00-0311
Summary Information Not Available
Cite as La. Att'y Gen. Op. No. 00-0311
October 9, 2000
OPINION 00-311
Mr. Mark A. Pivach
La. R.S. 34:3475(G)
8311 Highway 23, Suite 104
Requires the vote of a majority of the Board of Commissioners
P. O. Box 7125
of the Millennium Port Authority to act upon any matter.
Belle Chasse, LA 70037
La. R.S. 34:3475
There is no statutory authority for creating additional officer
positions on the Board of the Millennium Port Authority.
Dear Mr. Pivach:
Your request for an opinion, on behalf of the Board of Commissioners for the
Millennium Port Authority, has been forwarded to me for response. In your request, you
seek an opinion on two issues:
• Whether the Bylaws (passed by the Commission) “[satisfy] the legal
requirements as mandated by the enabling statutes of the Millennium Port
Authority and the Legislature?”
• “Whether it is sufficient for the ‘majority of the members present’ to decide
matters (other than the selection of the Executive Director), or is the ‘majority
of all members’ required?”
The Millennium Port Authority statutes were added by the Legislature by Acts 1999, No.
1225. The stated purpose of the Legislature in creating the Millenium Port Authority
(Authority) is to “[promote], plan, finance, develop, construct, control, license, regulate,
supervise, operate, manage, maintain and modify offshore or onshore terminal facilities
to be constructed within the jurisdiction of said authority after July 1, 1999, in order to
promote the economic welfare of [the citizens of Louisiana].” La. R.S. 34:3471.
La. R.S. 34:3474 establishes a Board of Commissioners, and provides the method by
which the nine voting and two ex-officio (non-voting) Commissioners are appointed. La.
R.S. 34:3475 provides the duties of the Board and the vote necessary to act upon all
matters.
La. R.S. 34:3475(G) addresses your second request. It provides “All matters to be
acted upon by the Board of Commissioners shall require the affirmative vote of a
majority of the board, with the exception that the affirmative vote of not less than five
commissioners shall be required to select the executive director." “When a law is clear
and unambiguous and its application does not lead to absurd consequences, the law
Mr. Mark A. Pivach
Opinion 00-311
Page 2
shall be applied as written and no further interpretation may be made in search of the
intent of the legislature.” La. C.C. Art. 9.
The clear language of La. R.S. 34:3475(G) requires the vote of a majority of the board
to act upon any matter. There are no apparent absurd consequences reached by this
interpretation of the clear language of La. R.S. 34:3475(G).
The statute makes no mention of the “majority of the members present” as sufficient to
take any action. Also, by requiring an affirmative vote of the majority of the board to act
upon any matter, La. R.S. 34:3475 thereby establishes the quorum necessary for the
authority to hold a meeting and act upon any matter, as one and the same.
In your first request, you ask whether the Bylaws (passed by the Commission) “[satisfy]
the legal requirements as mandated by the enabling statutes of the Millennium Port
Authority and the Legislature?
La. R.S. 34:3475 merely requires that “The board of commissioners shall prescribe its
own rules, which shall be adopted and promulgated.” The law gives no other guidance
as to the content of the rules other than the implied instruction that the rules accord with
the enabling statutes.
An examination of the Bylaws reveals that they do conform with the enabling statutes,
with the following exception. The Bylaws establish four officer positions within the
Board: President, Vice President, Treasurer, and Secretary. However, only two official
positions are established by La. R.S. 34:3475 – President and Secretary. While there is
certainly no threat to public order by adding additional officer positions, there is also no
statutory authority for doing so. Where the legislature sees fit, it has expressly
authorized the appointment of additional officer positions. See La. R.S. 17:3022
(Student Finance Commission authorized to “appoint such other officers and employees
as necessary…”); and La. R.S. 17:2812 (“The board of directors may also elect or
appoint such other officers, agents, or employees as it shall deem necessary or
advisable…”).
As these additional positions are not statutorily authorized, it should be clarified in the
Bylaws that the Board has adopted these additional positions as “unofficial positions”
necessary, in its estimation, to accomplish the purpose set for it by the legislature.
Mr. Mark A. Pivach
Opinion 00-311
Page 3
I trust this opinion has sufficiently addressed your concerns. Please contact this office
should you require further assistance.
Yours very truly,
RICHARD P. IEYOUB
ATTORNEY GENERAL
BY:
_______________________________
THOMAS L. ENRIGHT, JR.
ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL
TLE/dsc
OPINION 00-311
La. R.S. 34:3475(G); La. R.S. 34:3475
Requires the vote of a majority of the Board of Commissioners of the Millennium Port
Authority to act upon any matter. There is no statutory authority for creating additional
officer positions on the Board of the Millennium Port Authority.
Mr. Mark A. Pivach
8311 Highway 23, Suite 104
P. O. Box 7125
Belle Chasse, LA 70037
Date Received:
Date Released: October 9, 2000
THOMAS L. ENRIGHT, JR.
ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL
OPINION 00-311
Mr. Mark A. Pivach
8311 Highway 23, Suite 104
P. O. Box 7125
Belle Chasse, LA 70037
Dear Mr. Pivach:
Your request for an opinion, on behalf of the Board of Commissioners for the
Millennium Port Authority, has been forwarded to me for response. In your request, you
seek an opinion on two issues:
• Whether the Bylaws (passed by the Commission) “[satisfy] the legal
requirements as mandated by the enabling statutes of the Millennium Port
Authority and the Legislature?”
• “Whether it is sufficient for the ‘majority of the members present’ to decide
matters (other than the selection of the Executive Director), or is the ‘majority
of all members’ required?”
The Millennium Port Authority statutes were added by the Legislature by Acts 1999, No.
1225. The stated purpose of the Legislature in creating the Millenium Port Authority
(Authority) is to “[promote], plan, finance, develop, construct, control, license, regulate,
supervise, operate, manage, maintain and modify offshore or onshore terminal facilities
to be constructed within the jurisdiction of said authority after July 1, 1999, in order to
promote the economic welfare of [the citizens of Louisiana].” La. R.S. 34:3471.
La. R.S. 34:3474 establishes a Board of Commissioners, and provides the method by
which the nine voting and two ex-officio (non-voting) Commissioners are appointed. La.
R.S. 34:3475 provides the duties of the Board and the vote necessary to act upon all
matters.
La. R.S. 34:3475(G) addresses your second request. It provides “All matters to be
acted upon by the Board of Commissioners shall require the affirmative vote of a
majority of the board, with the exception that the affirmative vote of not less than five
commissioners shall be required to select the executive director." “When a law is clear
and unambiguous and its application does not lead to absurd consequences, the law