46-282
Teachers' Retirement Fund
Cite as N.D. Op. Att'y Gen. 46-282
OPINION
46-282
February 1, 1946 (OPINION)
TEACHERS' RETIREMENT FUNDS
RE: Benefits - How Calculated
This office is in receipt of your letter of January 28, 1946, in
which you say that the teachers insurance and retirement law provides
that the minimum annuity which may be paid to a retired teacher is
$350.00; that a teacher is interested in knowing what she would
receive if she should retire at the age of fifty. You say: "We find
that computing it actuarially she would get $316.52 which is less
than the minimum. The puzzle for which we need your solution is
would we be allowed to give her at fifty the actuarial equivalent of
what she would get a fifty-five? If so, $316.52 is less than the
minimum set by law."
Subsection 1 of section 15-3928 of the 1943 Revised Code provides
that if a teacher shall have attained the age of fifty-five years at
the time of applying for an annuity, such teacher is entitled to
receive the annuity prescribed in said subsection, which shall not be
less than $350.00. In other words, in order to be entitled to an
annuity in the amount of $350.00, event though such amount is in
excess of "one-fiftieth of her average annual salary for the years of
service for which assessments were paid, multiplied by the whole
number of years of service as a teacher," applicant for the annuity
must have attained the age of fifty-five years. The minimum fixed by
subsection 1 of section 15-3928 of the Revised Code clearly applies
only to teachers who have attained the age of fifty-five.
If a teacher applies for an annuity before she is fifty-five years of
age, then the amount thereof must be determined on the actuarial
basis provided in subsection 2 of section 15-3928. Therefore, if
$316.52 is the actuarial equivalent of the annuity the teacher
referred to in your letter would receive at the age of fifty-five,
then, in my opinion, that is the amount to which she will be entitled
if she retires when she is fifty years old.
NELS G. JOHNSON
Attorney General