440-RICR-10-00-1
440-RICR-10-00-1. General Rules and Regulations for Applications, Registration, Licensing, Claims, Violations, and Administrative Hearings (version Amendment, 03/21/2020 to 09/17/2020)
1.1 Authority
This Part is promulgated
pursuant to the Rhode Island Contractors’ Registration and
Licensing Board Law, R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65; the Rhode Island
Home Inspector Licensing Law, R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.1; the
Rhode Island Well-Drilling, Pump Installers, and Water-Filtration
Contractors Licensing Law, R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.2; the Rhode
Island Underground Utility Contractors’ Licensing Law, R.I.
Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.3; and the Rhode Island Commercial Roofing
Licensing Law, R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-73.
1.2 Purpose
A. The purpose of this Part is
to establish provisions, qualifications, and procedures for
registering and licensing those disciplines governed by the
Contractors' Registration and Licensing Board: including but not
limited to contractors, home inspectors, well-drillers, pump
installers, water filtration contractors, underground utility
contractors and commercial roofers.
B. The purpose of the Part is
also to promote public safety, health and welfare by providing a
mechanism to ensure that all persons conducting business in the
regulated disciplines within the State of Rhode Island have the
requisite skills, training, and experience necessary to safely and
adequately conduct those activities within the state.
C. This Part shall also govern
the complaint process and the conduct of adjudicatory proceedings
commenced before the Board after July 1, 2019. This Part shall be
liberally construed to further the fair, prompt and orderly
administration and determination of complaints and adjudicatory
proceedings in conformity with the Rhode Island Administrative
Procedures Act. To the extent that any part of these Rules are
inconsistent with applicable law or the terms of any other rule or
regulation promulgated by the Board, the applicable law and/or the
terms of such other rule or regulation shall be deemed to apply.
D. As applicable and/or
required, or unless otherwise indicated, all persons subject to the
registration or licensing requirements of the Contractors'
Registration and Licensing Board must comply with the provisions of
this Part and the following:
1. Contractors and
subcontractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65 and Part 2 of this
Subchapter.
2. Underground Utility
Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.3 and Part 3 of this
Subchapter.
3. Commercial Roofing
Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-73 and Part 4 of this
Subchapter.
4. Well Drilling, Pump
Installers, and Water Filtration Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter
5-65.2 and Part 5 of this Subchapter.
5. Home Inspectors: R.I. Gen.
Laws Chapter 5-65.1 and Part 6 of this Subchapter.
1.3 Incorporated Materials
Reserved
1.4 General Definitions
A. In addition to the terms
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-1 and Parts 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6
of this Subchapter, the following terms shall have the following
meanings:
1. "Agent of service"
or "Registered agent" means a business or individual
designated by the registrant/licensee upon whom any process, notice,
or demand required or permitted by law to be served upon the
corporation or individual registrant/licensee may be served. An
attorney licensed and located in Rhode Island or a company listed by
the Rhode Island Secretary of State may serve as an agent of service.
2. "Applicant" means
any person seeking to obtain a registration or license that is issued
by the Contractors’ Registration and Licensing Board.
3. "Architect" and
the "practice of architecture" are defined in R.I. Gen.
Laws § 5-1-2.
4. "Board" or “CRLB”
means the contractors' registration and licensing board established
pursuant to the provisions of § 5-65-14 or its designees.
5. "Building officials"
means the officials charged with the administration and enforcement
of the Rhode Island State Building Code.
6. "Claim" means the
portion of a complaint that requests the imposition of monetary
damages and/or restitution.
7. “Commercial
Contractor” means a contractor who does not regularly in the
course of his or her or its business as a contractor engage in
construction activities as contemplated in R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter
5-65 on residential structures.
8. "Complainant"
means an individual who files a complaint.
9. "Complaint" means
a formal allegation against another person.
10. "Condominium" is
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 34-36.1-1.03(7).
11. “Contested Case”
means an adjudicatory proceeding before a Hearing Officer in which
the legal rights, duties or privileges of a Party are determined in
accordance with R.I. Gen. Laws § 42-35-9.
12. "Continuing education
credit" means the credit unit awarded after a person receives
instruction related to the discipline for which that person is
registered/licensed with the Board. Different disciplines may
require a different number of credit units to maintain a
registration/license, and the credit must be issued by a Board
approved provider to be valid.
13. "Contract" means
the written or oral agreement between the client and the
registered/licensed person or person required to be
registered/licensed, describing the responsibilities and duties of
each party and the fee to be paid.
14. "Contractor" is
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-1(4)(i)
15. “Department”
means the Department of Business Regulation.
16. "Developer"
means a person who owns property and contracts with a general
contractor to construct, improve, or alter one or more buildings or
structures on the land for the purpose of selling or leasing those
buildings or structures, and who is required to be registered with
the Board pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-1(4)(i).
17. “Director”
means the Director of the Department of Business Regulation or the
Director's designee.
18. "Employee" means
an individual who works for wages or salary and is not an independent
contractor.
19. "Employer" means
a legal entity that controls and directs a worker in return for
payment of wages or salary as a means of compensation.
20. "Engineer," the
"practice of engineering" and "professional engineer"
are defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-8-2.
21. "Expungement"
means the removal, deletion or erasing of information from a
registrant’s or licensee’s record that is accessible to
the public.
22. “Flipping”
means the process of purchasing, renovating, and attempting to sell
the property for a quick profit.
23. "Good standing"
means an applicant who does not have any unresolved claims,
violations, penalties or fines with the Board for any
registration/license held by the applicant or its principal, nor with
any other municipal, state, or federal regulatory authority in Rhode
Island or elsewhere.
24. "Inactive
registration/license" means a registration/license that has
lapsed, expired, or has been suspended, surrendered, or revoked.
25. "Incapacity" or
"Incapacitated" means an ailment that renders an active
registrant/licensee unable to perform the work of the discipline for
which they are registered/licensed,
26. "Independent
Contractor" means a person or entity contracted to perform work
for—or provide services to—another entity as a
non-employee.
27. “License”
means any type of License issued by the Board granting permission to
engage in certain activities.
28. "Licensee" means
a holder of a license issued by the Board.
29. "Occupancy"
means, but is not limited to, the time of issuance of a certificate
of occupancy or the time of receipt of a letter of completion of the
construction by the Building Official.
30. "Owner" means
any person or his/her agent who holds title or other rights to a
property.
31. “Party” or
“Parties” means each Person named or admitted as a Party,
or properly seeking and entitled as of right to be admitted as a
Party in a Contested Case.
32. "Permits" means
documentation that must be obtained from the state or local building
department of each city or town in which work is to be performed
prior to the commencement of work.
33. “Person” is
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws 5-65-1(11) and includes any individual,
partnership, corporation, limited liability company, association,
governmental subdivision, public or private organization or any other
entity however formed.
34. “Reasonable Cause”
means there exists a set of facts of a type commonly relied upon by
reasonably prudent persons in the conduct of their affairs which
would induce a reasonably intelligent and prudent person to believe
that a violation(s) of law, rule, or regulation has occurred.
35. "Registrant"
means a holder of a registration issued by the Board.
36. "Registration"
means any type of registration issued by the Board granting
permission to engage in certain activities.
37. "Residence/residential
building" means a structure that consists of one or more
dwelling units.
38. “Respondent”
means a Party against whom a complaint has been filed against or a
violation has issued.
39. "Responsible person"
means the individual, corporate member, or partner of a business
entity who is responsible for the actions of the entity, the
individuals employed by the entity, and for any violations of law,
rule, or regulation that occur under the registration/license.
40. "Revoke" means
the termination of a registration or license by the Board.
41. "Structure" is
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-1 and includes modular and
mobile homes at the time they are placed on support blocking or
permanent foundations in the place they will be used.
42. “State of
Emergency shall mean any State of Emergency declared by the Governor
of the State of Rhode Island pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws §
30-15-9 or other applicable state statute.”
43. "Subcontractor"
means a person or entity who has a contract, either oral or written,
not with the owner of the structure but with a registrant/licensee or
one who is required to be registered/licensed, to perform work
subject to the Board’s authority, and who is responsible for a
specific portion of the project.
44. "Violation"
means an action that breaks or acts against a relevant statute, rule,
regulation, standard, order, registration, and/or license.
45. "Wages" is
defined in R.I. Gen. Laws § 28-14-1(4).
46. "Work period"
means the time period from the date a contract is entered into until
the date the contracted work is substantially completed by the
original registrant/licensee, or if not substantially completed, the
date work by the original registrant/licensee ceased.
1.5 General Administration and
Procedures
A. Delivery of Notices
1. Time for response to all
notices sent by the Board shall run from the date of mailing from the
Board, utilizing calendar days.
2. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Law § 5-65-6, Notices of Violation, Final Orders, and a
Notices of Hearing shall be considered delivered when deposited in
the United States mail and/or sent registered or certified or post
office receipt secured to the last known address of record.
B. Change of Address
The registrant/licensee must
notify the Board of any change of mailing address or email address in
writing and within ten (10) days of the date upon which the change of
address occurs for the duration of the registration/license and for
one (1) year following the date that the registration/license expires
or otherwise becomes inactive.
