15-316
Montana Attorney General Opinion 15-316
Length: 201 wordsOfficial source
Cite as 15 Mont. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 316
Opinion No. 316
Warehouses-Statutes-Conflict of
Laws-Federal Warehous.e Act,.
HELD: The State laws
~oyernil1g
warehouses are supreme and will gOY-
ern when in conflict with Federal Ware-
house Act.
August 21, 19.33.
You request my opinion relath'e to
an alleged conflict between the Federal
Warehouse Act, sections 241. et seq.
U. S. C. A. Tit. 7., and the laws of
Montana relating to warehouses and
warehousemen.
The Federal Law recognizes the
state's control in all such matters with-
in the police power of the state. (Inde-
pendent G. & ,V. Co. v. Dunwoodr, 40
Fed. (2) 1; Merchants Exchange Y.
~1issouri, 248 U. S. 365, 63 L. Ed. 300:
American Manuf. Co. v. St. Louis. 250
U. S. 459, 63 L. Ed. 1084.) In the Inde-
pendent G. & W. Co. case the court. in
construing the Federal Warehouse Act
recited a portion of the Act as follows:
"Nothing in this chapter shall be con-
strued to conflict with * * * or in any
way to impair or limit the effect or
operation of the laws of any state re-
lating- to warehouses, warehousemen,"
etc.
'l'he Act, further, authori7~s the
Secretan' of Agriculture to cooperate
with state officials in the matter.