810-RICR-00-00-3
810-RICR-00-00-3. Review of a Utility Scale Offshore Wind Project As Described In R.I. Gen. Law § 39-26.1-8 (version Adoption, 04/07/2010 to 04/07/2010)
STATE OF RHODE ISLAND AND PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE REVIEW OF A UTILITY SCALE
OFFSHORE WIND PROJECT AS DESCRIBED IN R.I.G.L. § 39-26.1-8
Date of Notice:
January 21, 2010
Date of Public Hearing:
March 1, 2010
Effective Date:
April 7, 2010
1.0
Authority
These regulations are promulgated by the Rhode Island Public Utilities
Commission pursuant to R.I.G.L. §§ 39-26.1-8 and 42-35.
2.0
Purpose of Regulations
2.1
The purpose of these Regulations is to govern the proceedings before the
Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission to review an application by a
Developer certified by the State to develop a utility-scale offshore wind
farm.
2.2
To the extent not specifically addressed in these Regulations, the
Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure shall govern the
proceedings before the Commission.
3.0
Definitions
3.1
Applicant means a Developer filing with the Commission for an Order
requiring the Electric Distribution Company to enter into a Long-term
Contract with the Developer.
3.2
Commission means the Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission.
3.3
Developer means an entity certified by the Department of Administration
to develop a Utility-Scale Offshore Wind Farm.
3.4
Division means the Rhode Island Division of Public Utilities and Carriers.
3.5
Electric Distribution Company means a company defined in R.I.G.L. § 39-
1-2(12), supplying standard offer service to end-use customers, but not
including the Block Island Power Company or Pascoag Utility District.
3.6
Long-Term Contract means a contract of ten (10) to fifteen (15) years in
duration, or of a term greater than fifteen (15) years upon approval of the
Commission.
3.7
OER means the Rhode Island Office of Energy Resources.
3.8
Party or Parties includes the Applicant, the Electric Distribution Company,
the Division, OER and intervenors as defined by the Commission’s Rules
of Practice and Procedure.
3.9
Utility-Scale Offshore Wind Farm means a wind power project located
offshore in the waters of Rhode Island or adjacent federal waters of at
least one hundred (100) megawatts but not more than one hundred fifty
(150) megawatts, as defined in R.I.G.L. § 39-26.1-2(7).
4.0
Filing Requirements and Service
4.1
Unless otherwise modified in this Section 4.0, the formal requirements as
to filings and service set forth in Rules 1.5 and 1.7 of the Commission’s
Rules of Practice and Procedure shall apply.
4.2
All graphs, charts, photographs, or other documents originally produced in
color shall be provided in hard copy to the Commission in color.
4.3
All filings, including Discovery responses, made by any Party shall be
provided in electronic format, as a PDF, to all members of the official
Service List maintained by the Commission Clerk with no further
requirement that hard copies be provided to a Party unless requested by
2
the Party. However, an original and nine (9) hard copies shall be filed with
the Commission Clerk. All hard copies, except for color copies, shall be
double-sided.
4.4
The Application shall be filed with the Commission with copies to the
Electric Distribution Company, the Division, OER, the Rhode Island
Department of Administration, the Economic Development Corporation,
and the Attorney General on the same day.
4.5
For purposes of determining the timeliness of a filing with the
Commission, a document is received at the time the hard copy is date
stamped with the Commission.
4.6
In the event an attachment to a Data Request exceeds fifty pages when
double-sided, Counsel for the Party shall contact Commission Legal
Counsel to determine whether nine (9) hard copies of the attachment will
be required and if not, the preferred format of delivery.
4.7
Any data request that seeks worksheets with formulae intact shall be
provided in Excel format.
5.0
Intervention
5.1
The Electric Distribution Company, Division and OER shall be mandatory
Parties to the proceedings covered by these Rules and shall simply notify
the Commission Clerk of their respective attorney’s contact information.
5.2
State Agencies seeking intervention may file a Notice of Intervention by
the Intervention Deadline setting forth the interest of the State Agency and
the level of involvement sought by the State Agency.
5.3
For all others seeking intervention, Section 1.13 of the Commission’s
Rules of Practice and Procedure shall apply.
6.0
Application
6.1
The application shall contain the following information:
6.1.1 A complete description of the proposed project.
6.1.2 A description of the legal entity that will enter into a Long-Term
Contract on behalf of the Applicant.
6.1.3 The proposed term of the Long-Term Contract.
6.1.4 A list of each permit or license that will be required and the
identity of the agency responsible for such permitting or licensing.
6.1.5 A time line for permitting, licensing, and construction.
6.1.6 The status of application for each permit or license.
6.1.7 A copy of all filings made with state and federal regulatory
agencies related to the proposed project.
6.1.8 Evidence of material progress toward obtaining real property rights
(site control).
6.1.9 Details regarding a proposed transmission line to the mainland.
6.1.10 All interconnection filings made with any entity related to the
proposed project.
6.1.11 Projected electrical energy production profiles.
3
6.1.12 A proposed initial term sheet for a long-term contract between the
Applicant and the Electric Distribution Company, which shall
consist of the essential terms that the Applicant expects to be
included in a draft Long-Term Contract that would be subject to
negotiation with the Electric Distribution Company.