C. Public Records and
Information Requests
1. Requests for information
filed in accordance with the R.I. Access to Public Records Act, R.I.
Gen. Laws Chapter 38-2.
2. In general, the Board
and/or its staff may provide information that includes, but is not
limited to the following:
a. Whether or not the person
is or has ever been registered/licensed;
b. The registration/license
number(s);
c. The business name(s) used
by the entity of record with the Board;
d. Type of business
organization (i.e. individual proprietorship, partnership, LLC,
corporation or joint venture);
e. Personal name(s) of owners,
partners, or corporate officers;
f. Last known address of the
registrant/licensee;
g. Expiration date or date
upon which the registration/license became inactive and the reason it
became inactive;
h. The date the person first
became registered/licensed;
i. Status of the
registration/license, history of compliance with the education
requirements, validity of insurance and/or bond, and the insurance or
bonding company name (as provided to the Board by the
registrant/licensee); and
j. Number, status, type, date
filed, and fines or awards of proposed orders, final orders, claims,
violations, or notices of hearings on record.
3. If no claims or violations
have been recorded, or if it appears to the Board that the person
about whom the inquiry is being made is unregistered/unlicensed, the
requesting party will be advised as such.
D. Certification of
Registration/License
1. The Board shall provide a
certification of registration/license relating to a specific person
upon written request and payment of the required fee. This
certification will include the following information:
a. Registration/license
number(s);
b. Name of the
registered/licensed person and any business name(s) on file with the
Board;
d. Type of business (i.e.,
individual proprietorship, partnership, LLC, corporation or joint
venture);
e. Name(s) of owner(s),
partner(s), or corporate officer(s) provided to the Board; and
f. Pertinent dates and actions
in the registration/license history.
E. Filing Fees and Record
Changes:
1. The Board may impose the
following charges for records and filing fees:
Public Record Requests
Fee set by R.I. Gen. Laws
Chapter 38-2
Complaint Form
$25.00 (exempt for state
and municipal agencies)
Appeals to the Board
$20.00
Expungement Request
$20.00 for first matter,
$5.00 for each additional matter made under the same request.
Late Fee
$50.00
Returned Check Fee
$35.00
2. The Board shall not refund
fees or civil penalties, unless an administrative error occurred.
1.6
General Registration and Licensing Requirements
1.6.1 Registration /
License Required
A. Every person who engages in
a discipline governed by the Board, listed in §§ 1.1 and
1.2(A) of this Part, must be properly registered or licensed with the
Contractors’ Registration and Licensing Board prior to engaging
in those activities.
B. No person subject to the
provisions of this Subchapter shall provide services, offer to the
public their services, or represent that they possess a
registration/license unless that person possesses a valid
registration/license, unless authorized to do so by the Board.
C. Any person who fails to
properly obtain a registration or license in their respective
discipline, as required, is subject to penalties for operating
without a registration or license.
D. For purposes of completing
an application in either paper or electronic form, for a permit to
conduct activities subject to this Subchapter, the actual applicant
does not need to possess a registration/license, as long as the
applicant is acting on behalf a validly registered/licensed
contractor and it will be the registered/licensed contractor who is
doing the work.
E. Officer/Partner
Cards/Certificates shall no longer be issued. All current
cards/certificates shall expire on December 31, 2019.
F. All Registration/License
requirements must be maintained and kept current for the duration of
the Registration/License.
1.6.2 Transfer of
Registration/License Prohibited
Any registration/license
issued to an individual contractor, subcontractor, or business entity
is for the exclusive use of that individual or entity and is
non-transferrable.
1.6.3 Display of
Registration/License Number
A. All Persons subject to the
provisions of this Subchapter shall display their
registration/license number in a conspicuous manner on all forms of
advertising, including but not limited to newsprint classified
advertising, newsprint display advertising, pamphlets, telephone
directory space ads, online ads, website ads, social media ads,
business vehicles, and display ads.
B. Advertising in any form by
an unregistered/unlicensed person shall be prohibited, including
alphabetical or classified directory listings, vehicles, business
cards, and all other forms of advertisements.
C. Registration/license
numbers must be included on all written contracts, proposals, and
invoices.
D. The wearing of company
apparel is exempt from the requirement to include the
registration/license number.
1.6.4 Business Entity
Registrations / Licenses
A. Any corporation, LLC, or
partnership which meets the registration/ licensing requirements may
obtain a registration/license upon approval by the Board. The
registrant/licensee shall be identified as the responsible person on
the application.
B. The responsible person is
required to meet all applicable requirements for
registration/licensing, including, but not limited to providing
evidence of the required insurance and bond and maintaining the
required continuing education credit. If the listed responsible
person disaffiliates from the business entity or becomes
unregistered/unlicensed, the business entity must identify a new
responsible person who meets the registration/licensing requirements
of that discipline in accordance with § 1.6.7 of this Part.
C. Corporate Documents:
1. If the registrant/licensee
is required to be registered with, and certified by, the Rhode Island
Secretary of State, the applicant must provide the names of the
corporate officers and a copy of the corporate papers filed with the
Secretary of State as part of its application.
2. The registrant/licensee is
required to notify the Board of any lapse or revocation of corporate
status with the Secretary of State.
1.6.5 Nonresident Persons /
Registered Agent
No registration/license shall
be issued to a nonresident applicant until he or she has filed with
the Board a power of attorney constituting and appointing a
registered agent upon whom all processes in any action or legal
proceeding against him or her may be served, and in the power of
attorney agrees that any lawful process against him or her which may
be served upon his or her registered agent is of the same force and
validity as if served on the nonresident applicant, and that the
force continues irrevocably in force until such time as the Board has
been duly notified in writing of any change to that status.
1.6.6 Change of
Registration
A. Registered individuals or
business entities may make application to the Board for a change in
their registration. Upon approval by the Board, the former
registration number may be transferred to the new registration.
B. When such a change is made,
the new registrant shall be responsible for any claims and violations
made against the former registrant that are within the jurisdiction
of the Board.
C. Nothing within this section
shall be construed to limit the availability of any other remedies
available to the Board or complainant.
1.6.7 Effect on
Registration/License Due to Loss of Responsible Person
A. If the responsible person
disaffiliates or otherwise becomes incapacitated, the entity's
registration/license shall remain valid until the next examination,
or until such times as the Board allows.
B. It shall be the sole
responsibility of the entity to appoint a new responsible person that
satisfies the registration/license requirements of this Subchapter.
C. In no event, shall the
registration/license remain valid for longer than six (6) months
after the disaffiliation or incapacitation of the responsible person,
without satisfying the registration/licensing requirements of this
Subchapter.
1.7 Applications for
Registration/Licensure
Unless otherwise indicated in
R.I. Gen. Laws Chapters 5-65, 5-65.1, 5-65.2, 5-65.3, 5-73, and/or
Parts 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 of this Subchapter, the following provisions
shall apply to all persons subject to this Subchapter.
1.7.1 General Application
A. All persons applying for
registration/license by the Board shall submit an application in a
manner as prescribed by the Board, meet all
pre-registration/licensing requirements, and submit the applicable
fee, prior to obtaining registration/licensure.
B. The Board may reject an
incomplete application and return the application with an explanation
of the deficiencies.
C. All applicants for a
registration/license, whether for initial or renewal, shall
acknowledge the following "statement" by affixing their
signature to the application prior to the application being
considered by the Board.
1. “I acknowledge,
understand, and agree that if a complaint is filed against me, I will
attend and participate, in good faith, with any attempts to resolve
the complaint by the Board, including, but not limited to informal
resolutions, formal resolutions, and the administrative hearing
process. My failure to do so may result in the imposition of fines
against me and/or the suspension or revocation of my
registration/licensure.
D. All registration/license
applications shall be submitted via mail, on-site dropbox, or
in-person via appointment only. Walk in renewals will not be
accepted.
1.7.2 Examination
A. As required, applicants
shall pass such examination as the Board deems necessary to test the
applicant's knowledge and skills prior to engaging in a discipline
regulated by the Board.
B. Examinations will be
conducted at least three times a year by an approved third-party
testing company. Testing locations, dates, times, and fees will be
posted on the Board’s website.
C. Upon successful completion
of the examination, the applicant must submit a copy of their exam
certification to the Board with his/her application.
D. If an applicant does not
successfully complete the examination, he/she may retake the
examination in accordance with the third-party testing company's
policies.
E. The Board or the Director
may defer or waive the examination requirements for
applicants/registrants/licensees whose educational or training
requirements are not only an examination in the event that a state of
emergency has been declared by the Governor or for good cause shown
by the applicant/registrant/licensee.
1.7.3 Effective Date / Term
A. Registrations/licenses
issued pursuant to this Subchapter are effective upon issuance by the
Board.
B. Registrations/licenses are
valid for two (2) years from the date issued, unless the
registrations/licenses were granted with an examination waiver.
C. Any registrations/licenses
granted with an examination waiver will expire 90 days after the
State of Emergency has been lifted, unless the
applicant/registrant/licensee submits successful completion of the
examination to the Board.
D. The Board or the Director
may extend the date of registration/license expiration in the event
that a state of emergency has been declared by the Governor.
