46-89
Education
Cite as N.D. Op. Att'y Gen. 46-89
OPINION
46-89
April 26, 1946 (OPINION)
EDUCATION
RE: Board of Higher - Trust Fund
This is in reply to your letter of April 3 asking for our opinion
on two propositions; namely:
1. May the State Board of Higher Education authorize the
institutions under its jurisdiction to set up on their
books a local trust fund to which will be credited the
payments from the Veterans Administration and expended for
the maintenance under such rules and regulations as may be
prescribed by the Board? (As a matter of accounting
procedure the Board would likely direct that $45.00 and
$60.00, whichever the case may be, will be deposited with
the State Treasurer as an institutional collection and the
difference between this figure and the amount received from
the Veterans Administration deposited in the local trust
fund.)
2. With reference to the handling of institutional collections
at the state institutions, the Legislature estimates the
amount of same and deducts such amount from the total
amount of the appropriation. In other words, the
Legislature estimates the amount of institutional
collections and makes an appropriation for the balance
necessary for the maintenance of the institutions for the
biennium. May the state board of higher education
authorize the institutions to set aside in a local trust
fund the excess of institutional collections and expend the
same for purposes similar to those suggested in proposition
No. 1?
Subdivision (e) of section 6 of the constitutional amendment which
establishes the board of higher education provides that the said
board, "shall have the control of the expenditure of the funds
belonging to, and allocated to such institutions and also those
appropriated by the Legislature, for the institutions of higher
education in this State; provided, however, that funds appropriated
by the Legislature and specifically designated for any one or more of
such institutions, shall not be used for any other institution."
You will note that the constitutional amendment quoted vests the
state board of higher education with broad powers. It shall have the
control of the expenditure of the funds belonging to and allocated to
such institutions and also those appropriated by the Legislature.
The Legislature may appropriate any sum deemed necessary for the
maintenance of the several state institutions, but it would appear
that the Legislature has no control over other institutional funds.
Or, stating it differently, the Legislature, of course, has control
over all funds raised by any method of taxation, but the board of
higher education has the control of other funds such as institutional
collections, income and interest which under the constitution belong
to and are allocated to the several state institutions.
The funds referred to in your first proposition are received, as I
understand it, from the Veterans Administration and are not the
proceeds of taxation by the state or its political subdivisions.
Therefore, the funds and the expenditure of the name would be
entirely within the control of the state board of higher education.
If it is the purpose of the state board of higher education to set up
or establish a trust fund from a portion of the institutional
collections and other institutional incomes, it is our opinion that
such board has a right under its constitutional powers to do so, and
has full power to disburse such funds for the maintenance and
legitimate expenditures of the institutions.
It should be observed, however, that if the Legislature should be of
the opinion that the board of higher education is taking too many
liberties with the institutional collections by expanding the
activities of the several state institutions, the Legislature may
reduce the appropriations to an extent which will require the board
of higher education to resort to the institutional collections for
general maintenance purposes.
We do not doubt, however, that a proper equilibrium will be
maintained by the board of higher education in making use of the
institutional collections, and that such funds will be expended for
only such purposes as are appropriate and necessary in maintaining
the educational standards of the institutions.
I believe that the foregoing discussion answering your first
proposition will also answer your second proposition.
NELS G. JOHNSON
Attorney General