45-262
Schools
Cite as N.D. Op. Att'y Gen. 45-262
OPINION
45-262
August 25, 1945 (OPINION)
SCHOOLS
RE: Teachers - Wearing Religious Garbs
This will acknowledge your letter of August 23, 1945, in which you
refer to a news release reporting the ruling of Arthur E. Thompson,
superintendent of public instruction, to the effect that the wearing
of a religious garb is not a bar to teaching in the public schools of
North Dakota. You want to know whether, in our estimation, this
ruling is correct and whether we concur with Mr. Thompson in that
ruling.
Mr. Thompson's ruling is based upon a supreme court opinion rendered
on April 2, 1936, in the case of G. Gerhardt v. Etheline Heid, found
in Volume 66 N.D., on page 444, 267 N.W. 127. That decision holds
that the employment of nuns, members of a religious society of the
Roman Catholic Church, who are duly qualified as teachers under the
laws of this state, does not violate the state constitution.
(Sections 147 or 152). It further holds that the employment of those
who possess the legal qualifications to teach in any school is a
matter for the directors of the school district to determine; that
the fact that a teacher in the public schools of North Dakota, who is
a member of a religious order, wears the habit of the order while
engaged in teaching and contributes a portion of her earnings to the
order, standing alone, cannot be said to make the school a sectarian
school, to remove the school from the absolute control of the state,
or to place the school under sectarian control.
It is, therefore, the opinion of this office that the news release to
which your refer of Arthur E. Thompson, superintendent of public
instruction, is correct and is in accordance with the decision above
referred to, and constitutes the law of this state.
NELS G. JOHNSON
Attorney General