1.7.4 Renewal and
Reissuance of Registration/License
A. A registration/license may
be renewed by the same procedure provided for an original
registration/license, upon application, payment of the fee, and any
additional supplemental information the Board may require.
B. Unless ordered by the
Board, written examinations and pre-education requirements are not a
required component of renewal.
C. A registration/license
which has been voluntarily and temporarily surrendered shall be
reinstated at no additional charge if reinstatement occurs within the
registration/license period and there are no outstanding claims
and/or violations pending. If there are outstanding claims or
violations pending, the claims and/or violations must be resolved
prior to reinstatement.
D. A registration/license
which has been revoked or suspended may be reissued or reinstated
upon written request to the Board and satisfaction of all other
requirements as ordered by the Board.
E. The Board has the
discretion to conditionally reissue or reinstate a
registration/license which has been revoked or suspended in a manner
not inconsistent with the general laws and provisions of this
Subchapter.
F. It is the responsibility of
the registrant/licensee to ensure that the requirements for renewal,
including timeliness, are met.
G. Effective March 17, 2020,
there shall be a sixty (60) day extension on the time to file a
renewal application
H. All registration/license
renewal applications shall be submitted via mail, on-site dropbox, or
in-person via appointment only. Walk in renewals will not be
accepted.
1.7.5 Lapsed
Registration/License
A. A registration/license is
deemed to have lapsed when it has not been renewed on/or before its
expiration date. During this time, the person shall not solicit,
perform, or offer to perform contracting services.
B. If a registration/license
becomes invalid or lapsed, any registration/ license card(s) and/or
registration/license certificates must be returned to the Board
within five (5) business days.
C. If a registration/license
lapses for more than six (6) months, the person shall be required to
meet the requirements for an original registration, including
application, examination, pre-educational requirements, and payment
of the fee, in addition to any back fees, penalties, and any
additional supplemental information the Board may require.
D. Waiver of Requirements Upon
a Showing of Good Cause
1. The Board may consider
granting a waiver of the renewal requirements for lapsed licenses
upon a showing of good cause.
2. The request shall be in
writing and shall state the reasons for the waiver.
3. Good cause includes, but is
not limited to, illness, incapacitation, disability, (which is
supported by a medical documentation) or military service.
1.7.6 Military Service
Registration/License:
A. Military Service Member
1. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Laws § 5-87-1, applicants who are members of the military
service and possess a registration/license from another state may
provide proof of education, training, or service completed as a
member of the Armed Forces or Reserves of the United States, the
National Guard of any state, the Military Reserves of any state, or
the Naval Militia of any state and evidence of their out-of-state
registration/license.
2. The Board will consider
whether the education, training, and/or service is substantially
equivalent to the requirements of this state. If so, the Board will
attempt to expedite the issuance of the appropriate
registration/license to the applicant.
3. If the Board determines
that the education, training, and service are not substantially
equivalent to the requirements of this state, the Board may issue the
service member a temporary registration/license for a period of time
sufficient to allow the applicant to complete any specific
requirements to obtain registration/licensure in this state.
B. Military Service Member’s
Spouse:
1. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Laws § 5-88-1, the Board will expedite the issuance of
registrations/licenses for applicants:
a. Who are registered/licensed
in another state to perform contracting services in a state other
than Rhode Island;
b. Whose spouse is a member
of the Armed Forces of the United States;
c. Whose spouse is the subject
of a military transfer to Rhode Island; and
d. Who left employment to
accompany their spouse to Rhode Island, may apply to the Board for a
registration/license based on the out of state registration/license.
2. If the Board determines
that the out of state registration/license is substantially
equivalent to the requirements of this state, the Board may issue the
applicant a registration/license.
3. If the Board determines
that the out of state registration/license is not substantially
equivalent to the requirements of this state, the Board may issue the
applicant a temporary registration/license for a period of time
sufficient to allow the applicant to complete any specific
requirements to obtain registration/licensure in this state.
1.8 Education Requirements –
Pre-Registration/License and Continuing Education
1.8.1 Scope
The Board adopts the
following education standards and requirements for persons
registered/licensed with the Board. The Board may have third-party
vendors or providers assist in the management of educational
programs.
1.8.2 Specifications
A. If applicable, as a
condition of applying for, or renewing a registration/license issued
by the Board, the educational requirements specified for that
discipline must be met.
B. If the registrant/licensee
holds another registration/license issued by the Board, educational
credits may be used to satisfy the education requirements for all
registrations/licenses held by the same person. The
registrant/licensee will be required to provide proof of completion
of the education credits from Board-approved courses.
C. Documentation of all credit
hours must be submitted to the Board at the time of application for,
or renewal of, a registration/license.
D. One (1) credit hour of
education is equal to fifty (50) minutes of instruction by a
Board-approved provider.
1.8.3 Qualifying Education
A. Each registrant/licensee
must obtain his/her pre-education and/or continuing education credits
through a Board-approved provider.
B. Courses must pertain to the
subject matter of the discipline for which the person holds the
registration/license.
C. Subject matter not
acceptable for pre- or continuing education credit includes, but is
not limited to:
1. Mechanical office and
business skills such as typing, speed reading or memory improvement;
2. Physical well-being or
personal development, such as motivation, stress management, time
management, dress for success; or
3. Meetings held in
conjunction with the general business of the registrant/licensee.
1.8.4 Course Materials and
Fees
Each
applicant/registrant/licensee shall be responsible for the cost of
all course-related fees and acquiring any course materials used in
any pre-education or continuing education course. This requirement
may include the acquisition of a current publication of codes and/or
standards or rules that may be applicable to the
applicant/registrant/licensee’s discipline.
1.8.5 Proof of Educational
Course Completion/Compliance
A. The
applicant/registrant/licensee is responsible for demonstrating
compliance with and completion of the pre-education and continuing
education requirements.
B. The
applicant/registrant/licensee is required to provide proof of course
completion to the Board for both initial registration/licensure and
renewal of registration/licensure.
C. The
applicant/registrant/licensee must retain the original documents for
his/her current registration period and for three (3) years following
the completion of the course(s).
D. Course certificates shall
include:
1. the name, date, and
identifying number of the course;
2. the number of credit hours
completed;
3. the contact information of
the provider and the instructor;
4. any accreditation
information; and
5. the signature of the
instructor.
1.8.6 Educational
Requirements
A. The specific requirements
for the individual disciplines can be found as follows:
1. Contractors and
subcontractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65 and Part 2 of this
Subchapter.
2. Underground Utility
Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.3 and Part 3 of this
Subchapter.
3. Commercial Roofing
Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-73 and Part 4 of this
Subchapter.
4. Well Drilling, Pump
Installers, and Water Filtration Contractors: R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter
5-65.2 and Part 5 of this Subchapter.
5. Home Inspectors: R.I. Gen.
Laws Chapter 5-65.1 and Part 6 of this Subchapter.
1.8.7 Exceptions to
Education Requirements
A. The Board or the Director
may defer or waive some, or all, of the pre-education or continuing
education requirements in the event that a state of emergency has
been declared by the Governor or for good cause shown by the
applicant/registrant/licensee. Good cause may include, but not be
limited to, illness, incapacitation, disability, (which is supported
by a medical documentation) or military service.
B. Upon request and payment of
a one-hundred dollar ($100.00) fee to the Board, a
registrant/licensee may be granted one (1) time, within a two
(2)-year renewal cycle, a six (6) month deferral to complete his/her
continuing education requirements.
C. Commercial Contractors are
exempt from the Education Requirements of this Subchapter.
1.8.8 Violations for
Failing to Complete Education Requirements
The Board may revoke,
suspend, or refuse to issue, reinstate, or reissue a
registration/license if the applicant/registrant/licensee has failed
to complete or maintain the required pre-education or continuing
education credits.
1.8.9 Educational Course
Providers
A. The Board shall review,
assess, approve and/or deny applications for educational course
providers, instructors, and training curriculum. As necessary,
information shall be presented to the full Board for consideration.
B. Educational Course
Providers
1. All providers of
educational courses must first be authorized and approved by the
Board. A current list of approved providers and courses shall be
maintained on the Board’s website.
2. Educational course provider
permits are valid for two (2) years and expire biannually on the date
of issuance.
3. Each authorized Provider
must designate one individual as an authorized agent. The authorized
agent shall:
a. Maintain records
documenting attendance of students;
b. Notify the Board of any
change in the address or telephone number of the authorized provider
or any change of the authorized agent within seven days of such
change; and
c. Ensure that only qualified
instructors are permitted to teach the curriculum that contributes
toward certification for registration, licensure, and/or continuing
education.
4. Each authorized provider
shall provide to the Board a list of all directors and owners of the
school, including their names, addresses and license numbers, if
applicable, and shall maintain the record of those directors and
owners for at least three (3) years.
