44-110
Taxation
Cite as N.D. Op. Att'y Gen. 44-110
OPINION
44-110
February 8, 1944
(OPINION)
TAXATION
RE: Nonprofit Co-ops
Your letter of February fourth addressed to the Attorney General has been received, in
which you ask for our construction of chapter 266 of the Session Laws of 1943, classifying
personal property of rural electric cooperatives for the purpose of taxation.
Section 1 of said Act provides that:
"The property of nonprofit cooperative corporations engaged in the
distribution, transmission and/or generation of electrical energy for
consumption in rural areas is hereby expressly classified as personal
property for the purpose of taxation."
Section 2 enumerates specific property which shall be included in the classification of
personal property, such as poles, wires, lines, transformers, generating equipment,
meters, machinery, buildings and substations used for housing such equipment and office
fixtures of every character used in connection with the cooperative business.
You request our opinion with reference t electric cooperatives which have established
retail outlets for electrical equipment; that is, as to whether such equipment in these retail
stores is covered by this exemption or should be assessed locally and taxed in the same
manner as the stock of goods and merchandise of other dealers.
Section 2 to which we have referred, specifically includes the items therein mentioned in
the classification, with all other personal property of the cooperative corporations
mentioned in said Act, and therefor, are not subject to separate taxation as personal
property.
Section 4 provides the method of taxation of such cooperative corporations and provides
specifically that the tax levied as therein provided shall be in lieu of any other taxes levied
on the personal property of such cooperatives.
It is our opinion, therefor, that the stocks of goods kept for sale at retail by such
cooperative corporations are not subject to separate assessment for the reason that the
tax upon gross receipts provided for in section 4 is in lieu of all other taxes which otherwise
might be levied upon personal property; but the gross income from the sale of such stocks
of goods should be included in the gross receipts provided for in section 4, upon which the
tax levy is computed.
ALVIN C. STRUTZ
Attorney General