No. 7
OFFICIAL OPINION No. 7
Cite as Pa. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 7 (1971)
OFFICIAL OPINION No. 7
Reapportionment-Certification of census-Time available to municipalities to
complete reapportionment.
1. Article IX, Section 11 of Pennsylvania Constitution requires that reappor-
tionment take place " ... within the year following that in which the Federal
decennial census is officially reported as required by Federal Jaw."
2. The critical year is the one in which the Secretary of Commerce reports the
census count to the President and not the year in which the certified figures
are made available.
OPINIONS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
17
3. The Secretary of Commerce reported the tabulation of total population by
States to the President on November 30, 1970.
4. Under Article IX, Section 11, municipalities have the full year of 1971 in
which to complete reapportionment.
Honorable Donald 0. Oesterling
173 Main Capitol Building
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120
Dear Senator Oesterling:
Harrisburg, Pa.,
March 4, 1971
This is in response to your letter of February 11th concerning our
interpretation of Article IX, Section 11, of the Pennsylvania Constitu-
tion relative to certifying census figures. We are of the opinion that
the critical year is the year in which the Secretary of Commerce reports
the census count to the President and not the year in which the certified
figures are made available.
Article IX, Section 11, provides that reapportionment shall take place
"within the year following that in which the Federal decennial census is
officially reported as required by Federal law."
On November 30, 1970, the Secretary of Commerce "reported" to
the President "the Tabulation of total population by States as required
for the apportionment of Representatives." In doing so, he acted pur-
suant to the mandate contained in the Act of August 31, 1954, c. 1158,
Section 1, 68 Stat. 1019, as amended, 13 U. S. C. A. § 141 (b)
(Supp. 1970). There is no requirement in the Federal census law as
to any other form of reporting of the census figures. There is a pro-
vision in the Federal law to the effect that the Secretary of Commerce
may furnish census information to State and local officials. However,
this provision is not mandatory, and it seems clear that our Constitu-
tional provision refers to the requirement that the Secretary of Com-
merce report the census count to the President.
Thus, it is our opinion that 1970 is the year "in which the Federal
decennial census was officially reported as required by Federal law,"
Pa. Const., Art. IX, Section 11. This being the case, it becomes academic
whether the language "Within the year following that" is interpreted
as "within the year following the date on which the census is officially
18
OPINIONS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
reported" or "within the year following the year in which the census is
reported." In the former case, the "cut-off" date would be November
30, 1971; in the latter, December 31, 1971.
Nevertheless, we believe that, as a matter of construction, the latter
interpretation is correct. Therefore, under Article IX, Section 11, mu-
nicipalities would have the full year of 1971 (January 1, 1971, through
December 31, 1971) in which to complete reapportionment.
Sincerely,
J. SHANE CREAMER,
Attorney General.