Rule 6-116 NMRA
Rule 6-116. Courtroom closure.
A. Courtroom proceedings open. All courtroom proceedings shall be open to the
public unless the courtroom is closed by an order of the court entered under this rule.
An agreement of the parties to close the courtroom shall not constitute a sufficient basis
for the issuance of an order for courtroom closure. Unless otherwise ordered by the
court, the following persons may be present during a closed courtroom proceeding: the
parties and their attorneys, witnesses while testifying, court employees and security
personnel, and victims and victim’s representatives as defined in the Victims of Crime
Act, Section 31-26-3 NMSA 1978. This rule does not affect the court’s inherent authority
to impose reasonable time, place, and manner limitations on public access to the
courtroom, including reasonable limitations on broadcasting, televising, photographing,
and recording of court proceedings as set forth in Rule 23-107 NMRA.
B. Motion for courtroom closure. A motion for courtroom closure must advance
an interest that overrides the public’s interest in attending the proceeding.
(1)
Motion of the court. If the court determines on the court’s own motion
that a courtroom proceeding should be closed, the court shall file and serve on each
party an order to show cause why the proceeding should not be closed.
(2)
Motion of a party, or other interested person or entity. A party, or any
person or entity with a sufficient interest, may move to exclude the public from any
portion of a courtroom proceeding. A motion for courtroom closure shall be filed and
served at least twenty (20) days prior to the commencement of the courtroom
proceeding, unless upon good cause shown the court waives the time requirement.
(3)
Response. A party opposing a motion for courtroom closure or
responding to an order to show cause may file a written response within fifteen (15)
days after service of the motion or order to show cause, unless a different time period is
ordered by the court. A reply is not permitted without leave of the court, which may be
granted upon a showing of good cause.
(4)
Response by non-party. Any member of the public may file a written
response to a motion for courtroom closure at any time before the hearing required
under Paragraph C of this rule.
(5)
Continuance. In the court’s discretion or at the request of the parties, the
court may continue a courtroom proceeding to allow time to file written responses.
C. Public hearing. Unless the court denies a motion for courtroom closure on the
pleadings, the court shall hold a public hearing on any proposed courtroom closure
considered under Subparagraph (B)(1) or (B)(2) of this rule.
(1)
Notice of hearing to the public. Media organizations, persons, and
entities that have requested to receive notice of proposed courtroom closures shall be
given timely notice of the date, time, and place of any hearing under this paragraph. Any
member of the public shall be permitted a reasonable opportunity to be heard at the
hearing.
(2)
In camera review. Although the court is required to hold a public hearing
on a motion for courtroom closure, this rule does not preclude the court from holding
part of a hearing in camera for the limited purpose of reviewing sensitive or confidential
information relevant to the motion. Any evidence tendered to the court for an in camera
review that is not ordered to be disclosed shall be returned to the party.
D. Order for courtroom closure. An order for courtroom closure shall be in writing,
shall articulate the overriding interest being protected, and shall specify the court’s
findings underlying the order. The court may order the exclusion of the public from all or
part of a courtroom proceeding only if
(1)
the court concludes that such order is necessary to preserve an overriding
interest that is likely to be prejudiced if the courtroom is not closed;
(2)
the order for courtroom closure is narrowly tailored to protect the
overriding interest; and
(3)
the court has considered reasonable alternatives to courtroom closure.