No. 6
OFFICIAL OPINION No. 6
Cite as Pa. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 6 (1957)
OFFICIAL OPINION No. 6
D epartment of Labor and Indu.strv-Transportation of migrant workers-Regu.la-
tion-Act of May 18, 1937, P. L. 654.
1. The Secretary of Labor and Industry has the power to regulate the trans-
portation of migrant workers within the Commonwealth in order to provide for
the health, safety and comfort of the o ccupan~s of labor camps.
2. The regulation applies to transportation in commercial motor vehicles not
xegulated by the Public Utility Commission.
Harrisburg, Pa., September 17, 1957.
Honorable William L. Batt, Jr., Secretary of Labor and Industry,
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.
Sir:
You have requested an opm10n whether the D epartment of
Labor and Industry has authority to issue regulations governing the
transportation of migrant workers in commercial vehicles on the high-
ways of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
If the power and duty to promulgate regulations governing such
transportation are given to the D epartment of Labor and Industry,
they must be found in § 9 and § 12 of the Act of May 18, 1937, P. L.
S54, 43 P. S. § 25-9 and § 25-12, which read as follows:
"All canneries for the canning or preserving of fruits, vege-
tables, or meats shall be kept in a clean and sanitary condi-
tion, and all labor camps operated in connection with such
canneries and all other labor camps shall be located, construe-
OPINIONS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
ted, maintained and operated in all respects as to provide
for the health, safety, and comfort of occupants of such
camps."
"The Department of Labor and Industry shall have the
power and its duty shall be to make, alter, amend, and repeal
rules and regulations for carrying into effect all the provisions
of this act, and applying such provisions to specific condi-
tions."
55
Migrant labor camps are clearly included within the term "all other
labor camps" in § 9.
The term "operated in all respects," when
reasonably interpreted, must be taken to cover all phases and activities
conducted in the normal everyday operation of a labor camp. Since
the purpose of operating a labor camp is to provide a labor force for
neighboring farmers and others who require the services of such
laborers, it is inherent in such operation that the laborers be trans-
ported from the camps to the fields to perform their duties. Section 9,
therefore, includes the transportation of migrant workers; § 12 em-
powers the Department of Labor and Industry to regulate this activity.
In regulating the transportation of migratory workers in commercial
vehicles, the Commonwealth cannot regulate the transportation beyond
the boundaries of the Commonwealth. However, where workers are
being transported from one labor camp to another within the Common-
wealth or into or out of the Commonwealth where the destination
within the Commonwealth or the point of departure from the Com-
monwealth is a labor camp, regulation of such transportation, limited
to that portion commencing and concluding within the Commonwealth,
is a reasonable exercise of the regulatory authority of § 12.
Such
transportation, included within the meaning of the "operation in all
respects" of a labor camp, arises pursuant to oral or written contracts.
These contracts, executed within or without the Commonwealth, pro-
vide that the operator of a labor camp within the Commonwealth or
his agent will furnish transportation to and from the site of the labor
camp or camps from which the laborer agrees to perform services for
a given period of time. It is contemplated in these contracts that
transportation to the camp or camps will be furnished in order that
the operator may have available the labor force essential to the opera-
tion of the labor camp.
It is, therefore, the opinion of this Department and you are accord-
ingly advised that transportation in commercial vehicles, not regulated
by the Public Utility Commission, of migrant workers within the
Commonwealth may be regulated to provide for the health, safety and
56
OPINIONS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
comfort of the occupants of labor camps within the Commonwealth
by the Department of Labor and Industry.
Very truly yours,
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE,
FREDERIC G. ANTOUN,
Deputy Attorney General.
THOMAS D. McBRIDE,
Attorney General.