6.1.13 Pricing projected under the Long-Term Contract being sought,
including prices for all market products that would be sold under
the proposed Long-Term Contract, subject to any contract
negotiations between the Applicant and the Electric Distribution
Company.
6.1.14 Economic justification for the proposal, including projection of
market prices over the term of the proposed Long-Term Contract.
6.1.15 A description of the economic benefits to Rhode Island, including
the creation of jobs in Rhode Island.
6.1.16 A description of the potential risks of the project to ratepayers in
the State of Rhode Island.
6.1.17 A description of binding legal commitments relative to the creation
of jobs in Rhode Island and any other economic benefits to Rhode
Island.
6.1.18 The Applicant’s business plan for the project including forecasts of
all expenses and revenues from the proposed project.
6.1.19 The Applicant’s plan to finance the proposed project and any
material progress made toward financing the plan.
6.2
Pre-Filed Testimony from an officer of the Applicant’s company
sponsoring the Application and explaining the specifics of the project,
including the economic benefits of the project to ratepayers and the State
of Rhode Island, and the potential risks of the project to the ratepayers. If
the officer of the Applicant’s company is not qualified to discuss specific
issues, the Application shall include Pre-Filed Testimony of a witness so
qualified.
7.0
Discovery
7.1
Discovery shall be governed by the Commission’s Rules of Practice and
Procedure.
8.0
Motions
8.1
The filing of Motions shall be governed by the Commission’s Rules of
Practice and Procedure
9.0
Public Records
9.1
All documents submitted by the Parties will be considered public
documents under the Access to Public Records Act, R.I.G.L. § 38-2-1
unless such documents are protected from release by one of the exceptions
set forth in R.I.G.L. § 38-2-2 and/or granted protection from disclosure by
the Commission.
4
9.2
All requests for confidential treatment shall be made in accordance with
Rule 1.2(g) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure.
10.0
Hearings and Briefs
10.1
Hearings shall be governed by Rules 1.20, 1.21, 1.22, 1.23, and 1.25 of the
Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure.
10.2
Briefs shall be governed by Rule 1.25 of the Commission’s Rules of
Practice and Procedure.
11.0
Assessment of Expenses
11.1
Responsibility – An Applicant shall be charged with and shall pay the
reasonable costs of consultants or counsel that may be hired by the
Commission and the Division for the proceeding, up to $100,000 for the
Commission and $100,000 for the Division, respectively.
12.0
Final Order on Application
12.1
The Commission shall determine through issuance of a final order within
eight (8) months from the filing of the Application, whether the proposal
is in the best interests of the electric distribution customers in Rhode
Island.
12.2
The Commission may require changes to the Applicant’s proposal as a
condition to a Long-Term Contract as the Commission determines are just
and reasonable.
12.3
If the Commission determines that the proposal is in the best interests of
the electric distribution customers in Rhode Island, the Commission shall
require the Electric Distribution Company to negotiate a commercially
reasonable Long-Term Contract with the Applicant wherein the Electric
Distribution Company agrees to purchase the entire output from the
proposed project, unless otherwise authorized by the Commission.
12.3.1 In determining whether the proposal is in the best interests of
electric distribution customers, the Commission will consider the
following factors:
12.3.1.1
The economic impact and potential risks of the proposal
on rates to be charged by the Electric Distribution
Company;
12.3.1.2
The potential benefits of stabilizing long-term energy
prices;
12.3.1.3
Any other factor the Commission determines necessary
to be in the best interest of the ratepayers.
12.4
To the extent the Application cites significant economic benefits to Rhode
Island that require commitments from the Applicant outside of the Long-
Term Contract to achieve such benefits, and those economic benefits are
ultimately relied upon by the Commission in authorizing a Long-Term
Contract to be negotiated, the Commission may require that appropriate
legally binding commitments be made by the Applicant as a condition to a
5
Long-Term Contract, unless the Commission finds that such commitments
are not necessary.
13.0
Filing of a Contract
13.1
Within three (3) months from the issuance of the Commission’s written
Order, the Applicant and Electric Distribution Company shall file a
proposed Long-Term Contract for review by the Commission.
13.2
If the Parties are unable to reach agreement on a Long-Term Contract
within three (3) months, the Applicant and Electric Distribution Company
shall jointly file with the Commission the terms upon which they can
agree and the terms upon which they cannot agree and their respective
positions on whether or not the terms upon which they cannot agree are
appropriate for arbitration. The Commission will then determine whether
or not to order arbitration.
13.3
Once the terms of the Long-Term Contract are finalized between the
Applicant and the Electric Distribution Company, the Long-Term Contract
shall be filed with the Commission for its review.
13.4
The Commission shall review the Long-Term Contract to determine
whether or not it is in the best interests of the electric distribution
customers in Rhode Island.
14.0
Legal Ramifications of the Application Process
14.1
The Application Process set forth in Rules 1.0 through 12.3 does not
convey a legal entitlement to the Applicant to a Long-Term Contract.
14.2
The Commission will review both the Application and the proposed Long-
Term Contract to determine whether or not each is in the best interests of
the electric distribution customers in Rhode Island.
15.0
Severability
If any part of these Rules is found to be invalid by a court of competent
jurisdiction or its application to any person or circumstances is held invalid by a
court of competent jurisdiction or through a change in State law or Federal
preemption, the invalidity does not affect other provisions or applications of the
Rules which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and
to this end, the provisions of these Rules are severable.
6