Rule 12-601 NMRA
Rule 12-601. Direct appeals from administrative decisions where the right to appeal is provided by statute.
A. Scope of rule. This rule governs the procedure for filing and perfecting direct
appeals to an appellate court from orders, decisions, or actions of boards, commissions,
administrative agencies, or officials when the right to a direct appeal is provided by
statute. This rule applies to both rulemaking and adjudicatory proceedings by the
administrative entity. To the extent of any conflict, this rule supersedes any statute
providing for the time or other procedure for filing or perfecting an appeal with an
appellate court. This rule does not create a right of appeal and does not govern petitions
for writs filed in the Supreme Court or appeals to the district court.
B. Initiating the appeal. Direct appeals from orders, decisions, or actions of
boards, commissions, administrative agencies, or officials shall be taken by filing a
notice of appeal with the appellate court clerk, together with the docket fee and proof of
service on the agency involved and all parties and participants entitled to notice under
Paragraphs C and D of this rule in accordance with Rule 12-307 NMRA, within thirty
(30) days from the date of the order, decision, or action appealed from. The additional
three (3)-day period provided in Rule 12-308(B) NMRA for certain kinds of service shall
not apply to the time limits for filing a notice of appeal under this paragraph. Within thirty
(30) days of the filing of the notice of appeal, the appellant shall file a docketing
statement in the Court of Appeals or a statement of the issues in the Supreme Court in
accordance with Rule 12-208 NMRA, and the appeal shall proceed in accordance with
these rules, notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary.
C. Intervention as a party-appellee in rulemaking proceedings.
(1)
In any appeal challenging the adoption of a rule by an administrative
entity, a participant in the rulemaking proceeding is entitled to notice of the appeal under
Paragraph B of this rule and may move to intervene in the appeal as a party-appellee as
of right if
(a) the participant was a party to the rulemaking proceeding under the
applicable rules or procedures of the administrative entity;
(b) the participant initiated the rulemaking proceeding; or
(c) the participant participated actively in the rulemaking proceeding, during
which it presented evidence relating to matters that the administrative entity was
required to consider in deciding whether to adopt the rule at issue.
(2)
Except as set forth in Subparagraph (1) of this paragraph, a participant in
the rulemaking proceeding may move to intervene in the appeal as a party-appellee
only at the discretion of the appellate court.
(3)
The appellate court may, in its discretion, order consolidated briefing by
similarly situated parties or take other measures to promote efficiency and avoid
unnecessary duplication.
D. Intervention as a party-appellee in adjudicatory proceedings.
(1)
In any appeal challenging an adjudicatory action by an administrative
entity, a participant in the adjudicatory proceeding is entitled to notice of the appeal
under Paragraph B of this rule and may move to intervene in the appeal as a party-
appellee as of right if the participant was a party to the adjudicatory proceeding under
the applicable rules or procedures of the administrative entity.
(2)
Except as set forth in Subparagraph (1) of this paragraph, a participant in
the proceeding may intervene in the appeal as a party-appellee only at the discretion of
the appellate court.
(3)
The appellate court may, in its discretion, order consolidated briefing by
similarly situated parties or take other measures to promote efficiency and avoid
unnecessary duplication.
E. Substitution of administrative entity. Whenever in these rules a duty is to be
performed by, service is to be made on, or reference is made to the district court or a
judge or clerk of the district court, the board, commission, administrative agency, or
official whose action is appealed from shall be substituted for the district court or a judge
or clerk of the district court, except that any request for extension of time must be made
to the appellate court.
F. Grace period when notice is sent by mail or commercial courier. A notice of
appeal that is sent by mail or commercial courier service to the court in which it is to be
filed shall be deemed to be timely filed on the day it is received if the notice of appeal
contains a certificate of service, which in addition to the information otherwise required
by Rule 12-307(E) NMRA, explicitly states that the notice of appeal was sent to the
appellate court by mail or commercial courier service and was postmarked by the
United States Postal Service or date-stamped by the commercial courier service at least
one (1) day before the due date for the notice of appeal otherwise prescribed by this
rule. The clerkโs office shall file-stamp a notice of appeal with the date on which it is
actually received regardless of any postmark date set forth in the certificate of service.