00-0310
Summary Information Not Available
Cite as La. Att'y Gen. Op. No. 00-0310
October 6, 2000
OPINION 00-310
Mr. Renford C. Rodgers
Justice of the Peace
16 Audubon Drive
Monroe, Louisiana 71203-2703
Dear Mr. Rodgers:
We are in receipt of your request for an Attorney General’s Opinion concerning
the re-drawing of ward lines. Specifically, you ask whether or not the Police Jury
has the statutory authority to change ward lines without the specific approval of
the Louisiana Legislature.
Per our conversation on August 25, 2000, you clarified your request by asking if
the Ouachita Parish Police Jury can re-draw Justice of the Peace ward lines
without the specific approval of the legislature.
For your information and review, please find enclosed Opinion No. 96-266. That
opinion addresses the same question you have presented. The conclusion of
that opinion stated that only the Louisiana Legislature has the authority to redraw
justice of the peace ward lines. Specifically, Opinion No. 96-266 in citing the
case of LeBlanc v. Altobello, 497 So.2d 1373 (La. 1986) quotes:
In LeBlanc the Supreme Court found that, ‘the legislature is
specifically given the authority to make changes relative to justice
of the peace courts’, including such changes as abolishment,
merger, rearrangement or reapportionment…we found clear and
convincing language in the constitutional debates which leads us to
conclude that only a legislative act can change, reapportion, merge,
abolish, etc., a justice of the peace court.
More recently in Miller v. Oubre, 682 So.2d 231 (La. 1996), the Louisiana
Supreme Court confirmed this contention. In Oubre, ordinances enacted by the
St. Charles Parish Council that provided for the redrawing of justice of the peace
and constable courts were at issue. The Supreme Court found these ordinances
to be unconstitutional. Specifically, in referencing Louisiana Constitution Article
V, § 20, the court opined:
90
POLICE
JURIES
–
Powers
&
Functions
La. Const. Art. V, § 20
Only the Louisiana Legislature has the authority
to re-draw justice of the peace ward lines.
Mr. Renford C. Rodgers
OPINION NO. 00-310
Page 2
It is clear that the drafters of the Constitution intended that only the
legislature shall have the power to alter the justice of the peace
courts in any way, including redistricting or reapportionment.
From the language of Opinion No. 96-266, as confirmed by Miller v. Oubre, it is
the opinion of this office that the Ouachita Parish Police Jury may not unilaterally
redraw justice of the peace ward lines. To do so would be a violation of the
Louisiana Constitution, Article V, §20. The authority to redistrict justice of the
peace courts is a power delegated solely to the Louisiana Legislature.
We hope this opinion addresses all of your concerns. If we can be of further
assistance, please advise.
Very truly yours,
RICHARD P. IEYOUB
Attorney General
BY:
___________________________
ANDREW D. BENTON
Assistant Attorney General
Mr. Renford C. Rodgers
OPINION NO. 00-310
Page 3
OPINION NUMBER 00-310
Syllabus
90
POLICE JURIES – Powers & Functions
La. Const. Art. V, § 20
Only the Louisiana Legislature has the authority to re-draw justice of the peace
ward lines.
Renford C. Rodgers
Justice of the Peace
16 Audubon Drive
Monroe, Louisiana 71203-2703
Date Received:
08/08/00
Date Released: October 6, 2000
Author:
Andrew D. Benton
Assistant Attorney General