Rule 12-208 NMRA
Rule 12-208. Docketing the appeal.
A. Attorney responsible. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, trial counsel shall
be responsible for preparing and filing a docketing statement in the Court of Appeals or
a statement of the issues in the Supreme Court.
B. When filed. Within thirty (30) days after filing the notice of appeal in all appeals
except those under Rules 12-203, 12-203.1, 12-204, 12-603, and 12-604 NMRA, the
appellant shall file a docketing statement, if the appeal has been docketed in the Court
of Appeals, or a statement of the issues, if the appeal has been docketed in the
Supreme Court. But if the notice of appeal was filed before the express disposition by
order or the automatic denial or the withdrawal of any timely filed post-trial or post-
judgment motion listed in Subparagraphs (1) or (2) of Rule 12-201(D) NMRA, then the
docketing statement or statement of the issues shall be filed within thirty (30) days after
the notice of appeal becomes effective under Rule 12-201(D)(4) NMRA.
C. Service. The appellant shall serve a copy of the docketing statement or
statement of the issues on the district court clerk and on those persons who are
required to be served with a notice of appeal under Rule 12-202 NMRA.
D. Docketing statement in the Court of Appeals; contents. A docketing
statement shall contain
(1)
a statement of the nature of the proceeding;
(2)
the date of the judgment or order sought to be reviewed, and a statement
showing that the appeal was timely filed;
(3)
a concise, accurate statement of the case summarizing all facts material
to a consideration of the issues presented;
(4)
a statement of the issues presented by the appeal, including a statement
of how they arose and how they were preserved in the trial court, but without
unnecessary detail. The statement of the issues should be short and concise and
should not be repetitious. General conclusory statements such as “the judgment of the
trial court is not supported by the law or the facts” will not be accepted;
(5)
for each issue, a list of authorities believed to support the contentions of
the appellant and any contrary authorities known by appellant and, where known, the
applicable standard of review. Argument on the law shall not be included, but a short,
simple statement of the proposition for which the case or text is cited shall accompany
the citation;
(6)
a statement specifying whether the entire proceedings were audio
recorded, and if not, identifying the portion of the proceedings, other than the record
proper, not audio recorded;
(7)
a reference to all related or prior appeals of which the party is aware,
including an appropriate citation, if any; and
(8)
where applicable, a copy of the order appointing appellate counsel.
E. Statement of the issues in the Supreme Court; contents. A statement of the
issues shall contain each issue to be presented by the appeal, including a statement of
how the issue arose, how each issue was preserved in the trial court, and a statement
of the court’s jurisdiction, but without unnecessary detail. A statement of the issues shall
contain a reference to all related or prior appeals of which the party is aware, including
an appropriate citation, if any. The statement of the issues should be concise and
accurate and should not be repetitious. General conclusory statements such as “the
judgment of the trial court is not supported by the law or the facts” will not be accepted.
F. Amendment. The Court of Appeals may, on good cause shown, allow the
amendment of the docketing statement. The Supreme Court may, on good cause
shown, allow the amendment of a statement of the issues.
G. Cross-appeals. A party who files a cross-appeal in accordance with Rule 12-
201(B) NMRA shall file a docketing statement in the Court of Appeals or a statement of
the issues in the Supreme Court in accordance with this rule within thirty (30) days after
the notice of appeal is filed by the cross-appellant and shall pay a docket fee as
provided in Paragraph H of this rule.
H. Docket fee. Except where free process has been granted on appeal, the docket
fee shall accompany the filing of a docketing statement in the Court of Appeals or a
statement of the issues in the Supreme Court unless the party filing the docketing
statement or statement of the issues has already paid a docket fee.
I. Response not permitted. No response to a docketing statement or statement of
the issues is allowed.
J. Failure to serve docketing statement or statement of the issues. On a
monthly basis, the district court clerk shall forward to the appellate court a list of all
criminal cases in which a notice of appeal has been on file for at least sixty (60) days
but in which the district court has not been served with a copy of a docketing statement
or a statement of the issues.