05-001
(1) Whether the Nebraska Environmental Trust Board may invest the Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund in a portfolio which contains investments which may return capital gains or dividends. (2) Whether the Nebraska Environmental Trust Board may allocate earnings of the Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund which are not interest income, but instead are capital gains or dividends, pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81 -15,174.01
Cite as Neb. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 05-001
JON BRUNIN G
ATIORNEY GENERAL
SUBJECT:
STATE OF NEBRASKA
<!&ffire of tbe ~ttornep ~eneral
2115 STATE CAPITOL BUILDING
LINCOLN, NE 68509-8920
(402) 471-2682
TDD (402) 471-2682
CAPITOL FAX (402) 471-3297
K STREET FAX {402) 471 -4725
ff0500 L
NO.
STATE OF NEBRASKA
OFFICIAL
JAN 12 2003
DEPT. OF JUSTICE
(1) Whether the Nebraska Environmental Trust Board may invest
the Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund in a portfolio which
contains investments which may return capital gains or dividends.
(2) Whether the Nebraska Environmental Trust Board may allocate
earnings of the Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund which
are not interest income, but instead are capital gains or dividends,
pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81 -15,174.01 .
REQUESTED BY: Mary Harding
Executive Director, The Nebraska Environmental Trust
WRITTEN BY:
Jon Bruning, Attorney General
Natalee J. Hart, Assistant Attorney General
On November 17, 2004, you requested a formal opinion from the Attorney
General's Office regarding (1) whether the Nebraska Environmental Trust Board
(hereinafter "Trust Board") may invest the Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund
(hereinafter "Endowment Fund") in a portfolio which contains investments which may
return capital gains or dividends; and (2) whether the Trust Board may allocate earnings
of the Endowment Fund which are not interest income, but instead are capital gains or
dividends, pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81 -15,174.01 (Cum. Supp, 2002). For the
reasons set forth below, we conclude that (1) the Endowment Fund may be invested in
a portfolio which contains investments which may return capital gains or dividends; and
(2) the Trust Board may allocate earnings of the Endowment Fund which are not
interest income, but instead are capital gains or dividends.
Printed with soy ink on recycled paper
t,
I
The Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund may
be invested in a portfolio which contains investments
which may return capital gains or dividends
Pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81-15,174.01, "[a]ny money in the [Endowment
Fund] available for investment shall be invested by the state investment officer pursuant
to the Nebraska Capital Expansion Act and the Nebraska State Funds Investment Act."
The Nebraska Capital Expansion Act provides for deposits into commercial
banking channels and capital stock financial institution or qualifying mutual financial
institution channels that return only interest income, not capital gains or dividends, and
thus is not relevant to your questions. Neb. Rev. Stat. §§72-1261 through 72-1269
(Reissue 2003).
The Nebraska State Funds Investment Act, however, does provide for the
investment of funds in a diversified portfolio which contains investments that may return
capital gains or dividends. Neb. Rev. Stat. §§72-1237 through 72-1260 (Reissue 2003).
The Nebraska Investment Council is governed, in part, by the "prudent man
standard," as set forth by the Legislature.
Members of the Nebraska Investment Council, which invests State funds
pursuant to the Nebraska State Funds Investment Act, shall act with the care,
skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a
prudent person acting in like capacity and familiar with such matters would use in
the conduct of an enterprise of a like character and with like aims by diversifying
the investments of the assets of . . . state funds so as to minimize risk of large
losses, unless in light of such circumstances it is clearly prudent not to do so.
Neb. Rev. Stat. §72-1239.01(3).
Pursuant to the investment policies established by the Nebraska Investment
Council, which are written with this prudent man standard in mind, the Investment
Council has authorized investments in diversified portfolios and has specifically allowed
other endowment funds to be invested in funds that return capital gains and dividends.
See, Nebraska Investment Council Policy for Political Subdivisions, amended
September 27, 2004; Cultural Preservation Endowment Fund Investment Policy
Statement, amended September 27, 2004; General Endowment Funds Investment
Policy Statement, amended September 27, 2004.