5. The Board may suspend,
revoke, fine, or refuse to renew the permit of any provider that
fails to adhere to the laws pertaining to registration/licensure,
this regulation, or a directive of the Board, including:
a. Failure to maintain
records as required by this § 1.8 of this Part;
b. Failure to notify the
Board of any change of address or telephone number of the authorized
agent;
c. Failure to provide the
Board with copies of or access to requested information;
d. Failure to use the exact
name of the authorized provider on any postings, advertisements,
solicitations, or any other medium of communication;
e. Obtaining a provider
permit by false pretenses or substantial misrepresentation or
omission;
f. Any misleading or
untruthful advertising;
g. Discriminating against an
individual based on any protected class designated in the Rhode
Island Fair Housing Practices Act, R.I. Gen. Laws § 34-37-1 et
seq.;
h. Failing to provide the
appropriate certification of completion to an individual completing
the curriculum for registration, licensure, or continuing education;
and/or
i. Providing certification of
completion to an individual who has not completed such curriculum.
C. Educational Course Provider
Application
1. Provider Application: To
become a Board-approved course provider, either as an organizational
provider or an individual provider, the applicant shall submit an
application to the Board, on a form as approved by the Board, that
contains the following information:
a. Name of training provider;
b. Business identifying number
(FEIN#);
c. Length of time providing
educational courses;
d. Physical address;
e. Phone number;
f. E-mail address;
g. Website address;
h. Type of instruction
(on-line, instructor led or both);
i. Business or individual
resume (basic description of business, credentials qualifying the
company or organization as a trainer);
k. Insurance coverage and
policy number (must have at least one million dollars ($1,000,000) in
liability coverage); and
k. A breakdown of the costs of
any fees that will be charged to the student, exclusive of books and
materials;
D. Certification
Each applicant for a Provider
permit shall attest under the pains and penalties of perjury that
they understand and agree to abide by the laws and regulations that
govern educational requirements.
E. Application Fee
The fee for all new and
renewal Educational Course Provider permits is two-hundred and fifty
($250) dollars.
F. Upon approval of the
Education Course Provider application, the Provider shall be assigned
an identification number.
G. Additional Requirements
1. Any facility where courses
will be taught shall be compliant with the American with Disabilities
Act, 42 U.S.C. § 12101 et seq.
2. Any facility where courses
will be taught shall be adequately lighted, heated/cooled, void of
distractions as much as possible, be equipped with the
teaching/learning equipment necessary to enhance learning (such as
media projectors, TV/VCR, marker board and/or other safety equipment
needed for instruction), have sufficient seating for attendees, and
have easily accessible restrooms available.
3. All information collected
from or provided by any applicant/registrant/ licensee shall not be
shared or provided to any third party without the express written
approval and consent of the applicant/registrant/licensee.
4. Upon request, the Provider
shall supply the Board with a list of
applicants/registrants/licensees who have completed the course,
including the applicant’s name, registration/license number,
and date of attendance and/or completion.
5. Educational Providers shall
require that each course attendee present a photo identification card
and affix their signature to the attendance roster.
1.8.10 Educational Courses
A. Requirements for Course
Approval
1. Requests for course
approvals must be provided to the Board at least thirty (30) days in
advance of the date of instruction.
2. The request must include:
a. A detailed course outline
with hours spent in each subject area;
b. Descriptions of the texts
and materials utilized in the course;
c Copies of tests,
examinations or other materials used to evaluate student performance;
and
d. A list of instructors and
their resumes.
3. Courses must consist of at
least one (1) credit hour of instruction.
a. Each hour of credit must
contain a minimum of fifty (50) minutes of instruction.
4 Courses must be taught by a
CRLB approved provider as set forth in § 1.8.9 of this Part.
5. Courses must substantially
relate to the work of the registrants/licensees that it seeks to
provide education for.
6. For each approved course,
the provider must maintain, and make readily available to the Board
for a period of three years upon request;
a. The materials provided in §
1.8.10(A)(2) of this Part;
b. Copies of student
evaluations of the course; and/or
c. Copies of certificates
issued to students.
B. Course Approval Fee
1. The fee for all new and
renewal course approvals is one-hundred ($100) dollars per course.
2. This fee shall be waived
for governmental organizations and non-profit entities, upon
sufficient proof of non-profit status. (i.e. 501(c)(3), annual
financial report, or IRS Form 990)
3. Approved courses shall be
valid for five (5) years and must be resubmitted for approval upon
expiration.
C. Instructor Qualification.
1. No person may act as an
instructor unless such person holds a registration/license and is in
good standing with the Board for the discipline in which the course
is offered for.
2. The Board may authorize
any person to act as an instructor, notwithstanding the requirements
of § 1.8 of this Part, if the person demonstrates that they have
the equivalent qualifications to those required by this section.
Equivalent qualifications may include, but are not limited to, the
following:
a. Demonstrated knowledge in
a particular subject matter;
b. Appointment to the faculty
of an accredited college, university or trade school; or
c. Current teaching
certificate with demonstrated industry specific knowledge or
experience.
3. Instructors may employ
specialists to teach particular portions of the curriculum and such
specialists need not obtain authorization from the Board. Specialists
may not be employed to teach the entire curriculum.
4. Current or prior
registrants/licensees whose registrations/licenses have been
suspended or revoked as a result of disciplinary action by the Board,
or the regulatory authority in another state, shall not qualify for
approval as an instructor.
D. Course/Instructor
Evaluations:
1. The Provider shall
distribute and review course/instructor evaluation forms at the
completion of each course.
2. Evaluation forms shall
include a contact name and phone number for the Contractors’
Registration and Licensing Board where complaints can be filed.
3. Evaluation forms shall be
maintained by the provider for a period of three (3) years following
the course completion date.
E. Instructor Credit:
1. Board-approved
pre-education and continuing education course instructors may use
their course instruction to satisfy the continuing education
requirement.
2. Instructors must provide
the Board with evidence of what Board-approved courses were taught,
when the course(s) were taught, and how many credit hours were
taught.
3. Instructors will receive
credit for teaching a particular course only once per renewal cycle.
4. A maximum of two (2)
Instructor Credit hours may be used per renewal cycle.
1.8.11 Violation for
Operating as Non-Approved Provider
Any individual or
organization who acts as a provider or instructor without being
properly approved by the Board, or who provides the Board with any
falsified information or documentation, may be prevented from
obtaining future approval as a provider or instructor.
1.8.12 Penalties for
Provider Noncompliance
Any provider or instructor
who violates these requirements or falsifies documentation may be
subject to having their provider or instructor status revoked. A
provider or instructor with a revoked status may petition the Board
for reinstatement.
1.9 Complaints
1.9.1 Duty to Participate
All persons who are
registered/licensed, or who are required to be registered/licensed,
shall participate and make good faith efforts to resolve all
complaints, violations, and/or contested cases within the
jurisdiction of the Board. Failure to do so shall result in the Board
taking action against the respondent, to the extent allowable by law,
including suspension or revocation of a contractor’s
registration/license, without which an individual cannot work as a
contractor in the state.
1.9.2 Complaints Generally
A. Complaints shall only be
accepted for work or services performed within the boundaries of the
State of Rhode Island, or for materials or equipment supplied or
rented for fabrication into or use upon structures located within the
boundaries of the State of Rhode Island. Unless otherwise specified,
the Board shall only accept complaints from complainants who can
demonstrate standing to bring the complaint.
B. A complaint may be made by
any Person against any registrant/licensee or any Person who is
required to be registered/licensed but is not registered/licensed by
the Board. Such statement of complaint shall be in writing, signed
by the complainant, and made on a form as required by the Board.
C. A complaint may contain an
allegation of a claim and/or violations.
D. When submitting a
complaint, complainants are encouraged to provide copies of all
supporting documentation, including but not limited to:
1. Written contracts and
agreements;
2. Invoices;
3. Billings;
4. Estimates;
5. Receipts;
6. Cancelled checks;
7. Court or arbitration
information/judgments; and
8. Notices of counter claims
by respondents.
D. Initial Acceptance or
Denial of Complaint. The Board shall make an initial determination as
to whether the complaint is within the Board's jurisdiction and meets
the requirements of R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65. If jurisdiction
exists and the requirements for acceptance are met, the Board shall
process the complaint. If jurisdiction does not exist, and/or the
requirements for acceptance are not met, the Board shall deny the
complaint.
E. Complaints Based on Valid
Contract Containing an Arbitration Clause
1. A complaint for work
performed pursuant to a valid contract which contains a requirement
that the parties resolve their dispute through an arbitration
process, shall not be accepted by the Board, unless both parties,
within forty-five (45) days of the filing of the complaint, agree in
writing to waive the arbitration clause and consent to the
jurisdiction of the Board for resolution of the dispute.
2. If the dispute is resolved
through arbitration, the decision may be submitted to the Board for
consideration of whether the decision establishes the basis for
disciplinary action against the registration/license of the
contractor, not inconsistent with any applicable general laws and/or
this Subchapter.
F. Limitations on Complaint
Process
1. If the investigation
determines that the potential monetary damages and/or restitution
exceeds ten-thousand dollars ($10,000), in accordance with R.I. Gen.
Laws § 5-65-12(b), the Board may refuse to continue processing
the claim and refer the complainant to Superior Court.
