No. 23-82
The Department of Mental Health may discharge persons from its placement program pursuant to discharge procedures and criteria established in Chapters 632 and 633, RSMo Supp. 1981. An individual who meets the criteria for placement in a placement program but not the criteria for admission to facility hospitalization may not be transferred from the former to the latter. The department may not continue to serve persons in a placement program who do not qualify for such treatment.
Cite as Mo. Op. Att'y Gen. No. 23-82
DEPARTMENT OF MENTAL HEALTH:
MENTAL HEALTH:
The Department of Mental Health
may discharge persons from its
placement program pursuant to
discharge procedures and criteria established in Chapters 632 and
633, RSMo Supp. 1981.
An individual who meets the criteria for
placement in a placement program but not the criteria for admission
to facility hospitalization may not be transferred from the former
to the latter.
The department may not continue to serve persons in
a placement program who do not qualify for such treatment.
April 5, 1982
OPINION NO. 23
Paul R. Ahr, Ph.D., M.P.A., Director
Department of Mental Health
2002 Missouri Boulevard
Jefferson City, Missouri
65101
Dear Dr. Ahr:
Fl LED
This is in response to your request for an opinion as follows:
1.
May the Department of Mental Health
discharge persons from its pla'cement program?
2.
If the Department of Mental Health
can discharge clients from its placement pro-
gram, what criteria may the Department use to
discharge the clients?
3.
May a Department facility refuse to
admit a placement client who does not meet
facility admission criteria while continuing
to meet criteria for receiving placement sup-
port and services?
4.
May the Department continue to serve,
through the placement program, persons who
could not meet the current criteria for the
placement program?
Paul R. Ahr. Ph.D., M.P.A., Director
For foundat.ional purposes, it is necesasary to examine per-
tinent statutory enactments relating to your question.
Section
630.605, RSMo Supp. 1981, directs the department to establish a
placement program "for persons affected by a mental disorder,
mental illness, mental retardation, developmental disability or
alcohol or drug abuse."
This section allows the department to
"utilize residential facilities, day programs and specialized
services which are designed to maintain a person who is accepted
in the placement program in the least restrictive environment in
accordance with the person's individualized treatment, habilita-
tion or rehabilitation plan."
The department is further directed
to "license, certify and fund, subject to appropriations, a con-
tinuum of facilities, programs and services short of admission to
a department facility to accomplish this [statutory] purpose."
[Emphasis added.]
Section 630.610.1, RSMo Supp. 1981, provides that a person
residing in a state mental health facility may be referred for
placement by the head of that facility.
If the patient is accepted
and placed "then the patient or resident shall be considered as
discharged as a patient or resident of the facility and reclassi-
fied as a client of the department."
Section 630.610.2, RSMo Supp.
1981, provides that any person, or his authorized representative
if he is a minor or has been declared incompetent by a court, "may
apply for placement of the person under this chapter." Section
630.610.3, RSMo Supp. 1981, states that if the department "finds
the application [for placement] ... -appropriate after review, it
shall provide for or arrange for a comprehensive evaluation and
the preparation of an individualized treatment, habilitation or
rehabilitation plan of the person seeking to be placed,
"
to determine if specified criteria are met.
•
Sections 630.615 through 630.660, RSMo Supp. 1981, detail the
criteria for admitting an individual to a placement program, the
procedure by which such a placement is to be effectuated, and
matters pertaining or relating thereto.
The genesis of your opinion request appears to be the fact
that while Sections 630.605 through 630.660, RSMo Supp. 1981,
provide detailed procedures for transferring a patient from a
state mental health facility to a placement program, these sections
do not establish necessary steps for discharging a person from the
placement program.
We note that there are statutory prov1s1ons relating to the
discharge of patients from state mental health facilities and from
state mental retardation facilities.
Section 632.150, RSMo Supp.
1981, provides that a voluntary patient at a state mental health
-2-
Paul R. Ahr, Ph.D., M.P.A., Director
facility may request his own release and "shall be released imme-
diately; ... [unless] the head of the facility determines that he
is mentally disordered and, as a result, presents a likelihood of
serious physical harm to himself or others, .
"
See also,
Section 632.155, RSMo Supp. 1981, (release of voluntary minor
patients).
Section 632.175.1, RSMo Supp. 1981, states that the head of
each mental health facility shall review each patient at least
every 180 days:
for the purpose of determining whether the
patient needs further hospitalization or
should be released.
If, as a result of such
review, it is determined that inpatient care,
treatment and rehabilitation are no longer
appropriate, the head of the facility shall
discharge, or initiate proceedings to dis-
charge, the patient.
If a patient meets the
criteria for placement, the head of the fa-
cility shall refer him for placement.
Section 633.125.1, RSMo Supp. 1981, provides that a resident
admitted to a mental retardation facility:
shall be discharged immediately when the person
who applied for his admission requests the re-
lease orally, in writing or otherwise from the
head of the mental retardation facility; except,
that if the head of the mental retardation facil-
ity regards the resident as presenting a likeli-
hood of serious physical harm to himself or others,
the head of the facility may initiate involun-
tary detention procedures pursuant to chapter
632, RSMo, if appropriate, or any individual,
including the head of the facility or the men-
tal health coordinator may initiate guardian-
ship proceedings and, if,appropriate, obtain
an emergency commitment order pursuant to
chapter 475, RSMo.
