Rule 5-803 NMRA
Rule 5-803. Petitions for post-sentence relief.
A. Application. A petition to set aside a judgment and sentence may be filed in the
district court of the jurisdiction which rendered the judgment by one who has been
convicted of a criminal offense, and who is not in custody or under restraint as a result
of such sentence. The petition shall be assigned to the judge that originally heard the
matter, or if that judge is no longer serving on the bench, the successor criminal
division.
B. Grounds. Relief under this rule is available to correct convictions obtained in
violation of the constitution or laws of the United States or the State of New Mexico.
C. Time for filing. A petition for post-sentence relief shall be filed within a
reasonable time after the completion of the petitioner’s sentence, unless the court finds
good cause, excusable neglect, or extraordinary circumstances beyond the control of
the petitioner that justify filing the petition beyond that time.
D. Procedure. A petition for post-sentence relief under this rule may be granted
only upon filing with the clerk of the court a petition on behalf of the party seeking relief.
If the petition is filed by a petitioner who is not represented by an attorney and who is
confined to an institution or other detention facility, the petition is deemed to be filed with
the clerk of the court on the date the petition is deposited in the institution’s internal mail
system for forwarding to the court provided that the petitioner states within the petition,
under penalty of perjury, the date on which the petition was deposited in the institution’s
internal mail system. The petition shall contain the following:
(1)
The respondent in proceedings under this rule, which shall be the State of
New Mexico;
(2)
The petitioner’s full name and address, if petitioner is not represented by
counsel;
(3)
A statement of the steps taken to exhaust all other available remedies,
including a statement of the name of the case, the docket number of the case, the court,
administrative agency or institutional grievance committee from which relief was sought,
and the result of each previous judicial proceeding. If a claim has been raised in prior
proceedings, a statement explaining why the ends of justice require additional
consideration of the petition;
(4)
if the petitioner has previously filed a petition seeking relief under this rule
or Rule 5-802 NMRA, a statement explaining why the petition should not be dismissed
under Paragraph G;
(5)
a statement as to whether:
(a) the petition seeks to vacate, set aside or correct the sentence or order of
confinement; or
(b) the petition challenges matters other than Subparagraph (a) of this
subparagraph;
(6)
A concise statement of the facts and law upon which the application is
based; and
(7)
a concise statement of the relief sought.
E. Papers attached to the petition. The following shall be attached to the petition:
(1)
any opinion, order, transcript, or other written material reasonably
available to petitioner indicating any court’s ruling on the petitioner’s prior custody or
restraint or on the issued raised in the petition, or a statement explaining why the
materials are not attached;
(2)
a certificate of service showing service on the district attorney in the
district in which the application is filed.
F. Procedure for adjudicating petition.
(1)
Summary dismissal; return of petition. Upon receipt of a petition for
post-sentence relief, the court shall promptly examine the petition together with all
attachments. If it plainly appears from the face of the petition, any exhibits, and the prior
court proceedings in the case, that the petitioner is not entitled to relief as a matter of
law, the court shall summarily dismiss the petition.
If the court is unable to determine from the face of the petition whether petitioner is
entitled to relief as a matter of law, the court may return a copy of the petition to the
petitioner for additional factual information or a restatement of the legal claims. If the
petition is returned to the petitioner, the petitioner has forty-five (45) days to resubmit a
revised petition. Upon receipt of the revised petition, the court has forty-five (45) days to
examine the petition together with all attachments. If no revised petition is filed, the
court may dismiss the petition.
(2)
Response. If the court determines that summary dismissal is not
appropriate, the court shall order the state to submit a response within one-hundred
twenty (120) days.
(3)
Preliminary disposition hearing. After the response is filed, at the
request of a party or upon its own motion, the court may conduct a preliminary
disposition hearing for the purpose of clarifying the issues and petitioner’s evidence in
support of the claims in the petition. At the preliminary disposition hearing, the court will
attempt to resolve any of the issues presented by the petition based on the filings by
counsel for the parties. The court shall then determine whether an evidentiary hearing is
required. If it appears that an evidentiary hearing is not required, the court may dispose
of the petition without a further hearing, but may ask for briefs and/or oral arguments on
legal issues;
(4)
Evidentiary hearing. If an evidentiary hearing is ordered, the hearing
shall be conducted as promptly as practicable.
G. Second and successive petitions. If the petitioner has previously filed a
petition seeking relief under this rule or Rule 5-802, the court shall have the discretion
to:
(1)
dismiss any claim not raised in a prior petition unless fundamental error
has occurred, or unless an adequate record to address the claim properly was not
available at the time of the prior petition; and
(2)
dismiss any claim raised and rejected in a prior petition unless there has
been an intervening change of law or fact or the ends of justice would otherwise be
served by rehearing the claim.
H. Discovery procedures.
(1)
Discovery procedures for parties represented by counsel. At any
time, counsel for a party may make a formal written request to opposing counsel for
production of documents and other discovery materials that are available under Rules
5-501 or 5-502 NMRA. The written request shall describe the good faith efforts by
counsel to obtain the discovery materials from previous counsel or any other sources
and shall show that these efforts were unsuccessful. Counsel for the opposing party
shall comply with the request within thirty (30) days after service or notify the court in
writing of any objection to the request. Any objection based on privilege should clearly
identify the material withheld and the basis of the privilege claim. The court shall then
hold a hearing to rule on any objection to the discovery request. The court shall grant a
challenged request for discovery when the requesting party demonstrates that the
materials are relevant to advance the claims that are alleged in the petition or the
materials are relevant to defend against the claims that are alleged in the petition.
(2)
For purposes of this rule, “discovery materials” are:
(a) materials in the possession of a party;
(b) materials in the possession of law enforcement authorities to which the
petitioner would have been entitled to at the time of trial; or
(c) materials in the possession of the New Mexico Corrections Department.
(3)
Counsel for a party may make use of any other discovery procedure under
the Rules of Criminal Procedure for the District Courts only after notice to opposing
counsel and prior written authorization from the court. In determining whether to
authorize such proceedings, the court may consider any of the factors contained in
Paragraph A of Rule 5-507 NMRA.
(4)
Discovery procedures for pro-se petitioners. Petitioners not
represented by counsel shall petition the court before requesting discovery under this
rule and the Rules of Criminal Procedure for the District Courts. In determining whether
to authorize a discovery request, the court may consider any of the factors contained in
Paragraph A of Rule 5-507.
(5)
Motions to compel. If the state or the petitioner fails to comply with any of
the provisions of this rule, the court may enter an order under Rule 5-505 or Rule 5-112
NMRA.
I. Appeal. Within thirty (30) days after the district court’s decision:
(1)
if the petition is granted, the state may appeal as of right to the Court of
Appeals under the Rules of Appellate Procedure.
(2)
if the petition is denied, the petitioner may appeal to the Court of Appeals
under the Rules of Appellate Procedure.