2. If the Hearing Officer
determines that a violation of R.I. Gen. Laws Chapters 5-65, 5-65.1,
5-65.2, 5-65.3, 5-73, and/or Parts 1-6 of this Subchapter has
occurred, the Hearing Officer may;
a. Order that a
registrant/licensee complete any unfinished work;
b. Return a deposit if no work
has commenced;
c. Issue fines;
d. Suspend or revoke a
registration/license; and/or
e. Order the contractor to
take additional educational classes if necessary.
3. A Hearing Officer cannot
order the Respondent to pay monetary damages and/or restitution.
However, the payment of monetary damages and/or restitution can be
agreed to by the Parties as part of any settlement/agreement.
4. If applicable, a claim may
be brought in the Superior Court, pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws §
5-65-12.1.
1.9.3 Board Initiated
Investigations
A. The Board, on its own
authority, may initiate an investigation and take action against:
1. A registrant/licensee;
2. An applicant for a
registration/license or for renewal of a registration/license;
3. Any Person who is required
to be registered/licensed but is not registered/licensed; and/or
4. Any Person who is subject
to the regulatory authority of the Board.
B. All such actions shall be
upon such terms and conditions as are permitted under applicable law
and this Subchapter.
1.9.4 The Board's Right to
Refuse and/or Dismiss Complaints
A. The Board may, in its sole
discretion, refuse to accept, or at any time refuse to continue
processing a complaint if:
1. The complaint involves a
contract that is administered, reviewed, and inspected by a local,
state, or federal agency when disbursement or administration of the
contract sum is contingent upon the approval of that agency;
2. The complainant fails to
respond to the Board’s written requests for information or
documentation within a time period specified by the Board;
3. The complainant does not
allow access to the property for investigation purposes;
4. The Board determines that
based on the nature or complexity of the issues, the amount in
controversy, and/or legal issues presented, a court of competent
jurisdiction or an alternate forum is more suited to adjudicate the
matter;
5. The same issues involved in
the complaint have been submitted by either party to a court,
arbitration, or other forum authorized by law to affect a resolution
prior to the administrative hearing;
6. The facts and issues of the
complaint are substantially the same as those in a complaint
previously filed by the same complainant, unless the complaint
concerns a repair previously ordered by the Board;
7. The Board determines that
the person against whom the complaint is filed is capable of
complying with the recommendations made by the Board relative to the
claim, but the complainant does not permit the respondent to comply
with those recommendations; or
8. The Board determines that
the value of the damages due to the complainant is less than that
owed to the respondent under the terms of the contract.
B. If at any time during the
complaint process the complainant accepts a valid promissory note
from the Registrant/Licensee as settlement of the claim, the Board
shall dismiss the claim. Dismissal of the claim will be final, and
the claim will not be reopened.
1.10 Notice of Accepted
Complaints and Initial Board Investigation
A. The Board shall give notice
to all Parties of the acceptance of a complaint. The notice shall
include:
1. A reference to the
particular sections of the statutes and rules involved; and,
2. A short and plain statement
of the matters asserted.
B. Initial Board Investigation
1. The Board may conduct an
initial investigation and make attempts to informally resolve the
matter between the Parties. If the matter can be resolved informally,
the agreement shall be reduced to writing and signed by the Parties.
2. The initial Board
investigation and attempts to informally resolve the matter shall be
completed within sixty (60) days of acceptance of the complaint. Time
may be extended for good cause, but in no event shall the matter
remain at the initial investigation stage for more than ninety (90)
days.
3. If the matter is not
resolved within sixty (60) days, or extended for good cause, it shall
be referred to the Hearing Officer for further administrative
proceedings in accordance with § 1.11 of this Part.
1.11 Pre-hearing
Conferences/Alternative Dispute Resolution
1.11.1 Pre-Hearing
Conferences
A. It is the policy of the
Board to encourage the use of prehearing conferences to make more
effective use of hearing time.
B. The Director or the Hearing
Officer may, with reasonable written notice, require that all Parties
attend a prehearing conference and/or attempt alternative dispute
resolution to resolve the matter and/or consider the following:
1. The simplification,
narrowing, and clarification of the issues;
2. The possibility of
obtaining written stipulations, admissions, agreements with respect
to the introduction of documents or similar agreements which will
avoid unnecessary proof;
3. The identification of
witnesses and the limitation of the number of witnesses;
4. The possibility of
agreement disposing of all or any of the issues in dispute;
5. The consideration of
outstanding motions;
6. The status of settlement
negotiations, if any;
7. The use of pre-filed
testimony, where appropriate;
8. Any matters of discovery,
including limitation of data requests, document requests, or other
discovery or resolving disputes as to the scope of discovery;
9. Scheduling of hearings; and
10. Any such other matters as
may aid in the final disposition of the proceeding.
1.11.2 Alternative Dispute
Resolution
A. It is the policy of the
Board to also encourage the use of alternative dispute resolution to
resolve a complaint.
B. Mediation
1. Mediation is a means by
which a trained impartial third person assists the Parties in
reaching a settlement/agreement.
2. The mediator is appointed
by the Director and has no decision-making authority. If the mediator
is an attorney, the mediator cannot provide legal advice to the
parties.
a. No Hearing Officer assigned
to the matter shall serve as the mediator.
3. If an agreement/settlement
is reached between the parties, the mediator may assist in preparing
the written settlement/agreement to be signed by the Parties.
4. Mediation shall be
conducted pursuant to the requirements of R.I. Gen. Laws §
9-19-44.
C. Consented to Final Order
1. A consented to Final Order
is a settlement/agreement reached between the parties with the
assistance of the Hearing Officer. Unlike mediation, the Hearing
Officer may actively participate and assist the Parties in reaching
the settlement/agreement.
2. The Hearing Officer is
appointed by the Director. The Hearing Officer cannot provide legal
advice to the Parties.
3. If an agreement/settlement
is reached between the parties, the Hearing Officer shall prepare a
Consented to Final Order, which shall be reduced to writing and
signed by the Parties and the Hearing Officer.
1.11.3 Pre-Hearing/Alternative
Dispute Resolution Procedures
A. All Parties shall
participate in the prehearing conference and/or alternative dispute
resolution fully prepared to discuss all matters related to the
proceedings. Failure of any Party to attend the prehearing
conference and/or alternative dispute resolution may constitute a
waiver of all objections to any order or ruling issued as a result of
the prehearing conference and/or alternative dispute resolution
unless good cause is shown.
B. At the sole discretion of
the Hearing Officer, the Parties may be permitted to waive the
prehearing conference and/or alternative dispute resolution by filing
with the Hearing Officer a stipulation prior to the prehearing
conference and/or alternative dispute resolution that contains the
following:
1. Agreement to the issues in
the matter,
2. An agreed to discovery
schedule,
3. Three (3) agreed to
possible dates for a hearing, and
4. Any other agreements as to
matters contained in § 1.11.1(B) of this Part.
C. In the discretion of the
Hearing Officer, with agreement of the parties, prehearing
conferences, conference hearings, alternative dispute resolution, or
status hearings may be held by telephone, electronically, or by any
other means.
D. Alternative Dispute
Resolution sessions shall be conducted via teleconference other
electronic means whenever possible. In-person sessions shall be
conducted only when the ability to utilize teleconferencing or other
electronic means is unavailable or burdensome as agreed to by the
Parties.
1.11.4 Administrative
Hearings Based on Contested Cases
A. If the Parties cannot reach
an agreement with the assistance of the Hearing Officer, with the
consent of both Parties, the Parties may request that the Hearing
Officer decide the issues by conducting an administrative hearing in
accordance with § 1.14 of this Part.
1. Emergency hearings shall be
conducted as required. An emergency hearing is a hearing that
determines the status of a registrant or licensee who is alleged to
be acting to the detriment of the health, welfare and safety of the
general public.
2. All other hearings shall be
scheduled once the State of Emergency is lifted.
B. Upon conclusion of the
administrative hearing, the Hearing Officer will issue a Final Order.
C. A Final Order issued
pursuant to this subsection may be appealed in accordance with §
1.13.2 of this Part.
1.12 Violations
1.12.1 Authority
A. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Laws Chapters 5-65, 5-65.1, 5-65.2, 5-65.3, 5-73, and this
Subchapter, investigative members of the Board may issue violations
to registrants/licensees, or those required to be registered/licensed
with the Board, for violations of statute, or any Part of this
Subchapter.
B. The Board may also
immediately suspend or revoke any registration or license for just
cause when the registrant/licensee is acting to the detriment of the
health, welfare and safety of the general public. Under this
provision revocation and suspension may be extended beyond the
initial thirty (30) days after the opportunity for an administrative
hearing has occurred.1.12.2 Procedure for Investigating and
Processing Violations
A. Notices of Violation shall
be issued for, but are not limited to, the following conduct
1. Court judgment against a
contractor;
2. Claims;
3. Disciplinary action;
4. Lack of insurance
policy/coverage;
5. Lack of workers’
compensation coverage;
6. Lack of minimum bond or
proof of bonding capacity;
7. Improper advertising;
8. Hiring
non-registered/non-licensed contractor(s) or subcontractor(s);
9. No registration/license
number on contract;
10. No registration/license
number in advertisement;
11. No mechanics’ lien
release form/notice provided in contract;
12. No right of rescission
clause;
13. Action filed by entity
such as building official, municipality, another agency, etc.;
14. Failure to list
employee(s);
15. Violation of State
Building Code;
16. Violation of rule,
regulation or order of the Board;
17. Working under an invalid,
revoked, or suspended registration/license;
18. Registrant/licensee
engaged in conduct dishonest or fraudulent conduct;
19. Working under another
person’s registration/license number;
20. Lien filed whereby
registrant/licensee wrongfully failed to perform a contractual duty
to pay person claiming lien;
21. Registrant/licensee made
false statements on application or to investigative staff;
22. Engaged in any act,
conduct, or practice which violates this Subchapter;
23. Knowingly making a false
or fraudulent statement on an application;
24. Failure to provide list of
sub-contractors or employees;
25. Failure to comply with the
disclosure requirements; and/or
26. Failure to comply with the
educational requirements.
