15-33
Montana Attorney General Opinion 15-33
Length: 787 wordsOfficial source
Cite as 15 Mont. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 33
Opinion No. 33
County ·Conunissioners-Per Diem-
E)..'penses-Lobbying.
HIDLD: A member of the Board of
County Commissioners has no right to
attend the legislative session at Helena,
at the expense of the county, including
OPIXIOXS OF TI-m A'l"l'UHXEY UEXEHAL
35
per diem. to look after a bill in whicb
the coun ty is in terested.
January 20, 19aB.
You have asked for an opinion from
this office as to the ri~ht of a member
of the board of county commissioners
to attend the legislative session at Hel-
ena, aot the expense of the county, in-
eiU(ling per diem, to look after a bill
before the assembly in which the county
is interested, and bearing upon this
question, we cite
YOIl the following
statutes and decisions.
Section 1632, R. C. M., 1921, as amend-
ed hy Chapter 1i6, Laws of 1929; Sec-
tion 443 R. C. 1\1., 1921, as amended by
Chapter 48, Laws of 192i, and as fur-
ther amended by Chapter 86, Laws of
1n31; and Section 460i, R. C. M., 1921,
set forth the rights of county commis-
sioners to compensation for senices.
Under the construction of these stat-
utes, we conclude that a member of the
board of county commissioners is not
l'ntitled to any compensation for any
se1'\'ices that he might assume to ren-
der ,to the county, except those set out
in the pro\'isions of the statutes cited,
nnd, as you will note, taking any part
in legislation and having the county
hear the expense of the party who as-
sumes to look after the interest of the
county in the assembly in relation to
any bill hefore the assembly affecting
the county, is not one of the duties enu-
merMed as the duty of any member of
the board of county commissioners, ]]01'
is the expense connected with any such
activity authorized to be paid out of
county funds.
In the case of State vs. Story, 53
;\Iont. 5i3, 583, the court used this
language: "It may be said that, as re-
slIects per diem, a commissioner may
receive $8 per day for each day's at-
tendance upon sessions of the board and
for each day hriven to inspection of
llontract roadwork under order of the
b()ard, but shaIl receive no othel' com-
pensation. In e\'ery instance his claim
must be verified as other claims."
The amendments to the Codes as set
uut abo\'e, have been made since the
deei.sion in State vs. Story, and change
slightly the right of the members of the
board to perform services at the ex-
pense of the county. This is true in
regard to granting a member of the
board the right to attend certain meet-
ings at the expense of the county, hut
there is nothing in the statute justify-
ing a member of the board drawing ex-
penses and per diem for rendering any
such senice as that to which you refer.
Opinion No, 35
Counties-Pool'-l\fedical Aid and Hos-
pitalization-Publication of Proceed-
ings of County Commissioners'
Meetings,
HELD: The cuunty must give med-
ical aid and hospitalization to poor
persons, even though such persons re-
".ide in an incorporated town, since the
poor of a city are a coullty charge.
It is mandatory upon the board of
c'Ounty commissioners to publish the
proceedings of their meetJings in the
county newspaper.
February 18, 1!)33.
You ha\'e requested an opinion of this
office on the following questions: "1.
Is a county compelled to give medical
aid and hospitalization ,to anyone living
in an incorporated town? 2. Would the
poor of a city become a county charge'!
3. Is it compulsory for a county to have
minutes of commissioners' proceedings
published in a local newspaper?"
In reply to the first question, your a t-
tention is called to Section 4465, R. C.
)1., Hl21, as Hmended by Chapter 1)5 of
the Session Laws of 1!l23. The fore-
Iwing provisions of the Codes and the
Session Laws relate to the general
powers of the board of county commi.s-
sioners, and subdi\'isions 5 and I) of
such powers are as follows:
"5.
To provide for the Cll re and
maintenance of the indigent "ick or
the otherwi'se dependent poor of the
county; erect and maintain hospitals
therefor, or otherwise pro\'ide for the
same; ... "
"9. To cause to be erected and fur-
nished a court house, jail, hospital.
and such other public buildings liS
may be necessary."
'E\'ery city within any county is.
of course, a part of that county and liS
the law places the care of the poor and
their hospitalization under certain cir-
cumstances entirely upon the county.
there i.s no duty imposed upon the city
to look after or care for the poor.