previously, we understand that the Missouri
Department of Agriculture has been designated the "official
agency" for grain inspection and weighing under the provisions
of the United States Grain Standards Act (7 U.S.C. §§ 71-87h).
Section 79 (f) (1) (A) (v) of that Act requires that the official
agency show to the satisfaction of the administrator of the
Federal Grain Inspection Service that it "will not charge offi-
cial inspection fees that are discriminatory or unreasonable."
7 U.S.C. § 79 (f) (1) (A) (v). While we expressly decline to
of fees by the Department of Agriculture pursuant to Section
construe the provisions of this section as applied to the setting
411.150, we would advise that you consult with the administrator
prior to making judgment on the future setting of fees.
CONCLUSION
It is the opinion of this office that the provisions of
Section 411.150, RSMo 1969, allow the director of the Department
of Agriculture to set fees for grain inspection and sampling
services either on a uniform basis throughout the state or on
a separate basis at each grain inspection location, based on
the administrative expenses at that location, so long as the
revenues produced from the fees meet the costs and expenses of
administering Chapter 411.
- 3 -
Mr. Jack Runyan
The foregoing opinion, which I hereby approve, was prepared
by my assistant, Greg Hoffmann.
Very truly yours,
John ashcroft
JOHN ASHCROFT
Attorney General
Enclosure: Op. No. 37
2/2/67, Davis
- 4 -