1.12.3 Notice of Violation
A. When a violation occurs, a
written Notice of Violation shall be issued to the
Registrant/Licensee in accordance with R.I. Gen. Law § 5-65-6.
B. The Notice of Violation
shall contain:
1. The identifying
information of the respondent;
2. The grounds for issuance;
3. The fine amount and due
date of payment; and
4. The respondent's right to
appeal.
1.12.4 Fines/Penalties
A. Monetary fines and
administrative penalties shall be imposed in accordance with R.I.
Gen. Laws Chapter 5-65.
B. In determining the
appropriate fine(s) and/or penalties to impose, the Board shall look
to past precedence of the Board for guidance and may consider any
mitigating or aggravating circumstances as known to the Board at the
time of the determination. Such circumstances may include, but are
not limited to the following:
1. The presence of lack of
past violations;
2. The Respondent's acceptance
of responsibility and candor with the Board;
3. The egregiousness of the
violation; and/or
4. Harm to the public.
C. Any fines assessed against
the respondent are due and payable upon the issuance of the Notice of
Violation(s), unless otherwise agreed to by the Board. The Board may
initiate its own collection proceedings and actions pursuant to
applicable law. Interest may be assessed on the amount due in the
final order in accordance with applicable law
D. For matters that are
appealed pursuant to §§ 1.13.1 and 1.13.2 of this Part, the
Hearing Officer and/or the Board may address, modify, and/or impose
fines for additional violations or matters based on the evidence
presented.
1.12.5 Court
Judgements/Arbitration Awards - Effect on Registration/License
A. A judgment/award issued by
a forum other than the Board may serve as the basis for disciplinary
action against a registrant/licensee.
B. The judgment/award must be
provided to the Board within ninety (90) days of entry in its
original forum. Upon receipt of a timely filed court
judgment/arbitration award, the Board may issue a notice of hearing
and schedule an administrative hearing to take action against the
registrant/licensee, utilizing the judgment/award as the basis for
such action.
1.13 Appeals
1.13.1 Appeal of Notice of
Violation to Hearing Officer
A. The issuance of a Notice of
Violation may be appealed to the Hearing Officer by requesting a
hearing in writing to the Board within twenty (20) days of the date
of mailing or issuance of the Notice of Violation.
1. If timely filed, the
Hearing Officer shall hold an administrative hearing in accordance
with § 1.15 of this Part.
2. Upon conclusion of the
hearing, the Hearing Officer shall issue a Final Order.
3. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Law § 5-65-6, a Final Order shall be considered delivered
when deposited in the United States mail and/or sent registered or
certified or post office receipt secured to the last known address of
record.
B. If the Board does not
receive a written request for an Appeal within twenty (20) days of
the date of mailing the Notice of Violation, and the Respondent has
not paid and/or complied with its requirements, the Notice of
Violation shall automatically convert to a Final Order.
C. Appeals/Requests for
Hearings which are timely filed, shall be scheduled once the State of
Emergency has been lifted. All enforcement and fines due shall be
stayed until such time as the hearing officer has issued an appeal
decision.
1.13.2 Appeal of Final
Order by the Hearing Officer to the Full Board
A. A Final Order issued
pursuant to §§ 1.11.4 or 1.13.1 of this Part, may be
appealed to the Full Board by requesting an appeal in writing to the
Board within twenty (20) days of the date of mailing or issuance of
the Final Order.
B. If timely filed, the Full
Board shall hear the appeal during one of its Board meetings,
pursuant to the Open Meetings Act, R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 42-46.
C. Board Consideration of
Appeal:
1. Members of the Full Board
shall only consider evidence presented to the Hearing Officer, issues
raised in the appeal, and written and/or oral argument relative to
the Final Order issued by the Hearing Officer.
2. Time allowed for oral
argument may be limited by the Board.
3. The Board will not consider
new or additional evidence.
4. The Board may allow the
Board staff investigator to report on his/her investigative findings.
D. Upon conclusion of the
testimony and consideration of the evidence and argument, the Board
shall issue a decision affirming, modifying, dismissing, or remanding
the violation back to the Hearing Officer.
E. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Law § 5-65-6, the decision shall be considered delivered
when deposited in the United States mail and/or sent registered or
certified or post office receipt secured to the last known address of
record.
F. Decisions of the Full Board
may be appealed to the Superior Court in accordance with §
1.13.3 of this Part.
G. Appeals which are timely
filed, shall be scheduled once the State of Emergency has been
lifted. All enforcement and fines due shall be stayed until such time
as the hearing officer has issued an appeal decision.
1.13.3 Appeal of Decision
by the Full Board to the Superior Court
Pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws §
42-35-15, any Party aggrieved by a decision of the Full Board may
file an appeal with the Superior Court.
1.14 Criminal Prosecution
Once all appeal rights have
been extinguished, if a Respondent fails to comply with a Final
Order, or a decision of the Full Board, the Board may refer the case
to the Office of the Attorney General for criminal prosecution.
1.15 Administrative Hearings
Administrative hearings shall
comply with the requirements of R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 42-35, the
enabling acts of the Board, and this Subchapter.
1.15.1 Notice of Hearing:
A. A notice of administrative
hearing shall comply with R.I. Gen. Laws § 42-35-9(b).
B. Unless otherwise agreed to
by the Board and the parties, the Board shall schedule administrative
hearings before a hearing officer no sooner than twenty (20) calendar
days from the date the parties are notified of the hearing.
C. In accordance with R.I.
Gen. Law § 5-65-6, a notice of hearing shall be considered
delivered when deposited in the United States mail and/or sent
registered or certified or post office receipt secured to the last
known address of record.
D. For administrative hearings
related to the notice of violation, the Hearing Officer is the
appropriate forum. For an appeal related to a Final Order of the
Hearing Officer, the appropriate forum is the Full Board.
1.15.2 Representation
A. Appearances.
1. The Board shall notify each
Party that each Party may retain legal counsel admitted in the State
of Rhode Island.
2. Individuals and partners of
partnerships may appear pro se if they choose. Corporations may be
represented by an officer in the corporation, even if not a member of
the state bar.
3. If a Party is not
representing themselves, the Party must be represented by a member,
in good standing, of the Bar of the State of Rhode Island, or by an
out of state attorney who has been admitted pro hac vice by the
Superior Court or by the appropriate court, unless exempted pursuant
to R.I. Gen. Laws § 11-27-11.
4. All attorneys must conform
to the standards of ethical conduct required of practitioners before
the courts of the State of Rhode Island.
B. Appearances of Present and
Former Employees of the Board.
1. No person who is currently
an employee or member of the Board may appear before the Board or
Department on behalf of any Person, or to represent any Person, or
act as an expert witness before the Board or Department, except in
the performance of his/her official duties as an employee or member
of the Board.
2. No person having been so
employed, or as a member of the Board may, within one (1) year after
said employment has ceased, appear before the Board or Department on
behalf of any other Person, or to represent any Person, or act as an
expert witness before the Board or Department.
1.15.3 Filing of Pleadings
and Other Documents
A. All pleadings and other
documents filed in any Contested Case shall, whenever possible, state
the file number, if any, the title of the proceeding and the name of
the Person on whose behalf the filing is made.
B. Form and Size. All
pleadings and other documents filed, except those documents which are
kept in a smaller or larger format during the ordinary course of
business, are to be submitted on 8½ by 11 inch paper. At the
discretion of the Hearing Officer or Board, filings may be made by
telecopier, facsimile, or by electronic mail or any other manner or
means approved by the Hearing Officer. If filings are made
electronically, the Party shall also file a hard copy of any such
electronic filing. All documents must include, if applicable, the
Rhode Island Bar number, address, telephone number, facsimile number
and email address of each attorney and pro se litigant. All papers
shall be filed during Regular Business Hours. The Board or
Department’s date stamp shall be presumptive of the actual date
of filing.
C. Signature. The original
copy of each pleading shall be signed and dated by the Party on whose
behalf the pleading is made or by the Party's authorized
representative. This signature shall constitute a certification that
the individual has read the document, knows the contents thereof and
to the best of his/her knowledge believes that such statements are
true, that it is not interposed for delay and that if the pleading
has been signed by an authorized representative, he/she has full
power and authority to do so.
D. Construction. All pleadings
shall be liberally construed and errors or defects therein which do
not mislead or affect the substantial rights of the Parties involved
may be disregarded.