The prudent man standard and the Investment Council's investment policy
statements allow the Nebraska Investment Council to authorize investments that they
deem proper for the funds of the state, which may include those that return capital gains
and dividends.
2
Therefore, as the Endowment Fund may be invested pursuant to the Nebraska
State Funds Investment Act, the Endowment Fund is not limited to investment in only
those vehicles which return interest income, but also may be invested in investments
which may return capital gains or dividends under the authority of the Nebraska
Investment Council.
The Trust Board may allocate earnings of the
Endowment Fund which are not interest income,
but instead are capital gains or dividends
Pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81 -15, 174.01, "[a]ny interest income earned by the
Nebraska Environmental Endowment Fund shall be available for allocation by the board
as provided in section 81 -15, 175."
Neb. Rev. Stat. §72-1248 (Reissue 2003) of the Nebraska State Funds
Investment Act provides that "Interest, premium, and other income received from
investments pursuant to sections 72-1244 and 72-1267 shall be credited to the fund
from which the investment was made except as otherwise provided by law."
Neb. Rev. Stat. §72-1248 states that investment income shall be credited back to
the fund from which the investment was made, in this case, the Endowment, Fund, and
Neb. Rev. Stat. §81 -15, 174.01 specifies that interest income shall be available for
allocation by the Trust Board. However, the relevant statute does not give guidance to
the Trust Board for handling investment income that is not interest. For this reason, we
believe the statute to be vague in this respect.
When a statute is vague, the legislative history of the statute may be reviewed for
the purpose of discovering the intent of the Legislature. North Star Lodge No. 227 v.
City of Lincoln, 212 Neb. 236, 322 N.W.2d 419 (1982).
We also keep in mind the general rules of statutory construction. In ascertaining
the meaning of a statute, courts in Nebraska will determine and give effect to the
purpose and intent of the Legislature as determined from the entire language of the
statute considered in its plain, ordinary and popular sense. Omaha Public Power District
v. Nebraska Dept. of Revenue, 248 Neb. 518, 537 N.W.2d 312 (1995); Nebraska Life
and Health Ins. Guarantee Association v. Dobias, 247 Neb. 900, 531 N.W.2d 217
(1995). Courts will also look to a statute's purpose and give it a reasonable construction
that best achieves that purpose, rather than a construction which would defeat that
purpose. Solar Motors, Inc. v. First National Bank of Chadron, 249 Neb. 758, 545
N.W.2d 714 (1996). Finally, courts will place a sensible construction upon a statute to
effectuate the object of the legislation rather than a literal meaning that would have the
effect of defeating the legislative intent. Bayer v. Father Flanagan's Boys' Home, 219
Neb. 824, 366 N.W.2d 760 (1985).
We believe the legislature intended to allow for the use of "investment income"
instead of simply "interest income" for allocation by the Trust Board. We read Neb. Rev.
3
Stat. §81 -15, 174.01 together with Neb. Rev. Stat. §72-1248, and the Legislative History
of Neb. Rev. Stat §81-15,174.01, and find that the Endowment Fund is not limited to
only be invested in those type of investments that return only interest income, but in a
range of investment opportunities, including those that return capital gains or dividends,
or other such income. The legislature intended the Trust Board to invest the principle
from the Endowment Fund and use the income from those investments for its
allocations, whether it be interest income, or capital gains or dividends.
The Endowment Fund is to be invested and administered as any other trust fund
is in the State. The Nebraska State Funds Investment Act allows the Endowment Fund
to be invested in a portfolio that includes vehicles which return capital gains or
dividends, and those capital gains and dividends are available for allocation by the Trust
Board, just as interest income is available.
Conclusion
Based on the above, it is our opinion, pursuant to Neb. Rev. Stat. §81-15, 174.01
and the provisions of the Nebraska State Funds Investment Act that the Endowment
Fund may be invested by the Trust Board in investments that return interest income,
capital gains, or dividends; and that the Trust Board may allocate earnings of the
Endowment Fund that are interest income, capital gains, or dividends.
Sincerely,
JON BRUNING
Approved:
4