Rule 23-107 NMRA
Rule 23-107. Broadcasting, televising, photographing, and recording of court proceedings; guidelines.
The broadcasting, televising, photographing, and recording of court proceedings in
the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals, district courts, magistrate courts, and
metropolitan courts of the State of New Mexico are hereby authorized in accordance
with the guidelines set forth in this rule, which establishes safeguards to ensure that
these types of media coverage shall not detract from the dignity of the court
proceedings or otherwise interfere with the achievement of a fair and impartial hearing.
A. Discretion of the court. Live coverage of proceedings shall not be limited by the
objection of counsel or parties, except that the Supreme Court reserves to the individual
courts the right to limit or deny coverage for good cause, in light of the guidelines in this
rule, or in accordance with Subparagraph (G)(2) of this rule.
(1)
Media coverage in the courts is subject at all times to the authority of the
judge or judges to
(a) control the conduct of the proceedings before the court;
(b) ensure decorum and prevent distractions; and
(c) ensure fair administration of justice in the pending cause.
(2)
The court has sole and plenary discretion to exclude coverage of certain
witnesses, including but not limited to the victims of sex crimes and their families, police
informants, undercover agents, relocated witnesses, and juveniles.
(3)
Neither the jury nor any member of the jury may be filmed in or near the
courtroom, nor shall the jury selection process be filmed.
(4)
The judge has discretionary power to forbid coverage whenever the judge
is satisfied that coverage may have a deleterious effect on the paramount right of the
defendant to a fair trial.
(5)
Audio pickup, broadcast, or recording of a tender of evidence offered by a
party for the purpose of determining admissibility made before the judge out of the
hearing of the jury is not permitted.
(6)
Audio pickup, broadcast, photography, televising, or recording of a
conference in the courtroom between members of the court, court and counsel, co-
counsel, or counsel and client is not permitted.
B. Notice. The broadcasters, photographers, and recorders shall notify the clerk of
the particular court at least twenty-four (24) hours in advance of coverage of their desire
to cover the proceeding. Each trial judge may, in the judge’s discretion, lengthen or
shorten the time for advance notice for coverage of a particular proceeding.
C. Decorum. The decorum and dignity of the court, the courtroom, and the
proceedings must be maintained at all times. Court customs must be followed, including
appropriate attire. Movement in the courtroom shall be limited, except during breaks or
recess. The changing of tapes, film magazines, film, and similar actions during the
proceedings shall be avoided.
D. Standards. The media shall maintain high journalistic standards regarding the
fairness, objectivity, and quality of the coverage allowed under these guidelines.
E. Equipment and personnel. Unless otherwise agreed upon by the court,
equipment and personnel within the courtroom or hearing room shall be limited as
follows:
(1)
All equipment shall be operated behind the rail;
(2)
Not more than one (1) portable television camera operated by not more
than one (1) camera person shall be permitted. Only natural lighting shall be used.
Cameras shall be quiet and shall be placed and operated as unobtrusively as possible
within the courtroom at a location approved by the court. The cameras shall be in place
at least fifteen (15) minutes before the proceedings begin;
(3)
Not more than two (2) audio systems shall be permitted. All running wires
shall be securely taped to the floor. Multiple radio feeds shall be provided by a junction
box;
(4)
Not more than two (2) still photographers, utilizing not more than one (1)
still camera each, shall be permitted. The cameras must not produce any distracting
sounds. Only natural lighting shall be used. Still photographers shall remain in one (1)
place during the proceedings, but they may shift positions during breaks or recess;
(5)
Tape recorders may be used by members of the media, so long as they
do not constitute a distraction during the proceedings; and
(6)
Any pooling arrangements necessary shall be the sole responsibility of the
media and must be concluded prior to coverage without calling upon the court to
mediate any dispute regarding appropriate media and personnel.
F. Inapplicability to individuals. The privileges granted by these rules may be
exercised only by persons or organizations that are part of the news media.
G. Objections limited.
(1)
An appellate court shall not exercise its appellate or supervisory
jurisdiction to review at the request of any news media persons or organization seeking
to exercise a privilege conferred upon them by these rules, any order, or ruling of any
judge under these rules.
(2)
Any party, or any person or entity with a sufficient interest, may object to
cameras in the courtroom by filing a motion for courtroom closure under Rule 1-104
NMRA, Rule 2-114 NMRA, Rule 3-114 NMRA, Rule 5-124 NMRA, Rule 6-116 NMRA,
Rule 7-115 NMRA, or Rule 12-322 NMRA.
H. Impermissible use of media material. None of the film, videotape, still
photographs, or audio reproductions developed during or by virtue of coverage of a
judicial proceeding shall be admissible as evidence in the proceeding out of which it
arose, any proceeding subsequent or collateral thereto, or upon any retrial or appeal of
such proceeding.
I. Other courts. The broadcasting, televising, photographing, and recording of
court proceedings in courts other than the appellate, district, magistrate, and
metropolitan courts of New Mexico is prohibited.