No. 16-79
169.410 through 169.540 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, as amended, do not allow the Board of Trustees of the Public School Retirement System of the City of St. Louis to establish a life insurance program for its active members and/or retirees.
Cite as Mo. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 16-79
PENSIONS:
PUBLIC SCHOOL RETIREMENT SYSTEM:
ST . LOUIS CITY SCHOOL RETIREMENT SYSTEM:
Sections 169.410 through
169.540 of the Revised
Statutes of Missouri, as
amended , do not allow
the Doard of Trustees of the Public School Retirement System of th0
City of St . Louis to establish a life insurance program for its
nctivc members and/or retirees.
OPINION NO . 16
January 25, 1979
Honorable Thomas A. Villa
State Representative, District 103
Room 414
State Capitol Building
Jefferson City, Missouri
65101
Dear Representative Villa:
This letter is in response to your request for an opinion
which reads as follows :
"Do Sections 169.410 to 169.540 of the
Revised Statutes of Missouri authorize the
noard of Trustees of the Public School Re-
tirement System for the City of St . Louis
to establish a life insurance program for
its active members and/or retirees?"
In your opinion request, it is also indicated that the Board
of Trustees of the Public School Retirement System for the City
of St . Louis is considering a proposal to purchase term or other
life insurance on the life of each active member and retiree,
and that the costs of purchasing these policies would be covered
out of the earnings of the assets of the retirement system.
Pres-
ently , the Board of Trustees does not anticipate that any addi-
tional contributions from members or retirees of the Public School
Retirement System for the City of St. Louis would be made to cover
the cost of this insurance.
Section 169.420 , Senate Bill No . 542 of the 79th General
Asserrtbly , Second Regular Session, establishes retirement systems
Honorable Thomas A. Villa
in school districts having a population of seven hundred thousand
(700 , 000) or more inhabitants " ... for the purpose of provid-
ing retirement allowances for employees of said school districts .
"
(Emphasis added.)
Section 169 .410(20), Senate Bill No. 542 of the 79th General
Assembly, Second Regular Session , defines the term retirement
allowance as follows :
"'Retirement allowance ' shall mean equal
monthly payments for life to a retirant or to
such beneficiary as is entitled to same as
provided herein; "
(Emphasis added . )
The courts of this state have consistently applied the prin-
cipl e of maximum expressio unius est exclusio alterius .
Thus ,
the Supreme Court has held :
" .. When , ... ' a statute enumerates the
subjects or things on which it is to operate,
or the persons affected , or forbids certain
things , it is to be construed as excluding
from its effect all those not expressly
mentioned; ... "
Giloti ~ Hamm-Singer
Corp., 396 S.W. 2d 711, 713 (Mo. 1965).
Sec <1lso Brown v. Morris , 290 S .W . 2d 160 (Mo . bane 1956);
Kt-O<JCr C£OCcry ~ I1ak1ng Co .
y~ City of St. Louis, 106 S.W.2d
435 (Mo. 1937); DePoortere ~Commerc ial Credit Corp ., 500 S.W.2d
724 (Mo.Ct.App. at Spr. 1973).
llere , the legislature has expressly stated that the purpose
of the retirement system is to provide retirement allowances,
that is, equal monthly payments for life to retirees or entitled
beneficiaries.
In expressing the retirement system purpose thus-
ly, the legislature excluded all other purposes by omission .
Where the legislature has intended for retirement systems
to purchase life insurance on members, it has expressly so
stated :
"The state highway commission may con-
tribute toward . .. life insurance benefits
. . . for e ach employee who is a member of
the state highway employees ' and highway
patrol retirement system ...
. "
Section
104.270 , RSMo Supp. 1977.
-
2 -
Honorable Thomas A. Villa
iliH.i 1
"The board s haJ l provide or con t ~- .-t e l fo r
li fe ins urance benef its for employees [who
arc members of the Missouri state employees '
r e tireme nt system] ..
. "
Section 104 . 515.2,
Senate Bill No. 497, 79th General Assembly,
Second Regular Se ssion.
CONCLUSION
It is therefore the opinion of this office that Sections
169 .410 through 169.540 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, as
amended , do not allow the Board of Trustees of the Public School
Retirement System of the City of St. Louis to establish a life
insurance program for its active members and/or retirees .
The forcqoing opinion , whic h I here by approve , was prepare d
by my a ssi s tan t , Edward D. Ro be rts on, Jr .
Ve ry truly yours ,
J OHN ASHCROFT
Attorney General
-
3 -