1.15.4 Service
A. Service Upon Parties and
Others. A copy of all pleadings and other documents filed in any
proceeding governed by this Part shall be served upon all other
Parties.
B. Manner of Service. Unless
otherwise ordered or authorized by the Hearing Officer, Board, or
Department, service under this Part shall be made upon a Party or
upon the Party's attorney, in accordance with R.I. Gen. Laws §
5-65-6.
C. Certificate of Service.
There shall accompany and be included in the original of each
pleading filed with the Board or Department a certificate of service
showing service on all Parties.
D. Date of Certificate to
Govern. In addition to the provisions of § 1.12.5 of this Part,
the time for response to all pleadings shall commence as of the date
of the certificate of service. However, if service is made by mail,
then one (1) day shall be added to the prescribed period.
1.15.5 Time
A. Computation. Unless
otherwise specifically provided by law, computation of any time
period referred to in this Part shall begin with the first day
following the act which initiates the running of the time period
(including Saturday, Sunday and legal holidays). The last day of the
time period so computed is to be included unless it is a Saturday,
Sunday or legal holiday or any other day on which the Board is
closed, in which case the period shall run until the end of Regular
Business Hours of the next following business day.
B. Extensions of Time. It
shall be within the discretion of the Hearing Officer, for good cause
shown, to extend any time limit. All requests for extensions of time
shall be made by written motion filed with the Hearing Officer before
the expiration of the applicable time period unless waived by the
Hearing Officer.
C. Continuances. Except as
otherwise provided by law, the Hearing Officer may, at any time, with
or without request, continue or adjourn a prehearing conference or a
hearing. If a Party requests a continuance, the Hearing Officer may
direct the Party to seek the assent of the other Party(ies) prior to
deciding whether to grant such request. If the Hearing Officer
grants a continuance at the request of a Party(ies), the Hearing
Officer may direct the Party(ies) requesting the continuance to
immediately notify all other Parties of record and if deemed
necessary to prepare an order. If such an order is made, the
continuance will only be effective when the notification to all other
parties of record has been made.
1.15.6 Motions
A. General. Any Party may
request that the Hearing Officer enter any order or action not
inconsistent with law or this Part. The types of motions made shall
be those which are permissible under these Rules and the Rhode Island
Superior Court Rules of Civil Procedure (“Super. R. Civ. P.”).
B. Presentation/Objections to
Motions. Motions may be made in writing at any time before or after
the commencement of a prehearing conference or hearing, and/or they
may be made orally during a prehearing conference or hearing. Each
motion shall set forth and/or state the grounds for the desired order
or action and state whether oral argument is requested. Within ten
(10) days after a written motion is filed with the Hearing Officer
and served on the opposing Party(ies), a Party opposing said motion
must file a written objection to the granting of the motion, and
shall, if desired, request oral argument. All written motions and
objections shall be accompanied by a written memorandum specifying
the legal and factual basis for the Party's position.
C. Action on Motion. The
Hearing Officer shall, if he/she/it determines oral argument on the
motion is warranted, give notice of the time and place for such
argument. The Hearing Officer may rule on a motion without argument
if the motion involves a matter as to which the presentation of
testimony or oral argument would not advance the Hearing Officer’s
understanding of the issues involved or if disposition without
argument would best serve the public interest. The Hearing Officer
may act on a motion when all Parties have responded thereto, or the
deadline for response has passed, whichever comes first.
1.15.7 Discovery
A. General. The Board favors
prompt and complete disclosure and exchange of information and
encourages informal arrangements among the Parties for this exchange.
It is the Board's policy to encourage the timely use of discovery as
a means toward effective presentations at hearing and avoidance of
the use of cross-examination at hearing for discovery purposes.
B. Procedure. Any Party, by
written request served upon all other Parties, may request the other
Party to produce for inspection, copying or photocopying document,
object or tangible thing which are relevant to the subject matter of
the hearing
C. Hearing Delay. No hearing
shall be continued to permit the completion of discovery unless due
diligence is shown.
D. Discovery Schedule. At the
discretion of the Hearing Officer, the discovery schedule shall be
set at the prehearing conference. The Hearing Officer may amend such
discovery schedule at the request of a party or on his or her own
volition.
E. Written Discovery. Written
discovery as set forth in the Superior Court Rules of Civil Procedure
is allowed but may be limited by the Hearing Officer.
F. Types of Discovery. Any
other types of discovery as set forth in the Superior Court Rules of
Civil Procedure may be allowed in the discretion of the Hearing
Officer.
G. Discovery Disputes.
Objections to discovery requests shall be made pursuant to the
Superior Court Rules of Civil Procedure. If there is a dispute
between the Parties relating to a Party’s failure to respond to
discovery, the Party requesting the discovery shall comply with file
a Motion to Compel Discovery with the Hearing Officer.
H. A Party is not required to
file discovery responses with the Hearing Officer unless otherwise
ordered by the Hearing Officer.
1.15.8 Subpoenas
Upon application of any
Party, subpoenas requiring the attendance and testimony of witnesses
and to compel the production and examination of papers, books,
accounts, documents, records, certificates and other evidence that
may be necessary or proper for the determination and decision of any
question before the forum may be issued by the Director upon
submission to the Hearing Officer. Except as may be otherwise
provided by law, including, without limitation, the provisions of
R.I. Gen. Laws § 42-14-11, in cases where a subpoena is not
honored, the Director may elect to make application to the State of
Rhode Island Superior Court for an order to show cause why the Person
who failed to honor the subpoena shall not be held in contempt and
for such further relief as may be appropriate. The Hearing Officer
may, on its own initiative, or on motion of any of the Parties or
witnesses, issue such protective orders, grant such motions to quash
and grant other motions as justice or fairness may require.
1.15.9 Evidence
A. Rules of Evidence.
Irrelevant, immaterial or unduly repetitious evidence shall be
excluded in all proceedings wherein evidence is taken. While the
rules of evidence as applied in civil cases in the Superior Courts of
this state shall be followed to the extent practicable, the Hearing
Officer shall not be bound by the technical evidentiary rules.
Evidence not otherwise admissible may be admitted, unless precluded
by statute, when necessary to ascertain facts not reasonably
susceptible of proof under the rules, if it is of a type commonly
relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in the conduct of their
affairs. The rules of privilege recognized by law shall apply.
Objections to evidentiary offers may be made and shall be noted in
the record.
B. Exhibits, Copies. In all
cases wherein evidence is taken, exhibits may be introduced in the
form of copies or excerpts, if the original is not readily available.
Upon request, a Party shall be given an opportunity to compare the
copy with the original.
C. Administrative Notice. In
all proceedings wherein evidence is taken, notice may be taken of
judicially cognizable facts. In addition, notice may be taken of
generally recognized technical or scientific facts within the Board
or Department’s specialized knowledge; but Parties shall be
notified either before or during the hearing, or by reference in
preliminary reports or otherwise, of the material noticed, including
any report or data required by law or regulation to be filed with the
Board or Department, and they shall be afforded an opportunity to
contest the material so noticed. The Board or Department’s
experience, technical competence and specialized knowledge may be
utilized in the evaluation of the evidence. The burden is on the
Party requesting the Board or Department’s notice to produce
the documents or other matter for the Hearing Officer’s review.
D. Board Employees, Agents and
Consultants. The Board or Department may employ the use of Board
employees, agents, and consultants to assist him/her in the
evaluation of any evidence introduced at the hearing. In the Hearing
Officer’s discretion, these persons may be present at the
hearing.
E. Oath. All testimony shall
be under oath or by affirmation.
1.15.10 Conduct of Hearings
A. General. Hearings shall be
as informal as may be reasonable and appropriate under the
circumstances. All Parties, witnesses and other Persons at a hearing
shall conduct themselves in a manner consistent with the standards of
decorum commonly observed in any courtroom. Where such decorum is
not observed, the forum may take appropriate action including
ejectment or adjournment, if necessary.
B. Duties of Hearing Officer.
The Hearing Officer shall conduct the hearing, make all decisions
regarding admission or exclusion of evidence or any other procedural
matters and either administer oaths to all witnesses or ask the
stenographer to do so.
C. Order of Proceedings.
Except as otherwise required by law, it shall be the usual practice
that the Board or the complainant shall open. Where evidence is
peculiarly within the knowledge of one Party, or in cases in which
contested cases have been consolidated or where there are multiple
Parties, the Hearing Officer may, in its discretion, direct who shall
open and shall further designate the order of presentation.
D. Rights of Parties. Parties
shall have the right to present evidence, cross-examine witnesses,
object, make motions, and present arguments.
E. Record of Proceedings.
1. A complete record of the
proceedings shall be recorded on audiotape, or at the discretion of
the Hearing Officer, by stenographic record. In the event the
Hearing Officer orders a stenographic record, the Hearing Officer
shall declare which Party or Parties shall bear the cost thereof.
Any Party may on his, her or its own initiative order a stenographic
record made of the proceedings. The requesting Party shall incur all
costs associated therewith. The Hearing Officer shall be provided,
at no cost, with the original of the stenographic record and Board
Counsel shall be provided with a copy at no cost. Any Party may
request a copy of the audiotape record of the proceedings. The
requesting Party shall bear the cost thereof.