Section 633.125.2, RSMo Supp. 1981, requires that a resident
of a mental retardation facility be discharged:
if it is determined in a comprehensive evalua-
tion or periodic review that the person is not
mentally retarded or developmentally disabled,
and if the resident, parent, if a minor, or
•
-3-
•
Paul R. Ahr, Ph.D., M.P .A., Director
guardian consents to the discharge.
If consent
is not obtained, the head of the facility shall
initiate appeal proceedings under section 633.
135, before a resident can be discharged.
Section 633.130.1, RSMo Supp. 1981, requires that the head of
each mental retardation facility review the condition and status
of each resident thereof every 180 days "for the purpose of deter-
mining whether the resident needs further residential habilitation,
placement in the least restrictive environment or discharge."
Section 633.130.2 mandates that the head of the mental retardation
facility initiate any necessary proceedings to discharge "any
resident whose continued residential habilitation is no longer
appropriate."
Section 633.135, RSMo Supp. 1981, sets forth, in detail, the
criteria and procedure required for the discharge of a resident
from a mental retardation facility when such discharge is not con-
sented to by the resident or his authorized legal representative.
In O'Connor v. Donaldson, 422 U.S. 563, 45 L.Ed.2d 396, 95
S.Ct. 2486 (1975), the United States Supreme Court concluded that
a state may not confine in a mental health facility even the
mentally ill if they are not dangerous and if they can live safely
in freedom.
See also, Parham v. J.R., 422 U.S. 584, 61 L.Ed.2d
101, 99 S.Ct.249T"(T979).
--
In response to your first two questions, we conclude that the
department may discharge persons from its placement program; the
criteria to be used in determining when discharge from such programs
is appropriate is found in the applicable statutes in Chapter 632
and 633, RSMo Supp. 1981.
We find that Chapters 630 through 633
comprehensively and completely deal with the mental health system
of this state.
Consequently, these chapters are to be read together.
Although there is no specific provision for discharge found in the
placement program sections of Chapter 630, we believe the discharge
provisions found in Chapters 632 and 633 establish the necessary
procedures and criteria to be used'in discharging a person from a
placement program.
We believe that the absence of discharge
procedure provisions in Chapter 630 relating to placement programs
was not an omission on the part of the legislature, but rather an
indication that the applicable discharge provisions of Chapters
632 and 633 were to apply.
In response to question three, we find that a department
facility may refuse to admit a placement client who does not meet
facility admission criteria while continuing to meet criteria for
receiving placement support and services.
Axiomatically, placement
-4-
•
Paul R. Ahr, Ph.D., M.P.A., Director
programs, which are generally residential facilities, provide a
less restrictive environment for those in need of state mental
health services than a department facility.
The statutes make it
clear that the criteria for placement are different than the
criteria for admission to a department facility.
Cf. Sections
630.610, 632.105 and 633.120.
Section 630.605, RSMo Supp. 1981, provides:
The department shall establish a place-
ment program for persons affected by a mental
disorder, mental illness, mental retardation,
developmental disability or alcohol or drug
abuse.
The department may utilize residential
facilities, day programs and specialized ser-
vices which are designed to maintain a person
who is accepted in the placement program in
the least restrictive environment in accor-
dance with the person's individualized treat-
ment, habilitation or rehabilitation plan.
The department shall license, certify and
fund, subject to appropriations, a continuum
of facilities, programs and services short of
admission to a department facility to accom-=-
plish this-purpose.
[Emphasis adde~]
Since Missouri law requires an individual to be treated in the least
restrictive environment, and the criteri'a for admission to a
placement program are different from the criteria for admission to
a department facility, if an individual meets the criteria for
admission to a placement program, and not a department facility,
the department may refuse to admit such an individual to a facility
while caring for him in a placement program.
In response to your final question, we believe that the
department may not continue to serve, on a residential basis,
persons who do not meet the current criteria for placement programs.
We emphasize, in responding to this question, that we assume that
prior to any discharge the appropriate professionals must deter-
mined that such discharge is consistent with the applicable dis-
charge statutes.
CONCLUSION
It is our opinion that the Department of Mental Health may
discharge persons from its placement program pursuant to discharge
procedures and criteria established in Chapters 632 and 633, RSMo
Supp. 1981.
-5-
Paul R. Ahr., Ph.D., M.P.A., Director
It is further our opinion that an individual who meets the
criteria for placement in a placement program but not the criteria
for admission to facility hospitalization may not be transferred
from the former to the latter.
Finally, it is our opinion that the Department of Mental
Health may not continue to serve persons in a placement program
who do not qualify for such treatment in accordance with Section
630.610, RSMo Supp. 1981.
HN ASHCROFT
Attorney General
-6-