16-23
Montana Attorney General Opinion 16-23
Length: 440 wordsOfficial source
Cite as 16 Mont. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 23
Opinion No. 23.
License-Wholesale Dealers-
Dealers in Hay.
HELD: Persons dealing in hay at
wholesale, are wholesale dealers with-
in the meaning of Chapter 164, Laws
of 1933.
January 4,1935.
Mr. Geo. L. Knight
Chief, Division of Horticulture
Missoula, Montana
You have stated that a number of
complaints have been made about the
practice of certain parties in the State
of Montana buying hay in large quan-
tities and evading payment for all or
part of the hay purchased, and you
have asked whether persons dealing
in hay at wholesale come within the
provisions of Chapter 164, Laws of
1933, which provides for the licensing
and bonding of dealers at wholesale.
Section 1 of this Act provides:
"For the purpose of this Act any
person who shall buy to sell at whole-
sale, or contract to buy to sell at
wholesale, or who shall handle at
wholesale for the purpose of resale, or
who shall handle at wholesale on ac-
count of, or as agent for another, any
produce as herein defined, * * * ."
Section 3. a. of the Act, reads:
"The term 'produce' as used in this
Act shall mean and include the na-
tural products of the farm, the na-
tural products of the orchard, vine-
yard, garden and apiary, raw and
manufactured; (except grains, dairy
products, livestOCk, poultry and poul-
try products), when handled for the
purpose of resale."
Undoubtedly, hay is a natural prod-
uct of the farm. If it is, since it is
not grain, which is expressly excepted,
we see no reason why dealers in hay
at wholesale, as specified in Section
1 above, would not be within the
meaning of the Act. If it was the in-
tention of the legislature to except
hay, it should have done so as it did
in excepting grain. The intention of
the legislature is to be obtained pri-
marily from the language of the stat-
ute.
(59 C. J. 962, Section 569.).
OPINIONS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
21
Where the language of a statute is
plain and unambiguous, there is no
occasion for construction. The stat-
ute must be given effect according to
its plain and obvious meaning, and
the court cannot speculate as to what
might have been in the mind of the
legislature, but which was not ex-
pressed in the statute. To do so would
be assuming legislative authority.
(Id.)
The words of Sections 1 and 3.a. of
Chapter 164, are plain and unambigu-
ous.
I am therefore of the opinion
that dealers in hay at wholesale are
within the terms of the Act.
Note: See Opinion No. 247, this
volume.