2. If a Party chooses to
appeal a final Board Decision to Superior Court pursuant to R.I. Gen.
Laws Chapter 42-35 and the Superior Court requires a transcript of
the hearing, said Party shall be responsible for having the
transcript prepared by an independent person or company at his, her
or its expense within twenty (20) days of filing the appeal.
F. Public Hearings. Except as
required by law, all hearings are to be open to the public. In
general, any Person who is not a Party to a proceeding may, in the
discretion of the Hearing Officer, be permitted to make oral or
submit written statements on any issues relevant to the proceeding.
G. Close of Proceedings. At
the conclusion of the evidence, the Hearing Officer may, in its
discretion, permit the Parties to argue orally and/or to submit
written briefs. The Hearing Officer may direct that proposed
findings of fact and conclusions of law be submitted by the Parties.
The record in the proceeding shall close after oral argument, the
deadline for the filing of the briefs, or upon such date as may be
set by the Hearing Officer. No evidence shall be admitted
thereafter, unless otherwise ordered by the Hearing Officer. The
Hearing Officer may in any case require either Party, with
appropriate notice to the other Party, to submit additional evidence
in any matter relevant to the hearing.
H. Waiver of Hearing. In any
proceeding, if the Parties agree to waive the hearing, the forum may
dispose of the matter upon the pleadings and other submittals of the
Parties.
I. Dispositions. Unless
otherwise precluded by law, disposition may be made of any contested
case at any time by stipulation, consent agreement, consent order,
default, or dismissal by the forum. A joint request for a stay of
the hearing for the purpose of preparing documents relevant to the
above shall be forwarded to the forum and may be granted within the
sound discretion of the forum.
1.15.11 Decisions
All decisions rendered by the
Hearing Officer shall be in writing or placed on the record and shall
comply with the requirements of R.I. Gen. Laws § 42-35-12.
1.16 Expungements
A. The Board may consider the
expungement of claims or violations upon written request of a
registrant/licensee. The petition will not be considered unless
submitted on the prescribed form along with the appropriate the fee
pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws. § 5-65-10(g).
B. The Board may consider
evidence, testimony and support, and objections from any interested
Party, including, but not limited to:
1. Volume and/or frequency of
claims or violations;
2. Severity of offenses;
3. Code violations cited;
4. Present record;
5. Time since last incident;
and
6. Other court cases.
C. Matters which have resulted
in a conviction in a court of competent jurisdiction shall not be
considered for expungement by the Board.
D. The Board will not consider
a request for expungement if the applicant has pending actions on the
applicant's registration/license.
E. An administrative hearing
resulting in judgment for the respondent may be expunged.
F. Partial expungement of the
respondent' record may be granted at the Board’s discretion.
G. Upon investigation by the
Board’s investigative staff, an invalid claim, a claim that is
deemed frivolous in nature, or a claim in which the claimant failed
to notify the registrant of deficiencies in a timely manner, may be
expunged.
H. Expungements shall be
scheduled once the State of Emergency has been lifted.
1.17 Default
If any Party to a proceeding
fails to answer a complaint, plead, appear at a prehearing conference
or hearing or otherwise fails to prosecute or defend an action as
provided by these Rules, the Hearing Officer or Board may enter a
default judgment against the defaulting Party or take such action
based on the pleadings and/or other evidence submitted by the
non-defaulting Party as the forum deems appropriate. Challenge to
such an order shall be made as a motion for reconsideration per §
1.15.6 of this Part.
1.18 Disqualification; Incapacity
of Hearing Officer
A. Disqualification. Any
Party may make a motion to the Director requesting that he/she
disqualify or remove the Hearing Officer from the proceeding. The
motion shall be accompanied by an affidavit setting forth the reasons
for the disqualification. In the event that the motion to disqualify
is granted, the Director shall assign another Hearing Officer to the
matter.
B. Incapacity. When the
Hearing Officer becomes incapacitated or unavailable to complete a
hearing and/or render a decision, the hearing shall be conducted,
and/or the decision shall be rendered by a substitute Hearing Officer
appointed by the Director. If any party objects to the substitution,
that party must prove prejudice by presentation of argument and
evidence to the substitute Hearing Officer. If the substitute
Hearing Officer finds that the objecting party will be prejudiced,
the substitute Hearing Officer will issue an order making such
findings and will hear the matter de novo.
1.19 Miscellaneous Provisions
A. Intervention. Any Person
claiming a right to intervene or an interest of such a nature that
intervention is necessary or appropriate to the administration of the
statute under which the proceeding is brought may seek to intervene
in any proceeding. Intervention may be initiated by filing a motion
to intervene with the forum. The motion shall set out clearly and
concisely the facts from which the nature of the movant's alleged
right of interest can be determined, the grounds for the proposed
intervention and the position of the movant in the proceeding.
B. Ex Parte Consultations. No
Person who is a Party to or a participant in any proceeding before
the Board or the Party's counsel, employee, agent or any other
individual acting on the Party's behalf, shall communicate ex parte
with the Board about any matter related to the proceeding, and the
Board shall not request or entertain any such ex parte
communications. The prohibitions contained above do not apply to
those communications which relate solely to general matters of
procedure and scheduling.
C. Consolidation. The Hearing
Officer may, in his/her discretion, consolidate or combine several
matters for purposes of hearing or other proceedings, when he/she
finds that sufficient common issues of fact or law or both are
involved.
D. Plural. Words in the
singular number include the plural, and vice-versa, except where the
context otherwise requires or where a contrary result appears from
necessary implication.
E. Appointment of Board
Counsel. At any time during a complaint hearing, the forum may
request that the Director appoint Board Counsel to prosecute the case
on behalf of the complainant.
F. Statutes. If any statute
has different requirements than those contained within this
Regulation, the statute shall be controlling.
G. Public Documents. The
Board reserves the right to publish in any form any public document.
1.20 Hearings - Public Information
A. Access to public records
shall be governed in accordance with R.I. Gen. Laws § 38-2-1 et
seq. All hearings are conducted pursuant to the Administrative
Procedures Act, R.I. Gen. Laws § 42-35-1 et seq. Except where
the Director, his or her designee or the Hearing Officer directs
otherwise, upon the opening of the prehearing conference all
pleadings, orders, communications, exhibits and other documents filed
with the forum shall become public records. Any claim of privilege
shall be governed by the policy underlying the Access to Public
Records Act, with the burden of proof resting on the party claiming
the privilege.
B. Any Party may request a
preliminary finding that some or all of the information is not a
public document under the Access to Public Records Act. A
preliminary finding that some documents are privileged shall not
preclude the Board from later determining that those documents are
public in accordance with R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 38-2.
C. Claims of privilege shall
be made by filing a written request with the Board. One copy of the
original documents, boldly indicating on the front page, “Contains
Privileged Information – Do Not Release,” shall be filed
specifically identifying the information for which the privilege is
sought, along with a description of the grounds upon which the Party
is claiming a privilege. If a document is filed electronically, it
shall contain a statement that the information has been redacted;
however, the original document must be filed as delineated above.
D. The Board shall retain the
documents for which privilege is asserted to exist in a secure,
non-public file until a determination is made as to whether to grant
the request for privileged treatment.
E. Any person, whether or not
a Party, may apply to the Board for release of the information,
pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws Chapter 38-2, the Access to Public Records
Act.
1.21 Publication of Orders and
Notices
The publication of all orders
issued by the board and notices of hearing shall comply with the
requirements of R.I. Gen. Laws § 5-65-25.
1.22 Equal Access to Justice for
Small Business
A. Pursuant to R.I. Gen. Laws
§ 42-92-1 et seq., the Hearing Officer shall award reasonable
litigation expenses incurred by the prevailing party in connection
with Board hearings, if the Hearing Officer finds that all of the
following conditions are met:
1. That there was no
reasonable basis in fact or law for the Board’s position; and
2. The adjudicatory
proceedings involved loss of benefits, the imposition of a fine, the
suspension or revocation of a registration, license, or permit, or
which may result in the compulsion or restriction of activities; and
3. The prevailing party must
be either:
a. An individual whose net
worth is less than five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) at the
time the adjudication is initiated; or
b. An individual,
partnership, corporation, association. or private organization doing
business and located in the state, which is independently owned and
operated, not dominant in its field, and which employs no more than
one hundred (100) persons at the time the adjudication is initiated;
and
4. The prevailing party must
request reimbursement not later than thirty (30) days following the
issuance of the written order.
B. A request for an award must
be in writing and sufficiently set forth:
1. Compliance with §
1.22(A)(1), (2), (3), and (4) of this Part; and
2. The costs incurred in
defending against the unreasonable adjudicatory proceedings,
including, but not limited to, attorney’s fees and witness
fees.
C. If found to be applicable,
the Hearing Officer shall issue a supplementary order directing the
Board to pay reasonable litigation expenses, as limited by R.I. Gen.
Laws § 42-92-2(6).
1.23 Severability
If any section, term, or
provision of this Regulation should be declared invalid for any
reason, the remaining sections, terms, and/or provisions shall remain
in full force and effect.